{"success":true,"data":{"_id":50262713,"filings":[{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["CHRISTOPHER STEVENS","RODNEY E LOPEZ","DEREK FARIAS","JUAN WILSON","CHARLOTTE ABOTSI","ANGEL ARRAZOLA","DR PHILIP CHAN","DR JOSEPH A CHAZAN","DR LAINA A CROWTHERS","JESSICA DAVID","ELIZABETH DEBS","LISA DECUBELLIS","ROBERT W EDWARDS JR","FRANK EYETSEMITAN","LOUIS GOLDMAN","DILLON M JONES","JAY JOYNES","BILLY KEPNER","BEVERLY LEDBETTER","KATHERINE MESSIER","JANE O' FARRELL","ISABELLA R PORTER","EVELYN RANONE","MEGHAN REGO","MARKEEM V RODRIGUES","ROBERT K TAYLOR","MARY ANN UPTON","HILLIAS J MARTIN JR","AARON PETERMAN","SHIRLEY FUERTES"],"Title":["CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","TREASURER","SECRETARY","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR","CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER","CONTROLLER"],"Hours":[2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,4.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,35.0,35.0,35.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,162524,124617,87814],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,148669,112494,77533],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,13855,12123,10281]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Provide free public library services for all rhode islanders","year":2023,"name":"PROVIDENCE PUBLIC LIBRARY","phone":4014558079,"website":"WWW.PROVLIB.COM","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"AARON PETERMAN","year_formation":1875,"state_legal_domicile":"RI","total_volunteers":40,"tax_period_begin":"2023-07-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2024-06-30T00:00:00","address":"150 EMPIRE STREET, PROVIDENCE, RI, 2903, USA","city":"PROVIDENCE","state":"RI","country":"USA","zip_code":2903},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":27,"Number of independent voting members":27,"Number of employees total":99,"Total Gross UBI":-13810,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":99,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":8827177,"Contributions":{"value":8649093,"Other contributions":1417727,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":70800,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":3207496,"Related organizations":3953070},"Program revenue":{"value":59875,"Total revenue":56047,"Total other revenue":3828,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":114734,"Investment income total":114734,"Net investment gain":0,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":3475,"Other total":0,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":-13810,"Net income from fundraising events":843,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":16442,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":8268071,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":4469058,"Current officers":412528,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":3269930,"Pension plan contributions":133480,"Other employee benefits":377746,"Payroll taxes":275374},"Other expenses":{"value":3799013,"Management services":0,"Legal":10000,"Accounting":42790,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":495965,"Advertising":28753,"Office expenses":99830,"Information technology":254969,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":643653,"Travel":36903,"Conferences and meetings":0,"Interest":1116064,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":289523,"Insurance":105643,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":569026,"BOOKS AND LIBRARY":339659,"OCEAN STATE LIBRARIES":97357,"EQUIPMENT RENTAL AND RE":75501,"MEMBERSHIPS AND SUBSCRI":56509},"All other expenses":105894},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":5222607,"Management And General Expenses":2607824,"Fundraising Expenses":437640}},"Assets":{"value":30719665,"Non-interest bearing cash":187611,"Savings and temp cash investments":10145,"Pledges and grants receivable":668094,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":11039000,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":5067093,"Investments publicly traded":0,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":13747722},"Liabilities":{"value":23588624,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":506418,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":226605,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":22631417,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":224184},"Fund balance":{"value":7131041,"Net assets without donor restriction":7006041,"Net assets with donor restriction":125000,"Unrestricted net assets":0,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.6316596700729832,"percentile":0.505625820692322},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":19.763031258568688,"percentile":0.5947770586896851},"Operating Margin":{"score":0.06333916267907622,"percentile":0.553704246803184},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.7678672277187919,"percentile":0.08344251294177797},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":3.715457329768939,"percentile":0.7552353262026098},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.04534975570480708,"percentile":0.7799249541036176},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.029085564910178628,"percentile":0.44487836771348094},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.07431020477520871,"percentile":0.6953355557104706},"Asset Growth":{"score":0.0870207640742205,"percentile":0.6488394306760603},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.6019603374508541,"percentile":0.6112209804728957}},"source_xml":"202511129349301206_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["ELIZABETH A DEBS","MICAH E SALKIND","JUAN WILSON","CHRISTOPHER STEVENS","DR JOSEPH A CHAZAN","SHARON LLOYD CLARK","ANDREW L CORTES","SEAN C DAGESSE","LISA DECUBELLIS","ROBERT W EDWARDS JR","FRANK EYETSEMITAN","MAIA FARISH","DR KATHLEEN HITTNER","BILLY KEPNER","JULIUS KOLAWOLE","GUY LOMBARDO","SALLY P MCDONALD","KATHERINE MESSIER","JANE O'FARRELL","MEGHAN REGO","BRENT RUNYON","SALLY STRACHAN","ROBERT K TAYLOR","HILLIAS J MARTIN JR","AARON PETERMAN","ERICA BUSILLO ADAMS"],"Title":["CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","SECRETARY","TREASURER","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR","CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER","DIRECTOR OF EXTERNAL RELATIONS"],"Hours":[4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,35.0,35.0,35.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,138500,109588,104296],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,138500,109588,104296],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Library services","year":2020,"name":"PROVIDENCE PUBLIC LIBRARY","phone":4014558079,"website":"WWW.PROVLIB.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"AARON PETERMAN","year_formation":1875,"state_legal_domicile":"RI","total_volunteers":0,"tax_period_begin":"2020-07-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2021-06-30T00:00:00","address":"150 EMPIRE STREET, PROVIDENCE, RI, 2903, USA","city":"PROVIDENCE","state":"RI","country":"USA","zip_code":2903},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":24,"Number of independent voting members":24,"Number of employees total":60,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":60,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":false,"Premiums Paid":false,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":6478555,"Contributions":{"value":6402705,"Other contributions":2910415,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":68983,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":934718,"Related organizations":2488589},"Program revenue":{"value":77146,"Total revenue":{"value":77146,"SPACE RENTAL AND EVENT":73010,"RENTALS AND FINES":4136},"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":311,"Investment income total":311,"Net investment gain":0,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":-1607,"Other total":0,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":-1607,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":7213538,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":3652002,"Current officers":366811,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":2613209,"Pension plan contributions":100933,"Other employee benefits":345879,"Payroll taxes":225170},"Other expenses":{"value":3561536,"Management services":0,"Legal":738,"Accounting":17120,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":525925,"Advertising":0,"Office expenses":296316,"Information technology":53000,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":349619,"Travel":0,"Conferences and meetings":7031,"Interest":728821,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":289601,"Insurance":90093,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":1158590,"RENTAL FEE":776000,"EQUIPMENT RENTAL/REPAIR":195177,"OTHER EXPENSES":96508,"SPECIAL LIBRARY FUND PR":90905},"All other expenses":44682},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":4331369,"Management And General Expenses":2337791,"Fundraising Expenses":544378}},"Assets":{"value":36987936,"Non-interest bearing cash":72139,"Savings and temp cash investments":440650,"Pledges and grants receivable":210548,"Accounts receivable":28578032,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":5171861,"Investments publicly traded":0,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":2514706},"Liabilities":{"value":33091299,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":393126,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":12660397,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":18537776,"Unsecured notes loans payable":1500000,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":3896637,"Net assets without donor restriction":3029721,"Net assets with donor restriction":866916,"Unrestricted net assets":0,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.6004500149579859,"percentile":0.4958836489893904},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":11.761505791931341,"percentile":0.4486207237540047},"Operating Margin":{"score":-0.11344860080681572,"percentile":0.2102674741918108},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.8946511370626358,"percentile":0.06554996206367077},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":5.127572073509559,"percentile":0.8100515757158224},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.04885036995715556,"percentile":0.7625109460246822},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.03077922205685719,"percentile":0.45227981809784223},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.0800608319453079,"percentile":0.7127061011223592},"Asset Growth":{"score":0.14034320265064676,"percentile":0.7662580775574481},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.5423698506831124,"percentile":0.43513046900607416}},"source_xml":"202211369349310861_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["ROBERT W EDWARDS JR","MARIA J R GONCALVES","MICAH E SALKIND","JULIUS KOLAWOLE","CHRISTOPHER STEVENS","DR JOSEPH A CHAZAN","ANDREW L CORTES","SEAN C DAGESSE","ELIZABETH A DEBS","LISA DECUBELLIS","KAREN DELPONTE","FRANK EYETSEMITAN","MAIA FARISH","DR KATHLEEN HITTNER","BILLY KEPNER","GUY LOMBARDO","SALLY P MCDONALD","KATHERINE MESSIER","JANE O'FARRELL","MEGHAN REGO","BRENT RUNYON","SALLY STRACHAN","ROBERT K TAYLOR","JUAN WILSON","HILLIAS J MARTIN JR","AARON PETERMAN","KASANDRA LARSEN"],"Title":["CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","SECRETARY","ASSISTANT SECRETARY","TREASURER","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","LIBRARY DIRECTOR","CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER","CONTROLLER"],"Hours":[4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,35.0,35.0,35.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,140185,107579,88795],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,135444,103941,86000],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,4741,3638,2795]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Library services","year":2018,"name":"PROVIDENCE PUBLIC LIBRARY","phone":4014558079,"website":"WWW.PROVLIB.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"AARON PETERMAN","year_formation":1875,"state_legal_domicile":"RI","total_volunteers":6,"tax_period_begin":"2018-07-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2019-06-30T00:00:00","address":"150 EMPIRE STREET, PROVIDENCE, RI, 2903, USA","city":"PROVIDENCE","state":"RI","country":"USA","zip_code":2903},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":24,"Number of independent voting members":24,"Number of employees total":72,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":72,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":6931345,"Contributions":{"value":6366660,"Other contributions":3568094,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":51200,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":50000,"Grant revenue":441669,"Related organizations":2255697},"Program revenue":{"value":414429,"Total revenue":{"value":414429,"RENTALS AND FINES":325372,"SALES LEASEBACK REVENU":89057},"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":88458,"Investment income total":88458,"Net investment gain":0,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":61798,"Other total":0,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":61798,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":7619243,"Grant expense":{"value":1913726,"Grants to domestic orgs":1913726,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":3244711,"Current officers":336559,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":2297471,"Pension plan contributions":69100,"Other employee benefits":348644,"Payroll taxes":192937},"Other expenses":{"value":2460806,"Management services":0,"Legal":0,"Accounting":0,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":375393,"Advertising":0,"Office expenses":219079,"Information technology":57855,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":252013,"Travel":0,"Conferences and meetings":27476,"Interest":487715,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":592387,"Insurance":80207,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":350320,"EQUIPMENT RENTAL/REPAIR":135553,"OTHER EXPENSES":100911,"OSL EXPENSES":94606,"NEW MARKET TAX CREDIT E":19250},"All other expenses":18361},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":5599360,"Management And General Expenses":1642202,"Fundraising Expenses":377681}},"Assets":{"value":23692802,"Non-interest bearing cash":72550,"Savings and temp cash investments":129041,"Pledges and grants receivable":379195,"Accounts receivable":635152,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":8364335,"Investments publicly traded":11039000,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":3073529},"Liabilities":{"value":17252422,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":424493,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":523671,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":16304258,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":6440380,"Net assets without donor restriction":0,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":3558217,"Temporarily restricted net assets":2882163,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.7348971544810948,"percentile":0.5606909524461666},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":16.857241958160458,"percentile":0.5525323133611176},"Operating Margin":{"score":-0.09924451892093093,"percentile":0.2239080649049999},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.7281714505527881,"percentile":0.08934189891402136},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":3.109600520681648,"percentile":0.719937658881639},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.044172236008222864,"percentile":0.7859223744314539},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.09116917330377766,"percentile":0.6554715891417402},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.09449430429458394,"percentile":0.7510761227162052},"Asset Growth":{"score":0.055403005531826276,"percentile":0.547125498377129},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.5812955464090246,"percentile":0.550289047858934}},"source_xml":"202011929349301696_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["ROBERT K TAYLOR","WILLIAM S SIMMONS","ELIZABETH DEBS","JOAN M CAINE","SHAUN BUCKLER","SAM COALE","JULIUS KOLAWOLE","HOWARD WALKER","DALE THOMPSON","KATHY ELLEN BULLARD"],"Title":["CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","SECRETARY","TREASURER","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","LIBRARY DIRECTOR (7/13-1/14)","ASSOC. LIBRARY DIRECTOR"],"Hours":[4.0,2.0,2.5,2.5,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,34.0,37.5],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,138628,90563],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,126152,83754],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,12476,6809]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Library services","year":2013,"name":"PROVIDENCE PUBLIC LIBRARY","phone":4014558030,"website":"WWW.PROVLIB.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"CARINDA PALUMBO","year_formation":1875,"state_legal_domicile":"RI","total_volunteers":29,"tax_period_begin":"2013-07-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2014-06-30T00:00:00","address":"150 EMPIRE STREET, PROVIDENCE, RI, 2903, USA","city":"PROVIDENCE","state":"RI","country":"USA","zip_code":2903},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":8,"Number of independent voting members":8,"Number of employees total":60,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":60,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":4338924,"Contributions":{"value":3760747,"Other contributions":1307986,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":57160,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":394786,"Related organizations":2000815},"Program revenue":{"value":599869,"Total revenue":{"value":599869,"RENTALS AND FINES":369181,"SALES LEASEBACK REVENU":230688},"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":2678,"Investment income total":2678,"Net investment gain":0,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":-24370,"Other total":0,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":-24370,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":3812625,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":2149146,"Current officers":240984,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":1591643,"Pension plan contributions":0,"Other employee benefits":184010,"Payroll taxes":132509},"Other expenses":{"value":1663479,"Management services":0,"Legal":2115,"Accounting":19750,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":78643,"Advertising":0,"Office expenses":158646,"Information technology":0,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":266535,"Travel":1935,"Conferences and meetings":0,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":500,"Depreciation and depletion":523566,"Insurance":87941,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":453978,"SPECIAL LIBRARY FUND PR":187862,"OTHER EXPENSES":133859,"CLAN EXPENSES":81268,"EQUIPMENT RENTAL/REPAIR":50989},"All other expenses":69870},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":3233008,"Management And General Expenses":535353,"Fundraising Expenses":44264}},"Assets":{"value":16705907,"Non-interest bearing cash":334651,"Savings and temp cash investments":446914,"Pledges and grants receivable":845693,"Accounts receivable":323998,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":3370,"Land, building, equipment":10280693,"Investments publicly traded":0,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":4470588},"Liabilities":{"value":6579532,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":2292902,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":1027017,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":3259613,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":10126375,"Net assets without donor restriction":0,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":9304185,"Temporarily restricted net assets":822190,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.8479742959247237,"percentile":0.6900232009215922},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":84.96175221398879,"percentile":0.8502885472980433},"Operating Margin":{"score":0.12129712343428924,"percentile":0.6578052079624528},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.39384464429258464,"percentile":0.16674512030650587},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":4.3817335825054915,"percentile":0.7846434473215731},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.060113701190124914,"percentile":0.7087881254984623},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Revenue Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Asset Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.7256467763309558,"percentile":0.887477419229687}},"source_xml":"201511359349301221_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["ROBERT K TAYLOR","ROBERT W EDWARDS JR","ELIZABETH DEBS","JULIUS KOLAWOLE","JOAN M CAINE","DR JOSEPH A CHAZAN","SEAN C DAGESSE","LISA DECUBELLIS","KAREN DELPONTE","MAK FALAYE","MAIA FARISH","MARIA J R GONCALVES","JANET S HASSON","DR KATHLEEN HITTNER","GUY LOMBARDO","SALLY P MCDONALD","JOSEPH PARI","BRENT RUNYON","MICAH E SALKIND","WILLIAM S SIMMONS","HILLIAS J MARTIN JR","AARON PETERMAN"],"Title":["CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","SECRETARY","ASSISTANT SECRETARY","TREASURER","TRUSTEE (AS OF 2/17)","TRUSTEE (AS OF 2/17)","TRUSTEE (AS OF 2/17)","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE (AS OF 2/17)","TRUSTEE (AS OF 2/17)","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE (AS OF 2/17)","TRUSTEE","LIBRARY DIRECTOR","ASSOC. LIBRARY DIRECTOR"],"Hours":[4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,35.0,35.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,137160,98357],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,125730,87868],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,11430,10489]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Library services","year":2016,"name":"PROVIDENCE PUBLIC LIBRARY","phone":4014558079,"website":"WWW.PROVLIB.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"AARON PETERMAN","year_formation":1875,"state_legal_domicile":"RI","total_volunteers":6,"tax_period_begin":"2016-07-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2017-06-30T00:00:00","address":"150 EMPIRE STREET, PROVIDENCE, RI, 2903, USA","city":"PROVIDENCE","state":"RI","country":"USA","zip_code":2903},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":20,"Number of independent voting members":20,"Number of employees total":72,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":72,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":4748166,"Contributions":{"value":4255134,"Other contributions":1073381,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":54723,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":50000,"Grant revenue":764869,"Related organizations":2312161},"Program revenue":{"value":494561,"Total revenue":{"value":494561,"RENTALS AND FINES":393709,"SALES LEASEBACK REVENU":100852},"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":4004,"Investment income total":4455,"Net investment gain":-451,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":-5533,"Other total":0,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":-5533,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":5987590,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":3541864,"Current officers":256656,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":1981134,"Pension plan contributions":878134,"Other employee benefits":267230,"Payroll taxes":158710},"Other expenses":{"value":2445726,"Management services":0,"Legal":7112,"Accounting":22850,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":178265,"Advertising":0,"Office expenses":78152,"Information technology":0,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":283792,"Travel":0,"Conferences and meetings":20324,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":626857,"Insurance":93916,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":1070250,"SPECIAL LIBRARY FUND PR":570002,"OTHER EXPENSES":226474,"EQUIPMENT RENTAL/REPAIR":174647,"OSL EXPENSES":99127},"All other expenses":64208},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":4797133,"Management And General Expenses":781344,"Fundraising Expenses":409113}},"Assets":{"value":14822986,"Non-interest bearing cash":186393,"Savings and temp cash investments":131342,"Pledges and grants receivable":21255,"Accounts receivable":350966,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":4772,"Land, building, equipment":10495905,"Investments publicly traded":0,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":3632353},"Liabilities":{"value":8225202,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":4091492,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":707777,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":3425933,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":6597784,"Net assets without donor restriction":0,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":6197938,"Temporarily restricted net assets":399846,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.8011792724618753,"percentile":0.6270109479348763},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":10.400877019307623,"percentile":0.41133471006540917},"Operating Margin":{"score":-0.26103215430968507,"percentile":0.12558738812952713},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.5548950798442365,"percentile":0.12200421806097016},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":2.475618070041536,"percentile":0.6690159104444614},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.0393341895487166,"percentile":0.8108741826194954},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.1259855317023567,"percentile":0.7221129202117221},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.032127267906717306,"percentile":0.5250706146476994},"Asset Growth":{"score":-0.04024460481779492,"percentile":0.18554137893427408},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.5398467888695758,"percentile":0.4279522188600353}},"source_xml":"201830899349300733_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["ELIZABETH A DEBS","MICAH E SALKIND","JUAN WILSON","CHRISTOPHER STEVENS","DR JOSEPH A CHAZAN","SHARON LLOYD CLARK","ANDREW L CORTES","SEAN C DAGESSE","LISA DECUBELLIS","ROBERT W EDWARDS JR","FRANK EYETSEMITAN","MAIA FARISH","DR KATHLEEN HITTNER","BILLY KEPNER","JULIUS KOLAWOLE","GUY LOMBARDO","SALLY P MCDONALD","KATHERINE MESSIER","JANE O'FARRELL","MEGHAN REGO","BRENT RUNYON","SALLY STRACHAN","ROBERT K TAYLOR","ADRIANA I DAWSON","HILLIAS J MARTIN JR","AARON PETERMAN","SHIRLEY FUERTES"],"Title":["CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","SECRETARY","TREASURER","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR","CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER","CONTROLLER"],"Hours":[4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,35.0,35.0,35.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,152210,106686,68428],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,135898,104457,68428],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,16312,2229,0]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Library services","year":2021,"name":"PROVIDENCE PUBLIC LIBRARY","phone":4014558079,"website":"WWW.PROVLIB.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"AARON PETERMAN","year_formation":1875,"state_legal_domicile":"RI","total_volunteers":11,"tax_period_begin":"2021-07-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2022-06-30T00:00:00","address":"150 EMPIRE STREET, PROVIDENCE, RI, 2903, USA","city":"PROVIDENCE","state":"RI","country":"USA","zip_code":2903},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":24,"Number of independent voting members":24,"Number of employees total":94,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":94,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":8598972,"Contributions":{"value":8318484,"Other contributions":4668803,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":33200,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":1139441,"Related organizations":2477040},"Program revenue":{"value":323379,"Total revenue":{"value":323379,"SPACE RENTAL AND EVENT":239094,"SALES LEASE BACK REVEN":69888,"RENTALS AND FINES":14397},"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":-76766,"Investment income total":3684,"Net investment gain":-80450,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":33875,"Other total":0,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":33875,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":8415479,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":4022618,"Current officers":331834,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":3058929,"Pension plan contributions":130199,"Other employee benefits":255548,"Payroll taxes":246108},"Other expenses":{"value":4392861,"Management services":0,"Legal":31764,"Accounting":92419,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":871496,"Advertising":339791,"Office expenses":306585,"Information technology":0,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":343458,"Travel":7293,"Conferences and meetings":0,"Interest":685730,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":272414,"Insurance":102252,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":1314707,"RENTAL FEE":776000,"EQUIPMENT RENTAL/REPAIR":265954,"OTHER EXPENSES":172340,"SPECIAL LIBRARY FUND PR":100413},"All other expenses":24952},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":4727300,"Management And General Expenses":3066923,"Fundraising Expenses":621256}},"Assets":{"value":26808137,"Non-interest bearing cash":82358,"Savings and temp cash investments":82754,"Pledges and grants receivable":838766,"Accounts receivable":6931750,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":11039000,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":5598215,"Investments publicly traded":0,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":2235294},"Liabilities":{"value":20817922,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":574929,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":1791431,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":16951562,"Unsecured notes loans payable":1500000,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":5990215,"Net assets without donor restriction":5390613,"Net assets with donor restriction":599602,"Unrestricted net assets":0,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.5617386722728439,"percentile":0.48640772397348003},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":13.389784565460937,"percentile":0.4875196453138786},"Operating Margin":{"score":0.021338946097277673,"percentile":0.45580381353661},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.7765523579650462,"percentile":0.08219401441744383},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":3.1855747010954456,"percentile":0.7249574042102485},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.03889546869524599,"percentile":0.8131583792704148},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.028085276735093246,"percentile":0.44050305012592106},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.08597877562305146,"percentile":0.7293053377646492},"Asset Growth":{"score":0.11144039646704228,"percentile":0.7097894010558965},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.5771579065006521,"percentile":0.5380707837779626}},"source_xml":"202321289349300222_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["ROBERT K TAYLOR","ROBERT W EDWARDS JR","ELIZABETH DEBS","JULIUS KOLAWOLE","JOAN M CAINE","DR JOSEPH A CHAZAN","SEAN C DAGESSE","LISA DECUBELLIS","KAREN DELPONTE","MAK FALAYE","MAIA FARISH","MARIA J R GONCALVES","JANET S HASSON","DR KATHLEEN HITTNER","GUY LOMBARDO","SALLY P MCDONALD","JOSEPH PARI","BRENT RUNYON","MICAH E SALKIND","WILLIAM S SIMMONS","HILLIAS J MARTIN JR","AARON PETERMAN","KASANDRA LARSEN"],"Title":["CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","SECRETARY","ASSISTANT SECRETARY","TREASURER","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","LIBRARY DIRECTOR","ASSOC. LIBRARY DIRECTOR","CONTROLLER"],"Hours":[4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,35.0,35.0,35.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,143229,108657,79043],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,131015,97517,68817],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,12214,11140,10226]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Library services","year":2017,"name":"PROVIDENCE PUBLIC LIBRARY","phone":4014558079,"website":"WWW.PROVLIB.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"AARON PETERMAN","year_formation":1875,"state_legal_domicile":"RI","total_volunteers":6,"tax_period_begin":"2017-07-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2018-06-30T00:00:00","address":"150 EMPIRE STREET, PROVIDENCE, RI, 2903, USA","city":"PROVIDENCE","state":"RI","country":"USA","zip_code":2903},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":20,"Number of independent voting members":20,"Number of employees total":70,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":70,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":5880907,"Contributions":{"value":5392481,"Other contributions":2792768,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":30800,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":50000,"Grant revenue":457441,"Related organizations":2061472},"Program revenue":{"value":451569,"Total revenue":{"value":451569,"RENTALS AND FINES":356520,"SALES LEASEBACK REVENU":95049},"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":3124,"Investment income total":3124,"Net investment gain":0,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":33733,"Other total":0,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":33733,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":5350413,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":2270602,"Current officers":329316,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":1508580,"Pension plan contributions":79751,"Other employee benefits":209630,"Payroll taxes":143325},"Other expenses":{"value":3079811,"Management services":0,"Legal":20140,"Accounting":17789,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":172607,"Advertising":0,"Office expenses":134377,"Information technology":0,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":282880,"Travel":0,"Conferences and meetings":24775,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":608631,"Insurance":83013,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":1553986,"SPECIAL LIBRARY FUND PR":989052,"OTHER EXPENSES":344632,"EQUIPMENT RENTAL/REPAIR":126041,"OSL EXPENSES":94261},"All other expenses":181613},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":4375563,"Management And General Expenses":612927,"Fundraising Expenses":361923}},"Assets":{"value":15579465,"Non-interest bearing cash":35071,"Savings and temp cash investments":134862,"Pledges and grants receivable":350019,"Accounts receivable":1322947,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":3545,"Land, building, equipment":10380080,"Investments publicly traded":0,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":3352941},"Liabilities":{"value":8451187,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":550776,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":612728,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":7287683,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":7128278,"Net assets without donor restriction":0,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":5258859,"Temporarily restricted net assets":1869419,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.8177991119564041,"percentile":0.6482714105032505},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":14.899525589697257,"percentile":0.5183050642426965},"Operating Margin":{"score":0.09020615357461018,"percentile":0.6059118601400255},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.5424568173554098,"percentile":0.12492564315597485},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":2.9118247507248505,"percentile":0.7058733182721438},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.061851113175749234,"percentile":0.7008347061141942},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.07833566892797424,"percentile":0.6231314283363939},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.06910335493569378,"percentile":0.6784871485400706},"Asset Growth":{"score":-0.022085200404185757,"percentile":0.23893841781504963},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.6294396040197378,"percentile":0.6885832545227035}},"source_xml":"201900799349300305_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["ELIZABETH A DEBS","MICAH E SALKIND","JUAN WILSON","DR JOSEPH A CHAZAN","SHARON LLOYD CLARK","SEAN C DAGESSE","LISA DECUBELLIS","ROBERT W EDWARDS JR","FRANK EYETSEMITAN","MAIA FARISH","BILLY KEPNER","KATHERINE MESSIER","JANE O'FARRELL","MEGHAN REGO","ROBERT K TAYLOR","ADRIANA I DAWSON","ANGEL ARRAZOLA","DR PHILIP CHAN","LOUIS GOLDMAN","JAY JOYNES","BEVERLY LEDBETTER","RODNEY E LOPEZ","MARY INN UPTON","CHRISTOPHER STEVENS","DR LAINA A CROWTHERS","HILLIAS J MARTIN JR","AARON PETERMAN","SHIRLEY FUERTES"],"Title":["CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","SECRETARY","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TREASURER","TRUSTEE","EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR","CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER","CONTROLLER"],"Hours":[4.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,2.0,1.0,35.0,35.0,35.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,155340,121131,82848],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,141857,109155,72720],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,13483,11976,10128]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Library services","year":2022,"name":"PROVIDENCE PUBLIC LIBRARY","phone":4014558079,"website":"WWW.PROVLIB.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"AARON PETERMAN","year_formation":1875,"state_legal_domicile":"RI","total_volunteers":17,"tax_period_begin":"2022-07-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2023-06-30T00:00:00","address":"150 EMPIRE STREET, PROVIDENCE, RI, 2903, USA","city":"PROVIDENCE","state":"RI","country":"USA","zip_code":2903},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":26,"Number of independent voting members":26,"Number of employees total":99,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":99,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":7764095,"Contributions":{"value":7411308,"Other contributions":3184299,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":66701,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":1078696,"Related organizations":3081612},"Program revenue":{"value":297275,"Total revenue":{"value":297275,"SPACE RENTAL AND EVENT":232445,"SALES LEASE BACK REVEN":63078,"RENTALS AND FINES":1752},"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":2086,"Investment income total":3589,"Net investment gain":-1503,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":53426,"Other total":0,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":53426,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":8768272,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":4314158,"Current officers":353578,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":3221981,"Pension plan contributions":124836,"Other employee benefits":343935,"Payroll taxes":269828},"Other expenses":{"value":4454114,"Management services":0,"Legal":41374,"Accounting":72700,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":570266,"Advertising":121126,"Office expenses":146947,"Information technology":0,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":456484,"Travel":53413,"Conferences and meetings":0,"Interest":1032286,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":309069,"Insurance":99240,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":1381091,"RENTAL FEE":776000,"AUDIO-VISUAL MATERIALS":398670,"EQUIPMENT RENTAL/REPAIR":108934,"OSL EXPENSES":97487},"All other expenses":170118},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":4978436,"Management And General Expenses":3165793,"Fundraising Expenses":624043}},"Assets":{"value":31256282,"Non-interest bearing cash":98209,"Savings and temp cash investments":150556,"Pledges and grants receivable":239520,"Accounts receivable":12418535,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":11039000,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":5354580,"Investments publicly traded":0,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":1955882},"Liabilities":{"value":26270244,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":386487,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":2353352,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":23030405,"Unsecured notes loans payable":500000,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":4986038,"Net assets without donor restriction":4524685,"Net assets with donor restriction":461353,"Unrestricted net assets":0,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.5677784630768754,"percentile":0.4876940459023789},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":11.876277756500754,"percentile":0.45162092440742435},"Operating Margin":{"score":-0.12933600116948596,"percentile":0.19663523943587913},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.8404788515793401,"percentile":0.07350102337959435},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":3.5647026004667737,"percentile":0.7473432574972328},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.040979454104525956,"percentile":0.8022829268387979},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.02810187226766437,"percentile":0.4405784570878688},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.07661563037503699,"percentile":0.7024537137747348},"Asset Growth":{"score":0.09939436578717878,"percentile":0.6816063689099583},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.5316054584377023,"percentile":0.40489478505946447}},"source_xml":"202431359349310663_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["ROBERT K TAYLOR","WILLIAM S SIMMONS","ELIZABETH DEBS","JOAN M CAINE","SHAUN BUCKLER","SAM COALE","ROBERT W EDWARDS JR","MAK FALAYE","DR KATHLEEN HITTNER","JULIUS KOLAWOLE","SALLY P MCDONALD","BRENT RUNYON","HOWARD WALKER","HILLIAS J MARTIN JR","KATHY ELLEN BULLARD"],"Title":["CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","SECRETARY","TREASURER","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE (AS OF 11/14)","TRUSTEE (AS OF 11/14)","TRUSTEE (AS OF 11/14)","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE (AS OF 11/14)","TRUSTEE (AS OF 11/14)","TRUSTEE","LIBRARY DIRECTOR","ASSOC. LIBRARY DIRECTOR"],"Hours":[4.0,2.0,2.5,2.5,1.0,1.0,2.0,1.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,37.5,37.5],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,114019,95539],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,113183,87788],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,836,7751]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Library services","year":2014,"name":"PROVIDENCE PUBLIC LIBRARY","phone":4014558030,"website":"WWW.PROVLIB.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"CARINDA PALUMBO","year_formation":1875,"state_legal_domicile":"RI","total_volunteers":29,"tax_period_begin":"2014-07-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2015-06-30T00:00:00","address":"150 EMPIRE STREET, PROVIDENCE, RI, 2903, USA","city":"PROVIDENCE","state":"RI","country":"USA","zip_code":2903},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":13,"Number of independent voting members":13,"Number of employees total":69,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":69,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":4489068,"Contributions":{"value":4129104,"Other contributions":667457,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":76595,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":90450,"Grant revenue":1177933,"Related organizations":2116669},"Program revenue":{"value":384712,"Total revenue":{"value":384712,"RENTALS AND FINES":272796,"SALES LEASEBACK REVENU":111916},"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":3684,"Investment income total":3684,"Net investment gain":0,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":-28432,"Other total":0,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":-28432,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":4550551,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":2615864,"Current officers":222277,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":1928605,"Pension plan contributions":0,"Other employee benefits":306431,"Payroll taxes":158551},"Other expenses":{"value":1934687,"Management services":0,"Legal":1782,"Accounting":20750,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":69124,"Advertising":0,"Office expenses":144746,"Information technology":0,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":258722,"Travel":5202,"Conferences and meetings":0,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":614949,"Insurance":87951,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":640436,"SPECIAL LIBRARY FUND PR":304775,"OTHER EXPENSES":170856,"OSL EXPENSES":82981,"SUBSCRIPTIONS":81824},"All other expenses":91025},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":3865317,"Management And General Expenses":540403,"Fundraising Expenses":144831}},"Assets":{"value":16037546,"Non-interest bearing cash":357128,"Savings and temp cash investments":776762,"Pledges and grants receivable":422542,"Accounts receivable":604976,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":2843,"Land, building, equipment":9682119,"Investments publicly traded":0,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":4191176},"Liabilities":{"value":7029355,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":3191014,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":915101,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":2923240,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":9008191,"Net assets without donor restriction":0,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":7849337,"Temporarily restricted net assets":1158854,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.8494173562718009,"percentile":0.6921686819782008},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":28.50980798309754,"percentile":0.6803024586284331},"Operating Margin":{"score":-0.01369616143039045,"percentile":0.35193029745781207},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.4383061473370053,"percentile":0.15274370609259086},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":3.524308594717431,"percentile":0.7451412708995224},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.04605112655588301,"percentile":0.7764168539232554},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Revenue Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Asset Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.6455984408906132,"percentile":0.7306822297412018}},"source_xml":"201641349349301154_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["ROBERT W EDWARDS JR","MICAH E SALKIND","JULIUS KOLAWOLE","CHRISTOPHER STEVENS","DR JOSEPH A CHAZAN","ANDREW L CORTES","SEAN C DAGESSE","ELIZABETH A DEBS","LISA DECUBELLIS","FRANK EYETSEMITAN","MAIA FARISH","DR KATHLEEN HITTNER","BILLY KEPNER","GUY LOMBARDO","SALLY P MCDONALD","KATHERINE MESSIER","JANE O'FARRELL","MEGHAN REGO","BRENT RUNYON","SALLY STRACHAN","ROBERT K TAYLOR","JUAN WILSON","HILLIAS J MARTIN JR","AARON PETERMAN","KASANDRA LARSEN"],"Title":["CHAIR","SECRETARY","ASSISTANT SECRETARY","TREASURER","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR","CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER","CONTROLLER"],"Hours":[4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,35.0,35.0,35.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,74917,57224,43678],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,70176,53586,40883],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,4741,3638,2795]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Library services","year":2019,"name":"PROVIDENCE PUBLIC LIBRARY","phone":4014558079,"website":"WWW.PROVLIB.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"AARON PETERMAN","year_formation":1875,"state_legal_domicile":"RI","total_volunteers":19,"tax_period_begin":"2019-07-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2020-06-30T00:00:00","address":"150 EMPIRE STREET, PROVIDENCE, RI, 2903, USA","city":"PROVIDENCE","state":"RI","country":"USA","zip_code":2903},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":24,"Number of independent voting members":24,"Number of employees total":60,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":60,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":7535662,"Contributions":{"value":6687498,"Other contributions":3564175,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":0,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":1140503,"Related organizations":1982820},"Program revenue":{"value":309939,"Total revenue":{"value":309939,"RENTALS AND FINES":226685,"SALES LEASEBACK REVENU":83254},"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":538225,"Investment income total":538225,"Net investment gain":0,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":0,"Other total":0,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":6065521,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":3454330,"Current officers":343586,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":2492157,"Pension plan contributions":67643,"Other employee benefits":349340,"Payroll taxes":201604},"Other expenses":{"value":2611191,"Management services":0,"Legal":0,"Accounting":0,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":521851,"Advertising":0,"Office expenses":229728,"Information technology":58435,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":210499,"Travel":0,"Conferences and meetings":28402,"Interest":518493,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":598125,"Insurance":84384,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":356368,"EQUIPMENT RENTAL/REPAIR":137440,"OTHER EXPENSES":103855,"OSL EXPENSES":101323,"AUDIO-VISUAL MATERIALS":13750},"All other expenses":4906},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":3825821,"Management And General Expenses":1843132,"Fundraising Expenses":396568}},"Assets":{"value":33332898,"Non-interest bearing cash":382285,"Savings and temp cash investments":230064,"Pledges and grants receivable":527115,"Accounts receivable":19268568,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":10410148,"Investments publicly traded":0,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":2514718},"Liabilities":{"value":25422377,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":469279,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":440417,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":24011119,"Unsecured notes loans payable":501562,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":7910521,"Net assets without donor restriction":4350787,"Net assets with donor restriction":3559734,"Unrestricted net assets":0,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.6307489496780243,"percentile":0.5053084191955403},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":16.863433257348046,"percentile":0.5526369603599088},"Operating Margin":{"score":0.1950911545661151,"percentile":0.7513238587647572},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.7626812706173942,"percentile":0.08419714273072744},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":5.495471534926678,"percentile":0.8204594787782935},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.028986627859338053,"percentile":0.8652260485351496},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.04473034022573965,"percentile":0.5110274112875653},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.10104460574118149,"percentile":0.7662690856925443},"Asset Growth":{"score":0.12066823302349079,"percentile":0.7294898238686653},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.6511960192933298,"percentile":0.7445649663235796}},"source_xml":"202131379349307038_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["ROBERT K TAYLOR","WILLIAM S SIMMONS","ELIZABETH DEBS","JOAN M CAINE","JOHN S RENZA III","MARY-ELLEN BOYLE","ROBERT W EDWARDS JR","MAK FALAYE","MAIA FARISH","DR KATHLEEN HITTNER","JULIUS KOLAWOLE","GUY LOMBARDO","SALLY P MCDONALD","JOSEPH PARI","BRENT RUNYON","HILLIAS J MARTIN JR","KATHY ELLEN BULLARD"],"Title":["CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","SECRETARY","TREASURER","ASSISTANT TREASURER","TRUSTEE (AS OF 2/16)","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE (AS OF 2/16)","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE (AS OF 2/16)","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE (AS OF 2/16)","TRUSTEE","LIBRARY DIRECTOR","ASSOC. LIBRARY DIRECTOR"],"Hours":[4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,35.0,35.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,125583,97375],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,122287,89706],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,3296,7669]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Library services","year":2015,"name":"PROVIDENCE PUBLIC LIBRARY","phone":4014558030,"website":"WWW.PROVLIB.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"CARINDA S PALUMBO","year_formation":1875,"state_legal_domicile":"RI","total_volunteers":37,"tax_period_begin":"2015-07-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2016-06-30T00:00:00","address":"150 EMPIRE STREET, PROVIDENCE, RI, 2903, USA","city":"PROVIDENCE","state":"RI","country":"USA","zip_code":2903},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":15,"Number of independent voting members":15,"Number of employees total":65,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":65,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":4731804,"Contributions":{"value":4254230,"Other contributions":1262341,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":59614,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":99675,"Grant revenue":706832,"Related organizations":2125768},"Program revenue":{"value":518119,"Total revenue":{"value":518119,"RENTALS AND FINES":411647,"SALES LEASEBACK REVENU":106472},"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":-8439,"Investment income total":7552,"Net investment gain":-15991,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":-32106,"Other total":0,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":-32106,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":5244782,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":2600762,"Current officers":239858,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":1832404,"Pension plan contributions":0,"Other employee benefits":382002,"Payroll taxes":146498},"Other expenses":{"value":2644020,"Management services":0,"Legal":3380,"Accounting":16283,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":139884,"Advertising":0,"Office expenses":183744,"Information technology":0,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":293096,"Travel":8066,"Conferences and meetings":0,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":579937,"Insurance":85531,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":1300818,"SPECIAL LIBRARY FUND PR":770864,"OTHER EXPENSES":381116,"OSL EXPENSES":86100,"EQUIPMENT RENTAL/REPAIR":62738},"All other expenses":33281},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":4261937,"Management And General Expenses":668661,"Fundraising Expenses":314184}},"Assets":{"value":15355625,"Non-interest bearing cash":377197,"Savings and temp cash investments":259039,"Pledges and grants receivable":51717,"Accounts receivable":568273,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":8186,"Land, building, equipment":10179448,"Investments publicly traded":0,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":3911765},"Liabilities":{"value":7978816,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":4368766,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":808629,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":2801421,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":7376809,"Net assets without donor restriction":0,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":6972194,"Temporarily restricted net assets":404615,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.8126051759634624,"percentile":0.6415342817784151},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":13.540568584014462,"percentile":0.4908059451016084},"Operating Margin":{"score":-0.10841066113473846,"percentile":0.21495679664392148},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.5196021653302942,"percentile":0.1304612336599299},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":2.927790897696034,"percentile":0.7070636359171983},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.042510441806732864,"percentile":0.7944486744382424},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.135858970506138,"percentile":0.736662179381166},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.043460830826658456,"percentile":0.5780050735598994},"Asset Growth":{"score":-0.042109393448248635,"percentile":0.18129138306960219},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.5718113015924485,"percentile":0.5223043914836124}},"source_xml":"201721299349302542_public.xml"}],"Latest":{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["CHRISTOPHER STEVENS","RODNEY E LOPEZ","DEREK FARIAS","JUAN WILSON","CHARLOTTE ABOTSI","ANGEL ARRAZOLA","DR PHILIP CHAN","DR JOSEPH A CHAZAN","DR LAINA A CROWTHERS","JESSICA DAVID","ELIZABETH DEBS","LISA DECUBELLIS","ROBERT W EDWARDS JR","FRANK EYETSEMITAN","LOUIS GOLDMAN","DILLON M JONES","JAY JOYNES","BILLY KEPNER","BEVERLY LEDBETTER","KATHERINE MESSIER","JANE O' FARRELL","ISABELLA R PORTER","EVELYN RANONE","MEGHAN REGO","MARKEEM V RODRIGUES","ROBERT K TAYLOR","MARY ANN UPTON","HILLIAS J MARTIN JR","AARON PETERMAN","SHIRLEY FUERTES"],"Title":["CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","TREASURER","SECRETARY","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR","CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER","CONTROLLER"],"Hours":[2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,4.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,35.0,35.0,35.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,162524,124617,87814],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,148669,112494,77533],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,13855,12123,10281]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Provide free public library services for all rhode islanders","year":2023,"name":"PROVIDENCE PUBLIC LIBRARY","phone":4014558079,"website":"WWW.PROVLIB.COM","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"AARON PETERMAN","year_formation":1875,"state_legal_domicile":"RI","total_volunteers":40,"tax_period_begin":"2023-07-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2024-06-30T00:00:00","address":"150 EMPIRE STREET, PROVIDENCE, RI, 2903, USA","city":"PROVIDENCE","state":"RI","country":"USA","zip_code":2903},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":27,"Number of independent voting members":27,"Number of employees total":99,"Total Gross UBI":-13810,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":99,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":8827177,"Contributions":{"value":8649093,"Other contributions":1417727,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":70800,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":3207496,"Related organizations":3953070},"Program revenue":{"value":59875,"Total revenue":56047,"Total other revenue":3828,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":114734,"Investment income total":114734,"Net investment gain":0,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":3475,"Other total":0,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":-13810,"Net income from fundraising events":843,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":16442,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":8268071,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":4469058,"Current officers":412528,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":3269930,"Pension plan contributions":133480,"Other employee benefits":377746,"Payroll taxes":275374},"Other expenses":{"value":3799013,"Management services":0,"Legal":10000,"Accounting":42790,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":495965,"Advertising":28753,"Office expenses":99830,"Information technology":254969,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":643653,"Travel":36903,"Conferences and meetings":0,"Interest":1116064,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":289523,"Insurance":105643,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":569026,"BOOKS AND LIBRARY":339659,"OCEAN STATE LIBRARIES":97357,"EQUIPMENT RENTAL AND RE":75501,"MEMBERSHIPS AND SUBSCRI":56509},"All other expenses":105894},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":5222607,"Management And General Expenses":2607824,"Fundraising Expenses":437640}},"Assets":{"value":30719665,"Non-interest bearing cash":187611,"Savings and temp cash investments":10145,"Pledges and grants receivable":668094,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":11039000,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":5067093,"Investments publicly traded":0,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":13747722},"Liabilities":{"value":23588624,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":506418,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":226605,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":22631417,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":224184},"Fund balance":{"value":7131041,"Net assets without donor restriction":7006041,"Net assets with donor restriction":125000,"Unrestricted net assets":0,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.6316596700729832,"percentile":0.505625820692322},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":19.763031258568688,"percentile":0.5947770586896851},"Operating Margin":{"score":0.06333916267907622,"percentile":0.553704246803184},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.7678672277187919,"percentile":0.08344251294177797},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":3.715457329768939,"percentile":0.7552353262026098},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.04534975570480708,"percentile":0.7799249541036176},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.029085564910178628,"percentile":0.44487836771348094},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.07431020477520871,"percentile":0.6953355557104706},"Asset Growth":{"score":0.0870207640742205,"percentile":0.6488394306760603},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.6019603374508541,"percentile":0.6112209804728957}},"source_xml":"202511129349301206_public.xml"},"sector":"Education","donation_categories":[],"zakat_policy":null},"error":null}