{"success":true,"data":{"_id":311151537,"filings":[{"Organization":{"Hours":[0],"Total Compensation":[0],"Direct compensation":[0],"Other compensation":[0]},"Basic":{"mission":"Provide medical and dental benefits for the exclusive benefit of its members","primary_activities":"Health care benefits - providing health care coverage to participants employed by 14 local school districts and related educational institutions\n\nIn march 2012, the trustees approved a merger of the plan, subject to the consent of the majority of the member districts. The plan subsequently received consents from a sufficient number of school districts to proceed with the merger. Effective september 1, 2012, the plan joined optimal health initiatives to form a state-wide, jointly administered arrangement with northern buckeye health plan and scioto health plan. The three merging plans will operate as divisions, providing local separation of assets and decision making for issues, such as plan design, rates, reserve management, etc. The purpose for the merger is to enhance the independent survivability of the plan from state and federal control by significantly increasing the number of members served on a state-wide basis.","year":2012,"name":"BUTLER HEALTH PLAN","phone":"5132732520","website":"WWW.BUTLERHEALTHPLAN.ORG","type":"990","principal_officer":"STEPHANIE HEARN","year_formation":1985,"state_legal_domicile":"OH","total_volunteers":0,"tax_period_begin":"2012-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2012-09-30T00:00:00","address":"400 NORTH ERIE BLVD STE B, HAMILTON, OH, 45011, USA","city":"HAMILTON","state":"OH","country":"USA","zip_code":"45011"},"Governance":{"501c determination":true,"Number of voting members":7,"Number of independent voting members":7,"Number of employees total":2,"Total Gross UBI":388126,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":2,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":false,"Taxable party notification":false,"Funds to pay premiums":false,"Premiums Paid":false,"Family or business relationship":false,"Delegation of management duties":false,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":false,"Compensation process for CEO":false,"Compensation process for other employees":false,"Changes to organizing documents":false,"Material diversion or misuse":false,"Members or stockholders":false,"Election of board members":false,"Decisions subject to approval":false,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":false,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":false,"Investment in joint venture":false,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":false,"Accountant compile or review":false,"Financial statements audited by independent accountant":true,"Audit committee":true,"Federal grant audit required":false,"Audited financial statements separate":true,"Political activities":false,"Donor advised funds":false,"Conservation easements":false,"Collections of art":false,"School":false,"Hospital":false,"Foreign activities":false,"Foreign office":false,"Gaming":false,"Fundraising activities":false,"Professional fundraising":false,"Loan to officer or DQP":false,"Grant to related person":false,"Business relationship through family member":false,"Business relationship with organization":false},"Revenues":{"value":48129923,"Contributions":{"value":0},"Program revenue":{"value":47741797,"Total revenue":47741797,"Unrelated business revenue":388126},"Investment income":{"value":388126,"Investment income total":388126},"Other revenues":{"value":0}},"Expenses":{"value":52641202,"Grant expense":{"value":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":50677410,"Benefits paid to members Total":50677410},"Salaries":{"value":205600,"Current officers":108191,"Other salaries and wages":72115,"Pension plan contributions":3606,"Other employee benefits":945,"Payroll taxes":20743},"Other expenses":{"value":1758192,"Legal":40664,"Accounting":33300,"Investment management fees":21192,"Other services":54311,"Office expenses":4332,"Information technology":1500,"Occupancy":9978,"Travel":6253,"Conferences and meetings":3568,"Insurance":72182,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":1509088,"VARIOUS":1509088},"All other expenses":1824}},"Assets":{"value":0,"Non-interest bearing cash":0,"Savings and temp cash investments":0,"Pledges and grants receivable":0,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":0,"Investments publicly traded":0,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":0},"Liabilities":{"value":0,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":0},"Form990Details":{"program_service_accomplishments":[{"description":"HEALTH CARE BENEFITS - PROVIDING HEALTH CARE COVERAGE TO PARTICIPANTS EMPLOYED BY 14 LOCAL SCHOOL DISTRICTS AND RELATED EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS"}],"program_service_revenue_detail":[{"business_code":"525100","description":"MEMBER CONTRIBUTIONS","total_revenue":47741797,"related_or_exempt_function_income":47741797}],"functional_expense_allocations":{"current_officers_directors":{"total":108191},"other_salaries_and_wages":{"total":72115},"pension_plan_contributions":{"total":3606},"other_employee_benefits":{"total":945},"payroll_taxes":{"total":20743},"legal_fees":{"total":40664},"accounting_fees":{"total":33300},"investment_management_fees":{"total":21192},"other_service_fees":{"total":54311},"office_expenses":{"total":4332},"information_technology":{"total":1500},"occupancy":{"total":9978},"travel":{"total":6253},"conferences_meetings":{"total":3568},"insurance":{"total":72182},"all_other_expenses":{"total":1824}},"tax_and_disclosure_flags":{"activities_conducted_through_partnership":false,"foreign_financial_account":false,"backup_withholding_compliance":true,"employment_tax_returns_filed":true,"deductible_non_cash_contributions":false,"deductible_contributions_of_art":false,"method_of_accounting_accrual":true,"schedule_o_part_iii":true,"schedule_o_part_vi":true,"schedule_o_part_xi":true,"schedule_o_part_xii":true},"principal_officer_detail":{"person_name":"STEPHANIE HEARN","address_line1":"400 NORTH ERIE BLVD STE B","city":"HAMILTON","state":"OH","zip":"45011"},"audit_financial_statement_detail":{"accountant_compile_or_review":false,"federal_grant_audit_required":false},"related_party_due_diligence":{"officer_entity_with_business_relationship":false,"officer_mailing_address":false,"related_entity":true,"related_org_controlled_entity":false,"compensation_from_other_sources":false,"annual_disclosure_covered_persons":true},"grant_due_diligence":{"grants_to_organizations":false,"grants_to_individuals":false,"more_than_5000_to_organizations":false,"more_than_5000_to_individuals":false},"books_are_in_care_of":{"phone":"5139426262","business_name_line1":"STEPHANIE HEARN","address_line1":"400 NORTH ERIE BLVD STE B","city":"HAMILTON","state":"OH","zip":"45011"},"contractor_compensation":[{"business_name_line1":"ALLIED BENEFIT SYSTEMS INC","compensation":742960,"services_description":"ADMINISTRATION FEES","address_line1":"208 SOUTH LASALLE ST STE 1300","city":"CHICAGO","state":"IL","zip":"60604","name":"ALLIED BENEFIT SYSTEMS INC","address":"208 SOUTH LASALLE ST STE 1300, CHICAGO, IL, 60604"},{"business_name_line1":"HEALTHSPAN","compensation":566358,"services_description":"ADMINISTRATION FEES","address_line1":"225 PICTORIA DRIVE SUITE 320","city":"CINCINNATI","state":"OH","zip":"45246","name":"HEALTHSPAN","address":"225 PICTORIA DRIVE SUITE 320, CINCINNATI, OH, 45246"},{"business_name_line1":"MULTIPLAN","compensation":106546,"services_description":"ADMINISTRATION FEES","address_line1":"115 FIFTH AVENUE","city":"NEW YORK","state":"NY","zip":"10003","name":"MULTIPLAN","address":"115 FIFTH AVENUE, NEW YORK, NY, 10003"}],"officers_directors_key_employees":[{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE-CHAIRPERSON","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true,"officer":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE (PART-YEAR)","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR","average_hours_per_week":40.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":92769,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":15422,"officer":true}]},"ScheduleB":{"attached":false,"required":false},"ScheduleD":{"land_buildings_equipment":{"total_book_value":0},"other_liabilities":{"footnote_text":true},"revenue_reconciliation":{"total_revenue_audited_financial_statements":47923913,"net_unrealized_gains_investments":-184818,"revenue_not_reported":-184818,"revenue_subtotal":48108731,"investment_expenses_not_included":21192,"revenue_not_reported_financial_statement":21192,"total_revenue_per_990":48129923},"expense_reconciliation":{"total_expenses_audited_financial_statements":52620010,"expenses_not_reported":0,"expenses_subtotal":52620010,"investment_expenses_not_included":21192,"expenses_not_reported_financial_statement":21192,"total_expenses_per_990":52641202},"supplemental_information":[{"identifier":"DESCRIPTION OF UNCERTAIN TAX POSITIONS UNDER FIN 48:","form_and_line_reference":"PART X, LINE 2:","explanation":"ACCOUNTING PRINCIPLES GENERALLY ACCEPTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA REQUIRE PLAN MANAGEMENT TO EVALUATE TAX POSITIONS TAKEN BY THE PLAN AND RECOGNIZE A TAX LIABILITY (OR ASSET) IF THE PLAN HAS TAKEN AN UNCERTAIN POSITION THAT MORE LIKELY THAN NOT WOULD NOT BE SUSTAINED UPON EXAMINATION BY THE INTERNAL REVENUE SERVICE. THE PLAN ADMINISTRATOR HAS ANALYZED THE TAX POSITIONS TAKEN BY THE PLAN, AND HAS CONCLUDED THAT, AS OF SEPTEMBER 1, 2012, THERE ARE NO UNCERTAIN POSITIONS TAKEN OR EXPECTED TO BE TAKEN THAT WOULD REQUIRE RECOGNITION OF A LIABILITY (OR ASSET) OR DISCLOSURE IN THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS. THE PLAN IS SUBJECT TO ROUTINE AUDITS BY TAXING JURISDICTIONS; HOWEVER, THERE ARE CURRENTLY NO AUDITS FOR ANY TAX PERIODS IN PROGRESS. THE PLAN ADMINISTRATOR BELIEVES THE PLAN IS NO LONGER SUBJECT TO INCOME TAX EXAMINATIONS FOR YEARS ENDED PRIOR TO DECEMBER 31, 2009."}]},"ScheduleN":{"termination_or_liquidation":{"assets_distributed":true,"liabilities_paid":true,"bonds_outstanding":false,"bond_liabilities_discharged":false,"required_to_notify_attorney_general":true,"attorney_general_notified":true},"successor_relationships":{"director_of_successor":true,"employee_of_successor":true,"owner_of_successor":false},"liquidations":[{"business_name_line1":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","distribution_date":"2012-09-01T00:00:00","description":"CASH","fair_market_value":480431,"method_of_fmv_determination":"BOOK VALUE","address_line1":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3","city":"CINCINNATI","state":"OH","zip":"45242","name":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","address":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3, CINCINNATI, OH, 45242"},{"business_name_line1":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","distribution_date":"2012-09-01T00:00:00","description":"ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE","fair_market_value":275097,"method_of_fmv_determination":"BOOK VALUE","address_line1":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3","city":"CINCINNATI","state":"OH","zip":"45242","name":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","address":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3, CINCINNATI, OH, 45242"},{"business_name_line1":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","distribution_date":"2012-09-01T00:00:00","description":"INVESTMENTS","fair_market_value":12723766,"method_of_fmv_determination":"FMV IS READILY AVAILABLE FOR PUBLICLY TRADED ASSETS","address_line1":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3","city":"CINCINNATI","state":"OH","zip":"45242","name":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","address":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3, CINCINNATI, OH, 45242"},{"business_name_line1":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","distribution_date":"2012-09-01T00:00:00","description":"ALLIED CLAIM ACCOUNT","fair_market_value":-2104985,"method_of_fmv_determination":"BOOK VALUE","address_line1":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3","city":"CINCINNATI","state":"OH","zip":"45242","name":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","address":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3, CINCINNATI, OH, 45242"},{"business_name_line1":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","distribution_date":"2012-09-01T00:00:00","description":"BENEFIT OBLIGATIONS - IBNR","fair_market_value":-8500000,"method_of_fmv_determination":"BOOK VALUE","address_line1":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3","city":"CINCINNATI","state":"OH","zip":"45242","name":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","address":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3, CINCINNATI, OH, 45242"},{"business_name_line1":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","distribution_date":"2012-09-01T00:00:00","description":"ACCOUNTS PAYABLE","fair_market_value":-5671,"method_of_fmv_determination":"BOOK VALUE","address_line1":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3","city":"CINCINNATI","state":"OH","zip":"45242","name":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","address":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3, CINCINNATI, OH, 45242"}],"supplemental_information":[{"explanation":"PART I, LINE 2E: STEPHANIE HEARN, BETH WEBER, ROBIN WHITE, RICHARD PACKERT, NANCY LANE, CHRISTINE COOK-POETTER, MIKE DAVIS & PATTY SPATH-MEYER"},{"explanation":"PART I, LINE 2E: THE EXISTING BOARD OF DIRECTORS CONTINUES TO DIRECT THE OPERATIONS OF BUTLER HEALTH PLAN, AS A DIVISION OF OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES. STEPHANIE HEARN CONTINUES TO FUNCTION AS EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE PLAN, BUT IS NOW AN EMPLOYEE OF SHAFELY PLAN MANAGEMENT."}]},"ScheduleR":{"tax_exempt_organizations":[{"business_name_line1":"FAIRFIELD CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","primary_activities":"PUBLIC SCHOOLING","exempt_code_section":"501(C)(1)","controlled_organization":false,"legal_domicile_state":"OH","address_line1":"211 DONALD DRIVE","city":"FAIRFIELD","state":"OH","zip":"45014","name":"FAIRFIELD CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","address":"211 DONALD DRIVE, FAIRFIELD, OH, 45014"},{"business_name_line1":"HAMILTON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","primary_activities":"PUBLIC SCHOOLING","exempt_code_section":"501(C)(1)","controlled_organization":false,"legal_domicile_state":"OH","address_line1":"533 DAYTON STREET","city":"HAMILTON","state":"OH","zip":"45012","name":"HAMILTON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","address":"533 DAYTON STREET, HAMILTON, OH, 45012"},{"business_name_line1":"LAKOTA LOCAL SCHOOLS","primary_activities":"PUBLIC SCHOOLING","exempt_code_section":"501(C)(1)","controlled_organization":false,"legal_domicile_state":"OH","address_line1":"5572 PRINCETON ROAD","city":"LIBERTY TOWNSHIP","state":"OH","zip":"45011","name":"LAKOTA LOCAL SCHOOLS","address":"5572 PRINCETON ROAD, LIBERTY TOWNSHIP, OH, 45011"}],"transaction_flags":{"dividends_from_related_organization":false,"gift_grant_or_capital_contribution_from_other_org":false,"gift_grant_or_capital_contribution_to_other_org":false,"loans_or_guarantees_from_other_org":false,"loans_or_guarantees_to_other_org":false,"performance_of_services_by_other_orgs":false,"performance_of_services_for_other_orgs":false,"sharing_of_facilities":false,"sharing_of_paid_employees":false,"reimbursement_paid_by_other_org":false,"reimbursement_paid_to_other_org":false,"rental_of_facilities_from_other_orgs":false,"rental_of_facilities_to_other_orgs":false,"purchase_of_assets_from_other_org":false,"sale_of_assets_to_other_org":false,"exchange_of_assets":false,"receipt_of_interest_annuities_rents_royalties":false,"other_transfer_from_other_org":true,"other_transfer_to_other_org":false},"transactions":[{"business_name_line1":"FAIRFIELD CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","amount_involved":5901978,"method_of_amount_determination":"CASH","transaction_type":"S","name":"FAIRFIELD CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT"},{"business_name_line1":"HAMILTON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","amount_involved":6673033,"method_of_amount_determination":"CASH","transaction_type":"S","name":"HAMILTON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT"},{"business_name_line1":"LAKOTA LOCAL SCHOOLS","amount_involved":11132468,"method_of_amount_determination":"CASH","transaction_type":"S","name":"LAKOTA LOCAL SCHOOLS"}]},"source_xml":"201300849349300760_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"Hours":[0],"Total Compensation":[0],"Direct compensation":[0],"Other compensation":[0]},"Basic":{"mission":"Provide medical and dental benefits for the exclusive benefit of its members","primary_activities":"Health care benefits - providing health care coverage to participating schools, serving approximately 6,400 individuals/families.","year":2010,"name":"BUTLER HEALTH PLAN","phone":"5138962300","website":"WWW.BUTLERHEALTHPLAN.ORG","type":"990","principal_officer":"STEPHANIE HEARN","year_formation":1985,"state_legal_domicile":"OH","total_volunteers":0,"tax_period_begin":"2010-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2010-12-31T00:00:00","address":"400 NORTH ERIE BLVD NO B, HAMILTON, OH, 45011, USA","city":"HAMILTON","state":"OH","country":"USA","zip_code":"45011"},"Governance":{"501c determination":true,"Number of voting members":7,"Number of independent voting members":7,"Number of employees total":2,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":2,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":false,"Taxable party notification":false,"Funds to pay premiums":false,"Premiums Paid":false,"Family or business relationship":false,"Delegation of management duties":false,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":false,"Compensation process for CEO":false,"Compensation process for other employees":false,"Changes to organizing documents":false,"Material diversion or misuse":false,"Members or stockholders":false,"Election of board members":false,"Decisions subject to approval":false,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":false,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":false,"Investment in joint venture":false,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":false,"Accountant compile or review":false,"Financial statements audited by independent accountant":true,"Audit committee":true,"Federal grant audit required":false,"Political activities":false,"Donor advised funds":false,"Conservation easements":false,"Collections of art":false,"School":false,"Hospital":false,"Foreign activities":false,"Foreign office":false,"Gaming":false,"Fundraising activities":false,"Professional fundraising":false,"Loan to officer or DQP":false,"Grant to related person":false,"Business relationship through family member":false,"Business relationship with organization":false},"Revenues":{"value":75951938,"Contributions":{"value":0},"Program revenue":{"value":75070315,"Total revenue":75070315,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":881623,"Investment income total":881623},"Other revenues":{"value":0}},"Expenses":{"value":79401958,"Grant expense":{"value":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":76310608,"Benefits paid to members Total":76310608},"Salaries":{"value":236973,"Current officers":127430,"Other salaries and wages":71726,"Other employee benefits":14994,"Payroll taxes":22823},"Other expenses":{"value":2854377,"Management services":6002,"Legal":97003,"Accounting":28600,"Lobbying services":7500,"Investment management fees":43621,"Other services":97683,"Office expenses":11012,"Occupancy":20549,"Travel":10507,"Conferences and meetings":3846,"Insurance":56893,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":2457217,"VARIOUS":2457217},"All other expenses":13944}},"Assets":{"value":21063812,"Savings and temp cash investments":1244602,"Accounts receivable":941200,"Investments publicly traded":18878010},"Liabilities":{"value":11046164,"Accounts payable, accrued":2846164,"Other liabilities":8200000},"Fund balance":{"value":10017648},"Form990Details":{"program_service_accomplishments":[{"description":"HEALTH CARE BENEFITS - PROVIDING HEALTH CARE COVERAGE TO PARTICIPATING SCHOOLS, SERVING APPROXIMATELY 6,400 INDIVIDUALS/FAMILIES."}],"program_service_revenue_detail":[{"business_code":"525100","description":"PARTICIPANT CONTRIBUTI","total_revenue":75070315,"related_or_exempt_function_income":75070315}],"functional_expense_allocations":{"current_officers_directors":{"program_services":127430,"total":127430},"other_salaries_and_wages":{"program_services":71726,"total":71726},"other_employee_benefits":{"program_services":14994,"total":14994},"payroll_taxes":{"program_services":22823,"total":22823},"management_fees":{"program_services":6002,"total":6002},"legal_fees":{"program_services":97003,"total":97003},"accounting_fees":{"program_services":28600,"total":28600},"lobbying_fees":{"program_services":7500,"total":7500},"investment_management_fees":{"program_services":43621,"total":43621},"other_service_fees":{"program_services":97683,"total":97683},"office_expenses":{"program_services":11012,"total":11012},"occupancy":{"program_services":20549,"total":20549},"travel":{"program_services":10507,"total":10507},"conferences_meetings":{"program_services":3846,"total":3846},"insurance":{"program_services":56893,"total":56893},"all_other_expenses":{"program_services":13944,"total":13944}},"tax_and_disclosure_flags":{"activities_conducted_through_partnership":false,"foreign_financial_account":false,"backup_withholding_compliance":true,"employment_tax_returns_filed":true,"deductible_non_cash_contributions":false,"deductible_contributions_of_art":false,"method_of_accounting_accrual":true,"schedule_o_part_vi":true,"schedule_o_part_xi":true,"schedule_o_part_xii":true},"principal_officer_detail":{"person_name":"STEPHANIE HEARN","address_line1":"1910 FAIRGROVE AVENUE SUITE C","city":"HAMILTON","state":"OH","zip":"45011"},"audit_financial_statement_detail":{"accountant_compile_or_review":false,"audited_financial_statement_separate":true,"federal_grant_audit_required":false},"related_party_due_diligence":{"officer_entity_with_business_relationship":false,"officer_mailing_address":false,"related_entity":true,"related_org_controlled_entity":false,"compensation_from_other_sources":false,"annual_disclosure_covered_persons":true},"grant_due_diligence":{"grants_to_organizations":false,"grants_to_individuals":false,"more_than_5000_to_organizations":false,"more_than_5000_to_individuals":false},"books_are_in_care_of":{"phone":"5139426262","business_name_line1":"STEPHANIE HEARN","address_line1":"1910 FAIRGROVE AVENUE SUITE C","city":"HAMILTON","state":"OH","zip":"45011"},"contractor_compensation":[{"business_name_line1":"ALLIED BENEFIT SYSTEMS INC","compensation":1210128,"services_description":"ADMINISTRATION FEES","address_line1":"208 SOUTH LASALLE ST STE 1300","city":"CHICAGO","state":"IL","zip":"60604","name":"ALLIED BENEFIT SYSTEMS INC","address":"208 SOUTH LASALLE ST STE 1300, CHICAGO, IL, 60604"},{"business_name_line1":"FIFTH THIRD BANK","compensation":115770,"services_description":"INVESTMENT SERVICES","address_line1":"5050 KINGSLEY DRIVE","city":"CINCINNATI","state":"OH","zip":"45263","name":"FIFTH THIRD BANK","address":"5050 KINGSLEY DRIVE, CINCINNATI, OH, 45263"}],"officers_directors_key_employees":[{"title":"CHAIRPERSON","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true,"officer":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"SECRETARY","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true,"officer":true},{"title":"TREASURER","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true,"officer":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR","average_hours_per_week":40.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":113606,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":13824,"officer":true}]},"ScheduleB":{"attached":false,"required":false},"ScheduleD":{"land_buildings_equipment":{"total_book_value":0},"other_liabilities":{"liabilities":[{"description":"RESERVE ACCOUNT","amount":8200000}],"total_liability":8200000},"net_assets_reconciliation":{"total_revenue":75951938,"total_expenses":79401958,"excess_or_deficit_for_year":-3450020,"net_unrealized_gains_losses_on_investments":-140325,"total_adjustments":-140325,"excess_or_deficit_per_financial_statements":-3590345},"revenue_reconciliation":{"total_revenue_audited_financial_statements":75767992,"net_unrealized_gains_investments":-140325,"revenue_not_reported":-140325,"revenue_subtotal":75908317,"investment_expenses_not_included":43621,"revenue_not_reported_financial_statement":43621,"total_revenue_per_990":75951938},"expense_reconciliation":{"total_expenses_audited_financial_statements":78658337,"expenses_not_reported":0,"expenses_subtotal":78658337,"investment_expenses_not_included":43621,"other_expenses_not_included":700000,"expenses_not_reported_financial_statement":743621,"total_expenses_per_990":79401958},"supplemental_information":[{"identifier":"DESCRIPTION OF UNCERTAIN TAX POSITIONS UNDER FIN 48:","explanation":"ACCOUNTING PRINCIPLES GENERALLY ACCEPTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA REQUIRE PLAN MANAGEMENT TO EVALUATE TAX POSITIONS TAKEN BY THE PLAN AND RECOGNIZE A TAX LIABILITY (OR ASSET) IF THE PLAN HAS TAKEN AN UNCERTAIN POSITION THAT MORE LIKELY THAN NOT WOULD NOT BE SUSTAINED UPON EXAMINATION BY THE INTERNAL REVENUE SERVICE. THE PLAN ADMINISTRATOR HAS ANALYZED THE TAX POSITIONS TAKEN BY THE PLAN, AND HAS CONCLUDED THAT, AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2010, THERE ARE NO UNCERTAIN POSITIONS TAKEN OR EXPECTED TO BE TAKEN THAT WOULD REQUIRE RECOGNITION OF A LIABILITY (OR ASSET) OR DISCLOSURE IN THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS. THE PLAN IS SUBJECT TO ROUTINE AUDITS BY TAXING JURISDICTIONS; HOWEVER, THERE ARE CURRENTLY NO AUDITS FOR ANY TAX PERIODS IN PROGRESS. THE PLAN ADMINISTRATOR BELIEVES THE PLAN IS NO LONGER SUBJECT TO INCOME TAX EXAMINATIONS FOR YEARS ENDED PRIOR TO DECEMBER 31, 2007."},{"identifier":"PART XIII, LINE 4B - OTHER ADJUSTMENTS:","explanation":"CHANGE IN RESERVE BALANCE INCURRED BUT NOT REPORTED 700,000."}]},"ScheduleR":{"tax_exempt_organizations":[{"business_name_line1":"FAIRFIELD CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","primary_activities":"PUBLIC SCHOOLING","exempt_code_section":"501(C)(1)","controlled_organization":false,"legal_domicile_state":"OH","address_line1":"211 DONALD DRIVE","city":"FAIRFIELD","state":"OH","zip":"45014","name":"FAIRFIELD CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","address":"211 DONALD DRIVE, FAIRFIELD, OH, 45014"},{"business_name_line1":"HAMILTON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","primary_activities":"PUBLIC SCHOOLING","exempt_code_section":"501(C)(1)","controlled_organization":false,"legal_domicile_state":"OH","address_line1":"533 DAYTON STREET","city":"HAMILTON","state":"OH","zip":"45012","name":"HAMILTON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","address":"533 DAYTON STREET, HAMILTON, OH, 45012"},{"business_name_line1":"LAKOTA LOCAL SCHOOLS","primary_activities":"PUBLIC SCHOOLING","exempt_code_section":"501(C)(1)","controlled_organization":false,"legal_domicile_state":"OH","address_line1":"5572 PRINCETON ROAD","city":"LIBERTY TOWNSHIP","state":"OH","zip":"45011","name":"LAKOTA LOCAL SCHOOLS","address":"5572 PRINCETON ROAD, LIBERTY TOWNSHIP, OH, 45011"},{"business_name_line1":"MIDDLETOWN CITY SCHOOLS","primary_activities":"PUBLIC SCHOOLING","exempt_code_section":"501(C)(1)","controlled_organization":false,"legal_domicile_state":"OH","address_line1":"1515 GIRARD AVENUE","city":"MIDDLETOWN","state":"OH","zip":"45044","name":"MIDDLETOWN CITY SCHOOLS","address":"1515 GIRARD AVENUE, MIDDLETOWN, OH, 45044"}],"transaction_flags":{"gift_grant_or_capital_contribution_from_other_org":false,"gift_grant_or_capital_contribution_to_other_org":false,"loans_or_guarantees_from_other_org":false,"loans_or_guarantees_to_other_org":false,"performance_of_services_by_other_orgs":false,"performance_of_services_for_other_orgs":false,"sharing_of_facilities":false,"sharing_of_paid_employees":false,"reimbursement_paid_by_other_org":false,"reimbursement_paid_to_other_org":false,"rental_of_facilities_from_other_orgs":false,"rental_of_facilities_to_other_orgs":false,"purchase_of_assets_from_other_org":false,"sale_of_assets_to_other_org":false,"exchange_of_assets":false,"receipt_of_interest_annuities_rents_royalties":false,"other_transfer_from_other_org":true,"other_transfer_to_other_org":false},"transactions":[{"business_name_line1":"FAIRFIELD CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","amount_involved":9290061,"method_of_amount_determination":"CASH","transaction_type":"R","name":"FAIRFIELD CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT"},{"business_name_line1":"HAMILTON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","amount_involved":9035242,"method_of_amount_determination":"CASH","transaction_type":"R","name":"HAMILTON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT"},{"business_name_line1":"LAKOTA LOCAL SCHOOLS","amount_involved":17001277,"method_of_amount_determination":"CASH","transaction_type":"R","name":"LAKOTA LOCAL SCHOOLS"},{"business_name_line1":"MIDDLETOWN CITY SCHOOLS","amount_involved":7333985,"method_of_amount_determination":"CASH","transaction_type":"R","name":"MIDDLETOWN CITY SCHOOLS"}]},"source_xml":"201122939349300402_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"Hours":[0],"Total Compensation":[0],"Direct compensation":[0],"Other compensation":[0]},"Basic":{"mission":"Provide medical and dental benefits for the exclusive benefit of its members","primary_activities":"Health care benefits - providing health care coverage to participating schools, serving approximately 6,400 individuals/families.","year":2011,"name":"BUTLER HEALTH PLAN","phone":"5138962300","website":"WWW.BUTLERHEALTHPLAN.ORG","type":"990","principal_officer":"STEPHANIE HEARN","year_formation":1985,"state_legal_domicile":"OH","total_volunteers":0,"tax_period_begin":"2011-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2011-12-31T00:00:00","address":"400 NORTH ERIE BLVD NO B, HAMILTON, OH, 45011, USA","city":"HAMILTON","state":"OH","country":"USA","zip_code":"45011"},"Governance":{"501c determination":true,"Number of voting members":7,"Number of independent voting members":7,"Number of employees total":2,"Total Gross UBI":600498,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":2,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":false,"Taxable party notification":false,"Funds to pay premiums":false,"Premiums Paid":false,"Family or business relationship":false,"Delegation of management duties":false,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":false,"Compensation process for CEO":false,"Compensation process for other employees":false,"Changes to organizing documents":false,"Material diversion or misuse":false,"Members or stockholders":false,"Election of board members":false,"Decisions subject to approval":false,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":false,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":false,"Investment in joint venture":false,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":false,"Accountant compile or review":false,"Financial statements audited by independent accountant":true,"Audit committee":true,"Federal grant audit required":false,"Political activities":false,"Donor advised funds":false,"Conservation easements":false,"Collections of art":false,"School":false,"Hospital":false,"Foreign activities":false,"Foreign office":false,"Gaming":false,"Fundraising activities":false,"Professional fundraising":false,"Loan to officer or DQP":false,"Grant to related person":false,"Business relationship through family member":false,"Business relationship with organization":false},"Revenues":{"value":79859724,"Contributions":{"value":0},"Program revenue":{"value":79259226,"Total revenue":79259226,"Unrelated business revenue":600498},"Investment income":{"value":600498,"Investment income total":600498},"Other revenues":{"value":0}},"Expenses":{"value":81759923,"Grant expense":{"value":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":78601119,"Benefits paid to members Total":78601119},"Salaries":{"value":250560,"Current officers":135132,"Other salaries and wages":75000,"Pension plan contributions":9750,"Other employee benefits":7395,"Payroll taxes":23283},"Other expenses":{"value":2908244,"Legal":74558,"Accounting":26900,"Investment management fees":37326,"Other services":150985,"Office expenses":18051,"Information technology":1675,"Occupancy":17731,"Travel":7703,"Conferences and meetings":8637,"Insurance":130568,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":2416873,"VARIOUS":2416873},"All other expenses":17237}},"Assets":{"value":17271435,"Savings and temp cash investments":1210594,"Accounts receivable":590606,"Investments publicly traded":15470235},"Liabilities":{"value":9206700,"Accounts payable, accrued":1206700,"Other liabilities":8000000},"Fund balance":{"value":8064735},"Form990Details":{"program_service_accomplishments":[{"description":"HEALTH CARE BENEFITS - PROVIDING HEALTH CARE COVERAGE TO PARTICIPATING SCHOOLS, SERVING APPROXIMATELY 6,400 INDIVIDUALS/FAMILIES."}],"program_service_revenue_detail":[{"business_code":"525100","description":"MEMBER CONTRIBUTIONS","total_revenue":79259226,"related_or_exempt_function_income":79259226}],"functional_expense_allocations":{"current_officers_directors":{"total":135132},"other_salaries_and_wages":{"total":75000},"pension_plan_contributions":{"total":9750},"other_employee_benefits":{"total":7395},"payroll_taxes":{"total":23283},"legal_fees":{"total":74558},"accounting_fees":{"total":26900},"investment_management_fees":{"total":37326},"other_service_fees":{"total":150985},"office_expenses":{"total":18051},"information_technology":{"total":1675},"occupancy":{"total":17731},"travel":{"total":7703},"conferences_meetings":{"total":8637},"insurance":{"total":130568},"all_other_expenses":{"total":17237}},"tax_and_disclosure_flags":{"activities_conducted_through_partnership":false,"foreign_financial_account":false,"backup_withholding_compliance":true,"employment_tax_returns_filed":true,"deductible_non_cash_contributions":false,"deductible_contributions_of_art":false,"method_of_accounting_accrual":true,"schedule_o_part_vi":true,"schedule_o_part_xi":true,"schedule_o_part_xii":true},"principal_officer_detail":{"person_name":"STEPHANIE HEARN","address_line1":"1910 FAIRGROVE AVENUE SUITE C","city":"HAMILTON","state":"OH","zip":"45011"},"audit_financial_statement_detail":{"accountant_compile_or_review":false,"audited_financial_statement_separate":true,"federal_grant_audit_required":false},"related_party_due_diligence":{"officer_entity_with_business_relationship":false,"officer_mailing_address":false,"related_entity":true,"related_org_controlled_entity":false,"compensation_from_other_sources":false,"annual_disclosure_covered_persons":true},"grant_due_diligence":{"grants_to_organizations":false,"grants_to_individuals":false,"more_than_5000_to_organizations":false,"more_than_5000_to_individuals":false},"books_are_in_care_of":{"phone":"5139426262","business_name_line1":"STEPHANIE HEARN","address_line1":"400 NORTH ERIE BLVD NO B","city":"HAMILTON","state":"OH","zip":"45011"},"contractor_compensation":[{"business_name_line1":"ALLIED BENEFIT SYSTEMS INC","compensation":1201450,"services_description":"ADMINISTRATION FEES","address_line1":"208 SOUTH LASALLE ST STE 1300","city":"CHICAGO","state":"IL","zip":"60604","name":"ALLIED BENEFIT SYSTEMS INC","address":"208 SOUTH LASALLE ST STE 1300, CHICAGO, IL, 60604"},{"business_name_line1":"HEALTHSPAN","compensation":923141,"services_description":"ADMINISTRATION FEES","address_line1":"225 PICTORIA DRIVE SUITE 320","city":"CINCINNATI","state":"OH","zip":"45246","name":"HEALTHSPAN","address":"225 PICTORIA DRIVE SUITE 320, CINCINNATI, OH, 45246"},{"business_name_line1":"MULTIPLAN","compensation":122179,"services_description":"ADMINISTRATION FEES","address_line1":"115 FIFTH AVENUE","city":"NEW YORK","state":"NY","zip":"10003","name":"MULTIPLAN","address":"115 FIFTH AVENUE, NEW YORK, NY, 10003"},{"business_name_line1":"FIFTH THIRD BANK","compensation":116958,"services_description":"BANKING & INVESTMENT SERVICES","address_line1":"5050 KINGSLEY DRIVE","city":"CINCINNATI","state":"OH","zip":"45263","name":"FIFTH THIRD BANK","address":"5050 KINGSLEY DRIVE, CINCINNATI, OH, 45263"}],"officers_directors_key_employees":[{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true,"officer":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE-CHAIRPERSON","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE-SECRETARY/TREASURER","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true,"officer":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true,"officer":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR","average_hours_per_week":40.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":120000,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":21132,"officer":true}]},"ScheduleB":{"attached":false,"required":false},"ScheduleD":{"land_buildings_equipment":{"total_book_value":0},"other_liabilities":{"liabilities":[{"description":"BENEFIT OBLIGATIONS - IBNR","amount":8000000}],"total_liability":8000000},"net_assets_reconciliation":{"total_revenue":79859724,"total_expenses":81759923,"excess_or_deficit_for_year":-1900199,"net_unrealized_gains_losses_on_investments":-52714,"total_adjustments":-52714,"excess_or_deficit_per_financial_statements":-1952913},"revenue_reconciliation":{"total_revenue_audited_financial_statements":79769684,"net_unrealized_gains_investments":-52714,"revenue_not_reported":-52714,"revenue_subtotal":79822398,"investment_expenses_not_included":37326,"revenue_not_reported_financial_statement":37326,"total_revenue_per_990":79859724},"expense_reconciliation":{"total_expenses_audited_financial_statements":81922597,"other_expenses_included":200000,"expenses_not_reported":200000,"expenses_subtotal":81722597,"investment_expenses_not_included":37326,"expenses_not_reported_financial_statement":37326,"total_expenses_per_990":81759923},"supplemental_information":[{"identifier":"DESCRIPTION OF UNCERTAIN TAX POSITIONS UNDER FIN 48:","explanation":"ACCOUNTING PRINCIPLES GENERALLY ACCEPTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA REQUIRE PLAN MANAGEMENT TO EVALUATE TAX POSITIONS TAKEN BY THE PLAN AND RECOGNIZE A TAX LIABILITY (OR ASSET) IF THE PLAN HAS TAKEN AN UNCERTAIN POSITION THAT MORE LIKELY THAN NOT WOULD NOT BE SUSTAINED UPON EXAMINATION BY THE INTERNAL REVENUE SERVICE. THE PLAN ADMINISTRATOR HAS ANALYZED THE TAX POSITIONS TAKEN BY THE PLAN, AND HAS CONCLUDED THAT, AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2011, THERE ARE NO UNCERTAIN POSITIONS TAKEN OR EXPECTED TO BE TAKEN THAT WOULD REQUIRE RECOGNITION OF A LIABILITY (OR ASSET) OR DISCLOSURE IN THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS. THE PLAN IS SUBJECT TO ROUTINE AUDITS BY TAXING JURISDICTIONS; HOWEVER, THERE ARE CURRENTLY NO AUDITS FOR ANY TAX PERIODS IN PROGRESS. THE PLAN ADMINISTRATOR BELIEVES THE PLAN IS NO LONGER SUBJECT TO INCOME TAX EXAMINATIONS FOR YEARS ENDED PRIOR TO DECEMBER 31, 2008."},{"identifier":"PART XIII, LINE 2D - OTHER ADJUSTMENTS:","explanation":"CHANGE IN BENEFIT OBLIGATIONS - CLAIMS INCURRED BUT NOT REPORTED 200,000."}]},"ScheduleR":{"tax_exempt_organizations":[{"business_name_line1":"FAIRFIELD CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","primary_activities":"PUBLIC SCHOOLING","exempt_code_section":"501(C)(1)","controlled_organization":false,"legal_domicile_state":"OH","address_line1":"211 DONALD DRIVE","city":"FAIRFIELD","state":"OH","zip":"45014","name":"FAIRFIELD CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","address":"211 DONALD DRIVE, FAIRFIELD, OH, 45014"},{"business_name_line1":"HAMILTON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","primary_activities":"PUBLIC SCHOOLING","exempt_code_section":"501(C)(1)","controlled_organization":false,"legal_domicile_state":"OH","address_line1":"533 DAYTON STREET","city":"HAMILTON","state":"OH","zip":"45012","name":"HAMILTON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","address":"533 DAYTON STREET, HAMILTON, OH, 45012"},{"business_name_line1":"LAKOTA LOCAL SCHOOLS","primary_activities":"PUBLIC SCHOOLING","exempt_code_section":"501(C)(1)","controlled_organization":false,"legal_domicile_state":"OH","address_line1":"5572 PRINCETON ROAD","city":"LIBERTY TOWNSHIP","state":"OH","zip":"45011","name":"LAKOTA LOCAL SCHOOLS","address":"5572 PRINCETON ROAD, LIBERTY TOWNSHIP, OH, 45011"},{"business_name_line1":"MIDDLETOWN CITY SCHOOLS","primary_activities":"PUBLIC SCHOOLING","exempt_code_section":"501(C)(1)","controlled_organization":false,"legal_domicile_state":"OH","address_line1":"1515 GIRARD AVENUE","city":"MIDDLETOWN","state":"OH","zip":"45044","name":"MIDDLETOWN CITY SCHOOLS","address":"1515 GIRARD AVENUE, MIDDLETOWN, OH, 45044"}],"transaction_flags":{"gift_grant_or_capital_contribution_from_other_org":false,"gift_grant_or_capital_contribution_to_other_org":false,"loans_or_guarantees_from_other_org":false,"loans_or_guarantees_to_other_org":false,"performance_of_services_by_other_orgs":false,"performance_of_services_for_other_orgs":false,"sharing_of_facilities":false,"sharing_of_paid_employees":false,"reimbursement_paid_by_other_org":false,"reimbursement_paid_to_other_org":false,"rental_of_facilities_from_other_orgs":false,"rental_of_facilities_to_other_orgs":false,"purchase_of_assets_from_other_org":false,"sale_of_assets_to_other_org":false,"exchange_of_assets":false,"receipt_of_interest_annuities_rents_royalties":false,"other_transfer_from_other_org":true,"other_transfer_to_other_org":false},"transactions":[{"business_name_line1":"FAIRFIELD CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","amount_involved":8935045,"method_of_amount_determination":"CASH","transaction_type":"R","name":"FAIRFIELD CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT"},{"business_name_line1":"HAMILTON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","amount_involved":10057530,"method_of_amount_determination":"CASH","transaction_type":"R","name":"HAMILTON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT"},{"business_name_line1":"LAKOTA LOCAL SCHOOLS","amount_involved":17732963,"method_of_amount_determination":"CASH","transaction_type":"R","name":"LAKOTA LOCAL SCHOOLS"},{"business_name_line1":"MIDDLETOWN CITY SCHOOLS","amount_involved":7658316,"method_of_amount_determination":"CASH","transaction_type":"R","name":"MIDDLETOWN CITY SCHOOLS"}]},"source_xml":"201212509349300231_public.xml"}],"Latest":{"Organization":{"Hours":[0],"Total Compensation":[0],"Direct compensation":[0],"Other compensation":[0]},"Basic":{"mission":"Provide medical and dental benefits for the exclusive benefit of its members","primary_activities":"Health care benefits - providing health care coverage to participants employed by 14 local school districts and related educational institutions\n\nIn march 2012, the trustees approved a merger of the plan, subject to the consent of the majority of the member districts. The plan subsequently received consents from a sufficient number of school districts to proceed with the merger. Effective september 1, 2012, the plan joined optimal health initiatives to form a state-wide, jointly administered arrangement with northern buckeye health plan and scioto health plan. The three merging plans will operate as divisions, providing local separation of assets and decision making for issues, such as plan design, rates, reserve management, etc. The purpose for the merger is to enhance the independent survivability of the plan from state and federal control by significantly increasing the number of members served on a state-wide basis.","year":2012,"name":"BUTLER HEALTH PLAN","phone":"5132732520","website":"WWW.BUTLERHEALTHPLAN.ORG","type":"990","principal_officer":"STEPHANIE HEARN","year_formation":1985,"state_legal_domicile":"OH","total_volunteers":0,"tax_period_begin":"2012-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2012-09-30T00:00:00","address":"400 NORTH ERIE BLVD STE B, HAMILTON, OH, 45011, USA","city":"HAMILTON","state":"OH","country":"USA","zip_code":"45011"},"Governance":{"501c determination":true,"Number of voting members":7,"Number of independent voting members":7,"Number of employees total":2,"Total Gross UBI":388126,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":2,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":false,"Taxable party notification":false,"Funds to pay premiums":false,"Premiums Paid":false,"Family or business relationship":false,"Delegation of management duties":false,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":false,"Compensation process for CEO":false,"Compensation process for other employees":false,"Changes to organizing documents":false,"Material diversion or misuse":false,"Members or stockholders":false,"Election of board members":false,"Decisions subject to approval":false,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":false,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":false,"Investment in joint venture":false,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":false,"Accountant compile or review":false,"Financial statements audited by independent accountant":true,"Audit committee":true,"Federal grant audit required":false,"Audited financial statements separate":true,"Political activities":false,"Donor advised funds":false,"Conservation easements":false,"Collections of art":false,"School":false,"Hospital":false,"Foreign activities":false,"Foreign office":false,"Gaming":false,"Fundraising activities":false,"Professional fundraising":false,"Loan to officer or DQP":false,"Grant to related person":false,"Business relationship through family member":false,"Business relationship with organization":false},"Revenues":{"value":48129923,"Contributions":{"value":0},"Program revenue":{"value":47741797,"Total revenue":47741797,"Unrelated business revenue":388126},"Investment income":{"value":388126,"Investment income total":388126},"Other revenues":{"value":0}},"Expenses":{"value":52641202,"Grant expense":{"value":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":50677410,"Benefits paid to members Total":50677410},"Salaries":{"value":205600,"Current officers":108191,"Other salaries and wages":72115,"Pension plan contributions":3606,"Other employee benefits":945,"Payroll taxes":20743},"Other expenses":{"value":1758192,"Legal":40664,"Accounting":33300,"Investment management fees":21192,"Other services":54311,"Office expenses":4332,"Information technology":1500,"Occupancy":9978,"Travel":6253,"Conferences and meetings":3568,"Insurance":72182,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":1509088,"VARIOUS":1509088},"All other expenses":1824}},"Assets":{"value":0,"Non-interest bearing cash":0,"Savings and temp cash investments":0,"Pledges and grants receivable":0,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":0,"Investments publicly traded":0,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":0},"Liabilities":{"value":0,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":0},"Form990Details":{"program_service_accomplishments":[{"description":"HEALTH CARE BENEFITS - PROVIDING HEALTH CARE COVERAGE TO PARTICIPANTS EMPLOYED BY 14 LOCAL SCHOOL DISTRICTS AND RELATED EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS"}],"program_service_revenue_detail":[{"business_code":"525100","description":"MEMBER CONTRIBUTIONS","total_revenue":47741797,"related_or_exempt_function_income":47741797}],"functional_expense_allocations":{"current_officers_directors":{"total":108191},"other_salaries_and_wages":{"total":72115},"pension_plan_contributions":{"total":3606},"other_employee_benefits":{"total":945},"payroll_taxes":{"total":20743},"legal_fees":{"total":40664},"accounting_fees":{"total":33300},"investment_management_fees":{"total":21192},"other_service_fees":{"total":54311},"office_expenses":{"total":4332},"information_technology":{"total":1500},"occupancy":{"total":9978},"travel":{"total":6253},"conferences_meetings":{"total":3568},"insurance":{"total":72182},"all_other_expenses":{"total":1824}},"tax_and_disclosure_flags":{"activities_conducted_through_partnership":false,"foreign_financial_account":false,"backup_withholding_compliance":true,"employment_tax_returns_filed":true,"deductible_non_cash_contributions":false,"deductible_contributions_of_art":false,"method_of_accounting_accrual":true,"schedule_o_part_iii":true,"schedule_o_part_vi":true,"schedule_o_part_xi":true,"schedule_o_part_xii":true},"principal_officer_detail":{"person_name":"STEPHANIE HEARN","address_line1":"400 NORTH ERIE BLVD STE B","city":"HAMILTON","state":"OH","zip":"45011"},"audit_financial_statement_detail":{"accountant_compile_or_review":false,"federal_grant_audit_required":false},"related_party_due_diligence":{"officer_entity_with_business_relationship":false,"officer_mailing_address":false,"related_entity":true,"related_org_controlled_entity":false,"compensation_from_other_sources":false,"annual_disclosure_covered_persons":true},"grant_due_diligence":{"grants_to_organizations":false,"grants_to_individuals":false,"more_than_5000_to_organizations":false,"more_than_5000_to_individuals":false},"books_are_in_care_of":{"phone":"5139426262","business_name_line1":"STEPHANIE HEARN","address_line1":"400 NORTH ERIE BLVD STE B","city":"HAMILTON","state":"OH","zip":"45011"},"contractor_compensation":[{"business_name_line1":"ALLIED BENEFIT SYSTEMS INC","compensation":742960,"services_description":"ADMINISTRATION FEES","address_line1":"208 SOUTH LASALLE ST STE 1300","city":"CHICAGO","state":"IL","zip":"60604","name":"ALLIED BENEFIT SYSTEMS INC","address":"208 SOUTH LASALLE ST STE 1300, CHICAGO, IL, 60604"},{"business_name_line1":"HEALTHSPAN","compensation":566358,"services_description":"ADMINISTRATION FEES","address_line1":"225 PICTORIA DRIVE SUITE 320","city":"CINCINNATI","state":"OH","zip":"45246","name":"HEALTHSPAN","address":"225 PICTORIA DRIVE SUITE 320, CINCINNATI, OH, 45246"},{"business_name_line1":"MULTIPLAN","compensation":106546,"services_description":"ADMINISTRATION FEES","address_line1":"115 FIFTH AVENUE","city":"NEW YORK","state":"NY","zip":"10003","name":"MULTIPLAN","address":"115 FIFTH AVENUE, NEW YORK, NY, 10003"}],"officers_directors_key_employees":[{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE-CHAIRPERSON","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true,"officer":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE (PART-YEAR)","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"TRUSTEE","average_hours_per_week":1.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":0,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":0,"individual_trustee_or_director":true},{"title":"EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR","average_hours_per_week":40.0,"reportable_comp_from_org":92769,"reportable_comp_from_related_orgs":0,"other_compensation":15422,"officer":true}]},"ScheduleB":{"attached":false,"required":false},"ScheduleD":{"land_buildings_equipment":{"total_book_value":0},"other_liabilities":{"footnote_text":true},"revenue_reconciliation":{"total_revenue_audited_financial_statements":47923913,"net_unrealized_gains_investments":-184818,"revenue_not_reported":-184818,"revenue_subtotal":48108731,"investment_expenses_not_included":21192,"revenue_not_reported_financial_statement":21192,"total_revenue_per_990":48129923},"expense_reconciliation":{"total_expenses_audited_financial_statements":52620010,"expenses_not_reported":0,"expenses_subtotal":52620010,"investment_expenses_not_included":21192,"expenses_not_reported_financial_statement":21192,"total_expenses_per_990":52641202},"supplemental_information":[{"identifier":"DESCRIPTION OF UNCERTAIN TAX POSITIONS UNDER FIN 48:","form_and_line_reference":"PART X, LINE 2:","explanation":"ACCOUNTING PRINCIPLES GENERALLY ACCEPTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA REQUIRE PLAN MANAGEMENT TO EVALUATE TAX POSITIONS TAKEN BY THE PLAN AND RECOGNIZE A TAX LIABILITY (OR ASSET) IF THE PLAN HAS TAKEN AN UNCERTAIN POSITION THAT MORE LIKELY THAN NOT WOULD NOT BE SUSTAINED UPON EXAMINATION BY THE INTERNAL REVENUE SERVICE. THE PLAN ADMINISTRATOR HAS ANALYZED THE TAX POSITIONS TAKEN BY THE PLAN, AND HAS CONCLUDED THAT, AS OF SEPTEMBER 1, 2012, THERE ARE NO UNCERTAIN POSITIONS TAKEN OR EXPECTED TO BE TAKEN THAT WOULD REQUIRE RECOGNITION OF A LIABILITY (OR ASSET) OR DISCLOSURE IN THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS. THE PLAN IS SUBJECT TO ROUTINE AUDITS BY TAXING JURISDICTIONS; HOWEVER, THERE ARE CURRENTLY NO AUDITS FOR ANY TAX PERIODS IN PROGRESS. THE PLAN ADMINISTRATOR BELIEVES THE PLAN IS NO LONGER SUBJECT TO INCOME TAX EXAMINATIONS FOR YEARS ENDED PRIOR TO DECEMBER 31, 2009."}]},"ScheduleN":{"termination_or_liquidation":{"assets_distributed":true,"liabilities_paid":true,"bonds_outstanding":false,"bond_liabilities_discharged":false,"required_to_notify_attorney_general":true,"attorney_general_notified":true},"successor_relationships":{"director_of_successor":true,"employee_of_successor":true,"owner_of_successor":false},"liquidations":[{"business_name_line1":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","distribution_date":"2012-09-01T00:00:00","description":"CASH","fair_market_value":480431,"method_of_fmv_determination":"BOOK VALUE","address_line1":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3","city":"CINCINNATI","state":"OH","zip":"45242","name":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","address":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3, CINCINNATI, OH, 45242"},{"business_name_line1":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","distribution_date":"2012-09-01T00:00:00","description":"ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE","fair_market_value":275097,"method_of_fmv_determination":"BOOK VALUE","address_line1":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3","city":"CINCINNATI","state":"OH","zip":"45242","name":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","address":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3, CINCINNATI, OH, 45242"},{"business_name_line1":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","distribution_date":"2012-09-01T00:00:00","description":"INVESTMENTS","fair_market_value":12723766,"method_of_fmv_determination":"FMV IS READILY AVAILABLE FOR PUBLICLY TRADED ASSETS","address_line1":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3","city":"CINCINNATI","state":"OH","zip":"45242","name":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","address":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3, CINCINNATI, OH, 45242"},{"business_name_line1":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","distribution_date":"2012-09-01T00:00:00","description":"ALLIED CLAIM ACCOUNT","fair_market_value":-2104985,"method_of_fmv_determination":"BOOK VALUE","address_line1":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3","city":"CINCINNATI","state":"OH","zip":"45242","name":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","address":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3, CINCINNATI, OH, 45242"},{"business_name_line1":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","distribution_date":"2012-09-01T00:00:00","description":"BENEFIT OBLIGATIONS - IBNR","fair_market_value":-8500000,"method_of_fmv_determination":"BOOK VALUE","address_line1":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3","city":"CINCINNATI","state":"OH","zip":"45242","name":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","address":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3, CINCINNATI, OH, 45242"},{"business_name_line1":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","distribution_date":"2012-09-01T00:00:00","description":"ACCOUNTS PAYABLE","fair_market_value":-5671,"method_of_fmv_determination":"BOOK VALUE","address_line1":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3","city":"CINCINNATI","state":"OH","zip":"45242","name":"OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES CONSORTIUM","address":"10999 REED HARTMAN HIGHWAY SUITE 3, CINCINNATI, OH, 45242"}],"supplemental_information":[{"explanation":"PART I, LINE 2E: STEPHANIE HEARN, BETH WEBER, ROBIN WHITE, RICHARD PACKERT, NANCY LANE, CHRISTINE COOK-POETTER, MIKE DAVIS & PATTY SPATH-MEYER"},{"explanation":"PART I, LINE 2E: THE EXISTING BOARD OF DIRECTORS CONTINUES TO DIRECT THE OPERATIONS OF BUTLER HEALTH PLAN, AS A DIVISION OF OPTIMAL HEALTH INITIATIVES. STEPHANIE HEARN CONTINUES TO FUNCTION AS EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE PLAN, BUT IS NOW AN EMPLOYEE OF SHAFELY PLAN MANAGEMENT."}]},"ScheduleR":{"tax_exempt_organizations":[{"business_name_line1":"FAIRFIELD CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","primary_activities":"PUBLIC SCHOOLING","exempt_code_section":"501(C)(1)","controlled_organization":false,"legal_domicile_state":"OH","address_line1":"211 DONALD DRIVE","city":"FAIRFIELD","state":"OH","zip":"45014","name":"FAIRFIELD CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","address":"211 DONALD DRIVE, FAIRFIELD, OH, 45014"},{"business_name_line1":"HAMILTON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","primary_activities":"PUBLIC SCHOOLING","exempt_code_section":"501(C)(1)","controlled_organization":false,"legal_domicile_state":"OH","address_line1":"533 DAYTON STREET","city":"HAMILTON","state":"OH","zip":"45012","name":"HAMILTON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","address":"533 DAYTON STREET, HAMILTON, OH, 45012"},{"business_name_line1":"LAKOTA LOCAL SCHOOLS","primary_activities":"PUBLIC SCHOOLING","exempt_code_section":"501(C)(1)","controlled_organization":false,"legal_domicile_state":"OH","address_line1":"5572 PRINCETON ROAD","city":"LIBERTY TOWNSHIP","state":"OH","zip":"45011","name":"LAKOTA LOCAL SCHOOLS","address":"5572 PRINCETON ROAD, LIBERTY TOWNSHIP, OH, 45011"}],"transaction_flags":{"dividends_from_related_organization":false,"gift_grant_or_capital_contribution_from_other_org":false,"gift_grant_or_capital_contribution_to_other_org":false,"loans_or_guarantees_from_other_org":false,"loans_or_guarantees_to_other_org":false,"performance_of_services_by_other_orgs":false,"performance_of_services_for_other_orgs":false,"sharing_of_facilities":false,"sharing_of_paid_employees":false,"reimbursement_paid_by_other_org":false,"reimbursement_paid_to_other_org":false,"rental_of_facilities_from_other_orgs":false,"rental_of_facilities_to_other_orgs":false,"purchase_of_assets_from_other_org":false,"sale_of_assets_to_other_org":false,"exchange_of_assets":false,"receipt_of_interest_annuities_rents_royalties":false,"other_transfer_from_other_org":true,"other_transfer_to_other_org":false},"transactions":[{"business_name_line1":"FAIRFIELD CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","amount_involved":5901978,"method_of_amount_determination":"CASH","transaction_type":"S","name":"FAIRFIELD CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT"},{"business_name_line1":"HAMILTON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT","amount_involved":6673033,"method_of_amount_determination":"CASH","transaction_type":"S","name":"HAMILTON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT"},{"business_name_line1":"LAKOTA LOCAL SCHOOLS","amount_involved":11132468,"method_of_amount_determination":"CASH","transaction_type":"S","name":"LAKOTA LOCAL SCHOOLS"}]},"Ratings":{"Mission Deployment Rate":{"score":null},"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":null},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Filing Consistency Score":{"score":1.0},"Grant Itemization Coverage":{"score":null},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0},"Operating Margin":{"score":-0.09373127399351958,"percentile":0.27752234166558737},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":0.0,"percentile":0.026800149493383534},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.002055253221611467,"percentile":0.9910659416376468},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Revenue Growth":{"score":-0.20463223574534836,"percentile":0.09087306934632093},"Asset Growth":{"score":-0.8241949764925214,"percentile":0.007014870474488992},"Foreign Oversight Score":{"score":null},"Major-Donor Itemization":{"score":null},"Related-Party Transparency":{"score":null},"Pay-Setting Controls":{"score":null,"weight":5,"atoms":{"Compensation committee":{"value":null},"Independent compensation consultant":{"value":null},"Form 990 of other organizations reviewed":{"value":null},"Written employment contract":{"value":null},"Compensation survey or study":{"value":null},"Board or committee approval":{"value":null}}},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":0.5555555555555556,"weight":5,"atoms":{"Conflict of interest policy":{"value":true},"Whistle blower policy":{"value":false},"Document retention policy":{"value":false},"Compensation process for CEO":{"value":false},"Compensation process for other employees":{"value":false},"Form 990 provided to governing body":{"value":true},"Minutes of governing body":{"value":true},"Audit committee":{"value":true},"Independent audit financial statements":{"value":true}}},"Categories":{"Financial Efficiency":{"score":null,"weight":45},"Transparency & Controls":{"score":1.0,"weight":20},"Accountability":{"score":0.8148148148148149,"weight":14},"Sustainability":{"score":0.2890874242711273,"weight":13},"Growth":{"score":0.06292033638904361,"weight":8}},"Overall Score":{"score":0.6485255748008075,"percentile":0.22510278333866587}},"source_xml":"201300849349300760_public.xml"},"sector":"Mutual/Membership Benefit","donation_categories":[],"zakat_policy":null},"error":null}