The viral CEO pay meme, tested
A forwarded list names familiar charities beside startling pay figures. We checked what the current returns say, then asked what those figures can actually tell us.
By the CharitySense Data team
Published Updated
01/forwarded claim has
The forwarded claim has a date problem
A recurring social post has named a former American Red Cross chief executive and claimed that only nine cents of each donated dollar helps people. PolitiFact rated that 2018 version false in 2019. The Red Cross also published a response in 2019. We do not need to turn either account into a timeless claim about program spending. The name in the post was already out of date.
The harder question is what readers can learn from a current return. A compensation entry has a person, a title, a tax year, and several pay components. Removing any of those details makes a memorable meme easier to share and harder to evaluate.
02/median
The median is for a listed person, not every CEO
We read the latest full Form 990 for 485,109organizations. Almost all list at least one person, but only 238,016 have a positive compensation entry. For each of those organizations, we took the largest positive amount among its listed people. The median is $108,882. The 90th percentile is $455,146; the 99th is $2,669,649. 8,739 organizations have a highest listed amount of at least $1 million, or 3.7% of the positive-pay group.
These people include officers and directors, along with trustees and certain highly compensated employees. The highest listed person need not be the chief executive. We add three components that the form reports for each person: pay from the filing organization, pay from related organizations, and other compensation. The result is reported total compensation, not a base salary or take-home pay. Another 247,093 full returns have no positive listed amount; excluding them is why $108,882 must never be described as the median for all nonprofits. An absent positive entry does not mean the organization has no paid staff.
A large number on a forwarded list is worth checking. The first question is whose number it is, and which parts of pay it includes.
A narrower title search finds 54,866 positive entries explicitly labeled CEO or chief executive officer. Their median reported total is $245,502. This is not a census of CEOs: organizations use titles such as president or executive director, and a transition can put two CEOs on one return. Our broader compensation analysisexplores the title problem in more detail.
03/Scale changes the comparison
Scale changes the comparison
Absolute compensation rises across revenue bands in the positive-pay group. The median highest listed amount is $64,890among organizations reporting $100,000 to under $1 million in revenue, and $2.33 million among those reporting at least $1 billion. That says something about the spread of organizations in these bands. It does not establish what any individual ought to earn.
Median highest listed compensation rises with revenue
| label | filers | paid | median | p90 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under $100K | 79,272 | 15,949 | 26,590 | 353,794 |
| $100K to $1M | 251,041 | 107,043 | 64,890 | 195,900 |
| $1M to $10M | 106,156 | 80,266 | 147,848.5 | 372,963 |
| $10M to $100M | 28,269 | 26,077 | 323,730 | 954,081 |
| $100M to $1B | 4,765 | 4,560 | 943,053 | 3,305,517 |
| $1B or more | 364 | 357 | 2,333,588 | 6,836,352 |
Median highest listed compensation, in dollars, among 234,252 organizations with positive revenue and positive listed pay on their latest full returns. The revenue bands are mutually exclusive. Hover for the median and group size; select a bar for the 90th percentile and the full band count.
Many returns have no positive entry, especially at the smallest revenue levels. The chart therefore compares selected paying groups, not every organization in each band. Some top entries include pay from a related organization, so dividing them by the filing organization's revenue would not measure that organization's own compensation expense. It would tell us even less about cents per donated dollar.
04/Three current filings three
Three current filings, three named people
We checked three organizations often brought into charity-pay arguments. Their latest full returns all cover tax year 2024. The people shown below are explicitly identified as president or CEO in those returns. Select a bar to see how its reported total is assembled.
What the three 2024 returns report for their CEOs
| organization | leader | title | year | from Org | related | other | revenue | label | compensation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| American Red Cross | Clifford Holtz | President and CEO as of July 1, 2024 | 2,024 | 950,468 | 0 | 38,607 | 3,916,983,933 | American Red Cross | 989,075 |
| U.S. Fund for UNICEF | Michael J. Nyenhuis | Director, president and CEO | 2,024 | 928,033 | 0 | 48,831 | 835,217,861 | U.S. Fund for UNICEF | 976,864 |
| World Vision | Edgar Sandoval | President and CEO | 2,024 | 573,543 | 0 | 74,387 | 1,423,305,144 | World Vision | 647,930 |
Latest 2024 full Form 990 for each named organization. Values combine reportable pay from the organization and related organizations with other compensation. Hover for the total; select a bar for the filed title and pay components.
The Red Cross return names Clifford Holtz as president and CEO from July 1, 2024, and also lists Gail McGovern as president and CEO through June 30. Their reported totals are $989,075and $735,613 respectively. A single “CEO salary” lifted from that filing could miss the leadership transition. The U.S. Fund for UNICEF lists Michael J. Nyenhuis at $976,864. World Vision lists Edgar Sandoval at $647,930.
The size comparison puts these values in context without judging them. Red Cross and World Vision each report more than $1 billion in revenue; both CEO totals are below the $2.33 millionmedian highest listed amount among positive-pay filers in that band. The U.S. Fund for UNICEF reports $835 million in revenue, and its CEO total is close to the $943,053 median in the $100 million to $1 billion band. The benchmark covers all listed roles and many kinds of organizations. It cannot determine whether a specific CEO is paid appropriately.
05/governance question is different
The governance question is different from the pay figure
Each of the three 2024 returns answers yes to the IRS question about a process for setting top-management compensation. The IRS defines that answer as a process involving approval without conflicts, comparable pay data, and contemporaneous records. It is a self-reported governance disclosure. We have not independently audited how any committee applied its process, and a yes answer is not a verdict on the resulting amount.
The filings let us ask better questions than the meme does: Was the person serving the whole year? Did a related organization pay part of the total? What comparison did the board use? A revenue denominator is useful for understanding scale, but it is not a donation denominator. The overhead questionneeds its own expense evidence rather than a salary pasted into a post.
Behind the Data
We refreshed the figures on September 28, 2026. The sector analysis uses one latest full Form 990 per organization, irrespective of tax year: 485,109 returns. Of these, 485,094 contain listed-person rows and 238,016 contain at least one positive compensation row. We summed the three reported pay components for each row, then selected the largest positive total within each organization. The median and percentile figures use those 238,016 selected amounts, not every filing or every person. A person can appear on more than one filing.
The revenue chart further requires positive latest revenue; it includes 234,252 organizations with positive listed pay. Each bar's median is calculated within that band, and its drill-down displays the 90th percentile. We did not cap compensation, infer a missing amount, or treat the largest row as a CEO. A separate title search identifies rows that literally say CEO or chief executive officer; it misses equivalent roles with different titles.
The named examples come from the latest 2024 full returns of American Red Cross, U.S. Fund for UNICEF, and World Vision. Current people summaries corroborate the filed titles, and governance answers come from those same returns. Most latest full returns in the wider sample are from 2024 or 2025, but some are older. Compensation is reported for a calendar year ending within the organization's tax year, which can differ from its fiscal year. The IRS also applies reporting thresholds to some listed roles. This is a public-filing analysis, not a judgment about what any person should earn.
Sources
- CharitySense analysis of current IRS full-return compensation, people, and governance records, September 28, 2026. See our methodology.
- Latest 2024 organization records: American Red Cross, U.S. Fund for UNICEF, and World Vision.
- IRS, Form 990 instructions, especially Part VI compensation review and Part VII reporting.
- IRS, reportable and other compensation definitions.
- PolitiFact's 2019 fact-check of the 2018 Red Cross post.
- American Red Cross's 2019 response to the circulating email.
Ask the research team
What would you want us to examine next about compensation in the filings? Send us a question for a future analysis.
Final Thoughts
We can check the names and amounts in a forwarded post. The more useful discovery is how much context the post leaves out. A current return identifies who served and which organization reported each part of compensation. It also records how a board says it set top-management pay. Across full returns, the highest listed amount has a wide distribution and is often not a CEO figure at all.
The three named filings offer concrete examples, not a verdict on the entire sector. We would read a leader's role and compensation alongside the organization's work before deciding what the number means. The form gives us a place to start that conversation with evidence.
About the author
The CharitySense Data team
Research team
We read public nonprofit filings and other sources to understand how the sector works. This blog shares what we find, along with the limits of the evidence. Each article explains how its figures were measured and cites the records or primary sources behind them.