How to evaluate a nonprofit before you donate
We revisited the American Red Cross's latest Form 990, its public website, and newly available federal-award and screening records. The useful questions changed when the evidence grew.
By the CharitySense Data team
Published Updated
Start here
Key takeaways
- Confirm the legal entity and its EIN first. A chapter, national body, and similarly named organization can have different records.
- Read the filed activity and the current public description together. A website capture is newer, but it is not proof of outcomes.
- Use the rating to prioritize inquiry. In this example, a fresh website capture changed the public-relationship measure from its earlier value, while foreign-activity oversight still merits a look.
- Compare financial figures only after checking the form, tax year, operating model, and what each denominator includes.
01/Start at the profile
Start at the profile header
Names repeat. National charities have local chapters, unrelated groups can have nearly identical names, and an organization may appear in more than one filing context. Start at the CharitySense search with the organization's name, a cause, or, best of all, its nine-digit Employer Identification Number (EIN). Then confirm that the name, location, and mission match the organization you meant to investigate.
Use the American Red Cross profile as the worked case. Its header identifies EIN 53-0196605, a Form 990 context and a latest Form 990 for tax year 2024, ending June 30, 2025. Recomputing the current rating from that filing and the September 2026 captured public website evidence yields 80, Strong. The separate Form 990-T addresses unrelated business income; it should not be mistaken for another Form 990 assessment of the same activities.
02/Read the Overview
Read the Overview
The top of a profile now leads with an Overview. Read the mission, the organization's reported current-year activity, any listed programs or campaigns, and, where available, its operating model and captured official-site context. On the Red Cross profile, that establishes disaster response, blood services, training, international aid, and support for military families before you ever interpret a financial ratio.
Check those filed descriptions against the organization's ownmission and values and disaster-relief information. The comparison keeps current public claims and filed activity in the same view.
The revenue mix changes how we read the case. The 2024 filing reports$2.48 billion in program-service revenue out of$3.92 billion in total revenue, or 63.3%. Blood services and training are part of the organization's mission, but their earned revenue means a donations-only comparison would mislead. Compare the Red Cross with operators that perform similar work, not with a grantmaking foundation whose revenue is mostly contributions.
Use the overview to ask a practical question: does this look like the work I intend to support? A filing records programs and spending. The nonprofit's website adds current context. Seek separate outcome evidence before you treat either source as proof of results.
1. Confirm the record
Match the EIN, filing years, and form context. Similar names and local chapters can point to a different organization.
2. Read the Overview
Use the mission, recent filed activity, programs, operating model, and official-site context to understand what the organization says it does.
3. Start with The Verdict
The Verdict gives you the plain-language bottom line, then shows the rating and the signals that deserve a closer look.
4. Open detail only when needed
Each signal and statistic can take you to its evidence. You do not have to read every filing section.
Open American Red Cross and notice the form context and overview before opening the rating.
03/Read The Verdict then
Read The Verdict, then use the rating
Immediately below Overview, The Verdict gives you the shortest useful answer. On the Red Cross profile, the recomputed verdict is Strong. The current public-website capture supplies public-relationship evidence that the older article lacked. The questions now worth pursuing include fundraising efficiency and what Schedule F says about oversight of activity outside the United States.
Read the bottom line as an orientation, not the final answer. It tells you whether there is an obvious reason to continue and what to inspect next. If it raises no question that matters to your decision, the profile may have answered your initial question. For a consequential gift, keep going to the underlying record.
The Rating breakdown explains how the score is built. In this case, the Live Rating is 80 from 25 measures in five weighted categoriesunder the current Form 990 rating method. Scores are computed from available filing and website evidence, so the mix can change with new captures. You can open it when you want the mechanics; you do not need to audit every measure before using the Verdict.
| name | score | weight | question |
|---|---|---|---|
| Financial efficiency | 76 | 40 | How do filed resources reach reported work? |
| Transparency and controls | 80 | 30 | Which public and filed controls can we inspect? |
| Accountability | 83 | 20 | What does the organization report about oversight? |
| Sustainability | 73 | 5 | How durable does the balance sheet look? |
| Growth | 100 | 5 | How have filed activity and capacity changed? |
Financial efficiency: How do filed resources reach reported work? It carries 40% of this Form 990 rating.
Source: the Red Cross's tax-year 2024 Form 990, CharitySense's published rating method, and a public-website capture from September 2026. Recomputed September 25, 2026. Select a bar for its question and weight.
| What it helps you understand | A weak result should make you ask | |
|---|---|---|
| Financial Efficiency40% weight · 76 in the worked case | Whether filed resources appear to reach the reported work, including program spending, deployment, and fundraising efficiency | Did program spending or mission deployment fall? Is fundraising unusually expensive, and is there a credible reason? |
| Transparency & Controls30% weight · 80 in the worked case | Whether the public record reports relationship disclosures and the controls that make oversight inspectable | Are related organizations, transactions, or key policies unclear or unreported? What evidence would resolve that? |
| Accountability20% weight · 83 in the worked case | Reported governance, board independence, and filing controls | Do filing checks fail, board independence look weak, or expected controls go unreported? |
| Sustainability5% weight · 73 in the worked case | Whether reserves, liabilities, and operating trends suggest resilience or fragility | Are reserves very thin, liabilities rising, or annual results deteriorating over time? |
| Growth5% weight · 100 in the worked case | The recent direction of filed activity and financial capacity | Did revenue or spending change abruptly, and can the organization explain the source, capacity, and consequences? |
04/Use Key Signals
Use Key Signals to decide what to inspect
Key Signals keep the next step simple: they identify the few facts worth opening, rather than asking you to work through an entire filing. On the Red Cross profile, the visible examples are fundraising efficiency scored 30, foreign-activity oversight scored 38, and the operating-reserve ratio scored 53. Open only the signal that could change your decision.
- Fundraising efficiency: the recomputed measure is $6.73 raised per dollar of fundraising expense and scores 30. This is contributions divided by filed fundraising expense, not a cost-per-dollar figure. Ask how the mix of fundraising methods compares with organizations doing similar work.
- Foreign-activity oversight: the current measure scores 38. Three of eight monitored practices are reported in the filing. Schedule F includes 49 foreign-organization grant rowsand $27.5 million of reported foreign grants. The unreported controls are a disclosure question, not proof they do not exist.
- Total-asset coverage ratio: the recomputed measure scores 53. Its underlying ratio is 1.54, against a 1.41 median among 8,175 Form 990 filers in its 2024, over-$50-million revenue peer band. The policy divides year-end assets by annual expense; that is not the same as liquid cash reserves. Ask which assets could actually support emergency operations.
One correction to the earlier version of this guide matters: the public-relationship measure now scores 100, after the September 4, 2026 website capture. We should not repeat an old zero after the evidence changed. A website score describes what the captured pages reveal; the filing remains the source for filed relationships and transfers.
05/Go deeper only when
Go deeper only when you need an answer
Details is there when you need it, not as homework. Pick the row below that matches your question. Each section opens the relevant filed evidence and, where available, official-website context.
| How to use it | Example that should prompt a question | |
|---|---|---|
| Score | Open each weighted category, measure, and control to trace the Live Rating to filed evidence. | A low-scoring metric, especially one that repeats across years, without a clear explanation. |
| Money flows | Read revenue, expenses, assets, liabilities, grants, and the Sankey as a map of reported money. Seek outcome evidence separately. | Mission deployment falls while fundraising cost climbs, or a sharp shift in revenue has no evident source. |
| Leadership & pay | See reported top compensation, people listed, and the filing's pay-setting controls. | A large or abrupt pay change without a reported process or context. Read the role, scale, and pay-setting evidence. |
| Governance & oversight | Inspect board independence, reported policies, and filing controls. | Few independent directors, unreported conflict or whistleblower controls, or governance disclosures that disappear. |
| What its programs report | Compare the organization's filed accomplishments and program spending with the work you mean to support. | Very broad claims paired with little specific program narrative or outcomes worth examining. |
| Consistency Checks | Open any current filing check that did not pass, then see whether the pattern repeats in history. | A reconciliation failure that recurs from year to year or grows more material. |
| What the schedules disclose | Read form schedules for detail such as foreign activity, grants, executive pay, and other disclosures. | Large grants, foreign transfers, or compensation disclosures that need a clearer purpose or counterparty. |
| Filing history | Compare multiple annual filings before treating the latest year as the whole story. | Missing periods, abrupt reversals, or persistent weak results that a single current-year score obscures. |
| Connected Organizations | Follow filed money flows and structural relationships with named counterparties. | A material transfer to a related organization without enough disclosed purpose or relationship context. |
| Official website evidence | Use captured official-site programs, locations, and claims as current context beside the filing. | A prominent website claim that is difficult to reconcile with the recent filed record. |
The profile is meant to answer a specific question quickly. Open a surprising metric and its cited evidence; leave the rest closed unless it changes what you need to know.
The CharitySense methodology explains how the profile compiles source material and applies the rating inputs. Use it when a metric's definition affects your decision.
The Red Cross record illustrates how fast a focused check can be. Open leadership and pay to see a highest listed total compensation of $989,075among 26 Form 990 Part VII rows and 6 of 6reported pay-setting controls. Looking across the available records, we find 27 distinct people, a different count with a different denominator. Open governance for 10 of 12 independent board members and 9 of 9 reported filing controls. Open consistency checks for 43 of 44 current checks passing. Use only the link that answers your question.
In the Red Cross case, Money flows summarizes 76.8% mission deployment under the rating method and 90.8% of spending in programs. They use different denominators, so neither should stand alone.
Those two percentages use different denominators. The mission-deployment measure reflects $2.99 billion in reported program spending against the rating method's definition of available resources. The program-expense share divides the same $2.99 billion by $3.29 billion in total expenses. Neither figure measures whether a disaster response helped the people it aimed to serve. For why a single overhead ratio falls short, read the overhead question.
The same section gives the recent year context. Read the revenue, expenses, assets, and liabilities across multiple filings before treating any one year as the whole story.
Connected Organizations adds a different kind of context: reported transfers and relationships with named counterparties. The Red Cross case lists 16 counterparties with current filed money-flow records, totaling $8.77 million in outgoing transfers in the current relationship view. That view is narrower than all grants or expenses. It includes nonzero flows with a named or resolved counterparty, so do not treat its sum as the organization's total giving.
Newly available records add a useful boundary. Federal-award records link 2,027 awards and 4,735 transaction events across fiscal years 2008 through 2026 to this EIN. Its $1.26 billion net transaction total is a multi-year federal-award measure, not 2024 Form 990 revenue. Contracts, assistance awards, timing, and accounting basis can differ. We use it to ask where the government relationship comes from, not to add it to donations.
IRS status and other public records supply another layer: federal exemption and deductibility are listed, and a 2025 federal audit record reports no findings. Screening reports no confirmed matches in the sources checked, but provider coverage is partial and responsibility status remains unknown. A clear result within partial coverage is a reason to describe the boundary, not to declare that all possible checks have been completed.
06/Discover other nonprofits doing
Discover other nonprofits doing similar work
Scroll to Other nonprofits doing similar work near the end of a profile. Open the organizations that fit your cause and geography. Use it only when you are choosing between options. Start each comparison with its Verdict and Overview, then open a signal or Detail only if it matters to your choice. Return to CharitySense search when you want to widen the comparison.
Compare like with like. A direct disaster-response operator may have a different revenue model, balance sheet, and cost structure than a grantmaker, research institute, local chapter, or advocacy organization. Compare mission, operating model, scale, and years of filings before comparing one ratio. For the methodology behind the live measures, read how CharitySense rates nonprofits and, for the specific limits of overhead, read the overhead question.
07/Ask what the record
Ask what the record cannot settle
A filing shows what was reported, and a website capture shows what was publicly described when we looked. Neither establishes the effect of a particular gift. If a restricted donation depends on an outcome, ask the organization for program evidence and a clear account of what your funds would support.
In this case we would ask how the organization defines outcomes for disaster response and how it monitors foreign grants. Schedule F reports three of eight oversight practices; the 2025 federal-audit record reports no findings. They cover different activities and periods, so neither source cancels the other.
For a grantmaker's workflow, see the grantee due-diligence guide. It covers questions that can change an award or renewal decision.
08/three-step nonprofit vetting routine
A three-step nonprofit vetting routine
- 1
1. Confirm the nonprofit and read Overview
Match the name and EIN, then check that the mission and reported work match what you mean to support.
- 2
2. Read The Verdict and Key Signals
Use the bottom line and rating for orientation. Open a signal only if it could change your decision.
- 3
3. Ask one focused follow-up
Open linked evidence, compare a genuinely similar nonprofit, or ask the organization what the record cannot show.
09/Questions donors ask before
Questions donors ask before giving
How do I know I found the right nonprofit?
Search by EIN when you have it, then match the organization name, location, filing years, and selected form context. This avoids treating a national organization, local chapter, or similarly named nonprofit as the same record.
What should I check before giving to a nonprofit?
Start with the organization's reported work, then open the Live Rating and Details sections that answer your question. Follow the cited evidence for financials, governance, leadership pay, money flows, or related organizations. A headline number cannot answer each of those questions.
What is a bad nonprofit signal to watch for?
Patterns carry more weight than a single signal. Look for repeated filing inconsistencies, unclear related-party transfers, missing governance controls, thinning reserves, rising fundraising cost, or claims that do not match reported programs. Open the evidence and ask for an explanation before you rely on one measure.
Does a Live Rating prove a nonprofit's impact?
A Live Rating prioritizes available financial and governance evidence. It helps you decide what to inspect next. It does not prove outcomes or select the right nonprofit for your gift.
Behind the Data
We checked every figure on September 25, 2026 against records for American National Red Cross, EIN 53-0196605. The latest Form 990, its separate unrelated-business-income return, named financial relationships, federal-award history, and IRS status evidence supplied the filed and public-record facts. A September 4 capture of the organization's public website supplied more recent context. We recomputed the rating with our current published method rather than copying an earlier screenshot.
The latest Form 990 is tax year 2024 and ends June 30, 2025. The percentages above use the stated numerators and denominators. Federal-award transactions span fiscal years 2008 through 2026, not one filing year. The relationship view contains named or resolved nonzero money transfers, not all expenses. Screening coverage is partial. Scores can change; check the live profilefor subsequent data. Lower measures identify questions, not misconduct.
Sources
- CharitySense methodology and rating methodology, for how the dated score was calculated.
- IRS Form 990 instructions and Schedule F instructions.
- American Red Cross mission and values and disaster-relief description.
- USAspending data guide for federal-award definitions and coverage.
Ask the research team
What would you want us to pull from the filings next? Tell us, and a future piece may answer it.
10/Final Thoughts
Final Thoughts
Vetting replaces a vague impression with a named organization, reported work, financial and governance evidence, and a short list of unanswered questions. That record supports a more deliberate decision and tells you when to seek more research.
The Red Cross example shows why we return to sources. New web evidence changed a transparency measure. The Form 990 still anchors money and governance analysis. Federal awards and audit records add context, but they come with different periods and coverage limits. A good donor question is often narrower than “Is this a good charity?”
About the author
The CharitySense Data team
Research team
We read public nonprofit filings and other sources to understand how the sector works. This blog shares what we find, along with the limits of the evidence. Each article explains how its figures were measured and cites the records or primary sources behind them.