{"success":true,"data":{"_id":203859268,"filings":[{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["SHEPARD BARBASH","RAYMOND BROWN","GEORGE CUNNINGHAM","MARK Y HERRING","MARILYN REED","ROBERT S SPANGLER","JOHN E STONE"],"Title":["DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","SECRETARY","PRESIDENT"],"Hours":[0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,40.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Ecf was created to advance the interests of parent groups, school boards, college trustees, legislative committees, and civic organizations by gathering and disseminating information about education policy and practice","year":2022,"name":"EDUCATION CONSUMERS FOUNDATION C/O EAST TENNESSEE FOUNDATION","phone":8655241223,"website":"WWW.EDUCATION-CONSUMERS.COM","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"JOHN E STONE","year_formation":2005,"state_legal_domicile":"TN","total_volunteers":7,"tax_period_begin":"2022-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2022-12-31T00:00:00","address":"520 W SUMMIT HILL DR SUITE 1101, KNOXVILLE, TN, 37902, USA","city":"KNOXVILLE","state":"TN","country":"USA","zip_code":37902},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":7,"Number of independent voting members":7,"Number of employees total":2,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":null,"Number of employees":2,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":101809,"Contributions":{"value":100000,"Other contributions":0,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":0,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":100000},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":1570,"Investment income total":1570,"Net investment gain":0,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":239,"Other total":239,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":78558,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":52087,"Current officers":0,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":47644,"Pension plan contributions":0,"Other employee benefits":0,"Payroll taxes":4443},"Other expenses":{"value":26471,"Management services":0,"Legal":0,"Accounting":0,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":739,"Other services":17061,"Advertising":0,"Office expenses":4420,"Information technology":0,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":1381,"Travel":0,"Conferences and meetings":0,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":0,"Insurance":1144,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":1726,"ADMIN FEES TO ETF":1704,"STATE TAX":22},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":49923,"Management And General Expenses":28635,"Fundraising Expenses":0}},"Assets":{"value":181913,"Non-interest bearing cash":4901,"Savings and temp cash investments":0,"Pledges and grants receivable":0,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":0,"Investments publicly traded":177012,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":0},"Liabilities":{"value":0,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":0,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":181913,"Net assets without donor restriction":181913,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":0,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.6354922477659818,"percentile":0.5069810203571975},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Operating Margin":{"score":0.2283786305729356,"percentile":0.7829682765063702},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.0,"percentile":0.9977938754541298},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":2.3156521296367014,"percentile":0.6530310963916803},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":-0.18695441239763064,"percentile":0.09327027140508021},"Revenue Growth":{"score":-0.13696496082707052,"percentile":0.11049229097182385},"Asset Growth":{"score":-0.18631345574772937,"percentile":0.05832354639011087},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.5498212704226393,"percentile":0.4567462132400658}},"source_xml":"202343199349309124_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["SHEPARD BARBASH","GEORGE CUNNINGHAM","MARK Y HERRING","ANN MACTIER","MARILYN REED","ROBERT S SPANGLER","JOHN E STONE"],"Title":["DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","PRESIDENT"],"Hours":[0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,40.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Ecf was created to advance the interests of parent groups, school boards, college trustees, legislative committees, and civic organizations by gathering and disseminating information about education policy and practice","year":2014,"name":"EDUCATION CONSUMERS FOUNDATION C/O EAST TENNESSEE FOUNDATION","phone":8655241223,"website":"WWW.EDUCATION-CONSUMERS.COM","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"JOHN E STONE","year_formation":2005,"state_legal_domicile":"TN","total_volunteers":7,"tax_period_begin":"2014-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2014-12-31T00:00:00","address":"520 W SUMMIT HILL DR SUITE 1101, KNOXVILLE, TN, 37902, USA","city":"KNOXVILLE","state":"TN","country":"USA","zip_code":37902},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":7,"Number of independent voting members":7,"Number of employees total":1,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":null,"Number of employees":1,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":151216,"Contributions":{"value":101600,"Other contributions":101600,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":0,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":46677,"Investment income total":33894,"Net investment gain":12783,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":2939,"Other total":2939,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":331810,"Grant expense":{"value":33000,"Grants to domestic orgs":15000,"Grants to domestic individuals":18000,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":33566,"Current officers":0,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":30741,"Pension plan contributions":0,"Other employee benefits":0,"Payroll taxes":2825},"Other expenses":{"value":265244,"Management services":147218,"Legal":0,"Accounting":0,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":9190,"Other services":639,"Advertising":36124,"Office expenses":21736,"Information technology":27043,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":4296,"Travel":1748,"Conferences and meetings":3501,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":0,"Insurance":654,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":13095,"ADMINISTRATIVE FEES":13038,"STATE AND LOCAL TAXES":57},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":245846,"Management And General Expenses":71901,"Fundraising Expenses":14063}},"Assets":{"value":889101,"Non-interest bearing cash":0,"Savings and temp cash investments":0,"Pledges and grants receivable":0,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":0,"Investments publicly traded":889101,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":0},"Liabilities":{"value":365,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":0,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":365},"Fund balance":{"value":888736,"Net assets without donor restriction":0,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":888736,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.7409240227841234,"percentile":0.5654350575592308},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":7.224632013083979,"percentile":0.301057894752001},"Operating Margin":{"score":-1.194278383239869,"percentile":0.0360526947045038},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.0004105270379855607,"percentile":0.5787703221556356},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":2.6795485368132366,"percentile":0.6874209696784263},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Revenue Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Asset Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.499605235592118,"percentile":0.32059404249634477}},"source_xml":"201542269349303629_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["SHEPARD BARBASH","RAYMOND BROWN","GEORGE CUNNINGHAM","MARK Y HERRING","MARILYN REED","ROBERT S SPANGLER","JOHN E STONE"],"Title":["DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","SECRETARY","PRESIDENT"],"Hours":[0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,40.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Ecf was created to advance the interests of parent groups, school boards, college trustees, legislative committees, and civic organizations by gathering and disseminating information about education policy and practice","year":2023,"name":"EDUCATION CONSUMERS FOUNDATION C/O EAST TENNESSEE FOUNDATION","phone":8655241223,"website":"WWW.EDUCATION-CONSUMERS.COM","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"JOHN E STONE","year_formation":2005,"state_legal_domicile":"TN","total_volunteers":7,"tax_period_begin":"2023-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2023-12-31T00:00:00","address":"520 W SUMMIT HILL DR SUITE 1101, KNOXVILLE, TN, 37902, USA","city":"KNOXVILLE","state":"TN","country":"USA","zip_code":37902},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":7,"Number of independent voting members":7,"Number of employees total":2,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":null,"Number of employees":2,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":-1595,"Contributions":{"value":0,"Other contributions":0,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":0,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":-1887,"Investment income total":3360,"Net investment gain":-5247,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":292,"Other total":292,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":62891,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":39601,"Current officers":0,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":32324,"Pension plan contributions":0,"Other employee benefits":0,"Payroll taxes":7277},"Other expenses":{"value":23290,"Management services":0,"Legal":0,"Accounting":0,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":14652,"Advertising":0,"Office expenses":5296,"Information technology":0,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":1384,"Travel":0,"Conferences and meetings":0,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":0,"Insurance":104,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":1854,"ADMIN FEES TO ETF":1832,"STATE TAX":22},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":41419,"Management And General Expenses":21472,"Fundraising Expenses":0}},"Assets":{"value":128962,"Non-interest bearing cash":4302,"Savings and temp cash investments":0,"Pledges and grants receivable":0,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":0,"Investments publicly traded":124660,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":0},"Liabilities":{"value":0,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":0,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":128962,"Net assets without donor restriction":128962,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":0,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.6585838991270611,"percentile":0.5160654298212402},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Operating Margin":{"score":40.430094043887145,"percentile":0.9997988456143146},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.0,"percentile":0.9977938754541298},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":2.050563673657598,"percentile":0.6225975641129536},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":-0.17483805944300615,"percentile":0.0980787505751923},"Revenue Growth":{"score":-0.16552150004800986,"percentile":0.09220821361249391},"Asset Growth":{"score":-0.1824817156963581,"percentile":0.05965666403220565},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.5878904336327987,"percentile":0.5697823546716322}},"source_xml":"202413209349303971_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["SHEPARD BARBASH","GEORGE CUNNINGHAM","MARK Y HERRING","ANN MACTIER","MARILYN REED","ROBERT S SPANGLER","JOHN E STONE"],"Title":["DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","PRESIDENT"],"Hours":[0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,40.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Ecf was created to advance the interests of parent groups, school boards, college trustees, legislative committees, and civic organizations by gathering and disseminating information about education policy and practice","year":2017,"name":"EDUCATION CONSUMERS FOUNDATION C/O EAST TENNESSEE FOUNDATION","phone":8655241223,"website":"WWW.EDUCATION-CONSUMERS.COM","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"JOHN E STONE","year_formation":2005,"state_legal_domicile":"TN","total_volunteers":7,"tax_period_begin":"2017-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2017-12-31T00:00:00","address":"520 W SUMMIT HILL DR SUITE 1101, KNOXVILLE, TN, 37902, USA","city":"KNOXVILLE","state":"TN","country":"USA","zip_code":37902},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":7,"Number of independent voting members":7,"Number of employees total":1,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":null,"Number of employees":1,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":36232,"Contributions":{"value":1000,"Other contributions":1000,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":0,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":33187,"Investment income total":17673,"Net investment gain":15514,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":2045,"Other total":2045,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":144285,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":33190,"Current officers":0,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":30416,"Pension plan contributions":0,"Other employee benefits":0,"Payroll taxes":2774},"Other expenses":{"value":111095,"Management services":65779,"Legal":0,"Accounting":0,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":5815,"Other services":430,"Advertising":0,"Office expenses":7502,"Information technology":19032,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":4857,"Travel":209,"Conferences and meetings":0,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":0,"Insurance":665,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":6806,"ADMINISTRATIVE FEES":6768,"TAX, LIFE INS. & ANNUITY":38},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":96814,"Management And General Expenses":47471,"Fundraising Expenses":0}},"Assets":{"value":487731,"Non-interest bearing cash":6533,"Savings and temp cash investments":0,"Pledges and grants receivable":0,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":0,"Investments publicly traded":481198,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":0},"Liabilities":{"value":0,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":0,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":487731,"Net assets without donor restriction":0,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":487731,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.6709914405516859,"percentile":0.5216413040851345},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Operating Margin":{"score":-2.982253256789578,"percentile":0.018569790279739106},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.0,"percentile":0.9977938754541298},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":3.380330595696018,"percentile":0.7369563719279851},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":-0.20338396275293472,"percentile":0.08746179309186539},"Revenue Growth":{"score":-0.4067993431437571,"percentile":0.030432960389445138},"Asset Growth":{"score":-0.198299827399422,"percentile":0.05439091943623843},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.41572637177463856,"percentile":0.14768868704657223}},"source_xml":"201842989349300934_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["SHEPARD BARBASH","GEORGE CUNNINGHAM","MARK Y HERRING","ANN MACTIER","MARILYN REED","ROBERT S SPANGLER","JOHN E STONE"],"Title":["DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","PRESIDENT"],"Hours":[0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,40.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Ecf was created to advance the interests of parent groups, school boards, college trustees, legislative committees, and civic organizations by gathering and disseminating information about education policy and practice","year":2015,"name":"EDUCATION CONSUMERS FOUNDATION C/O EAST TENNESSEE FOUNDATION","phone":8655241223,"website":"WWW.EDUCATION-CONSUMERS.COM","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"JOHN E STONE","year_formation":2005,"state_legal_domicile":"TN","total_volunteers":7,"tax_period_begin":"2015-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2015-12-31T00:00:00","address":"520 W SUMMIT HILL DR SUITE 1101, KNOXVILLE, TN, 37902, USA","city":"KNOXVILLE","state":"TN","country":"USA","zip_code":37902},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":7,"Number of independent voting members":7,"Number of employees total":1,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":null,"Number of employees":1,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":26063,"Contributions":{"value":25000,"Other contributions":25000,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":0,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":-891,"Investment income total":27617,"Net investment gain":-28508,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":1954,"Other total":1954,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":179403,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":33447,"Current officers":0,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":30622,"Pension plan contributions":0,"Other employee benefits":0,"Payroll taxes":2825},"Other expenses":{"value":145956,"Management services":75685,"Legal":0,"Accounting":0,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":8534,"Other services":328,"Advertising":4336,"Office expenses":8598,"Information technology":26550,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":4384,"Travel":0,"Conferences and meetings":6180,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":0,"Insurance":653,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":10708,"ADMINISTRATIVE FEES":10686,"STATE AND LOCAL TAXES":22},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":119332,"Management And General Expenses":51900,"Fundraising Expenses":8171}},"Assets":{"value":732102,"Non-interest bearing cash":1415,"Savings and temp cash investments":0,"Pledges and grants receivable":0,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":0,"Investments publicly traded":730687,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":0},"Liabilities":{"value":5194,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":0,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":5194},"Fund balance":{"value":726908,"Net assets without donor restriction":0,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":726908,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.6651616751113415,"percentile":0.5189407732029355},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":3.0596010280259454,"percentile":0.11731024570923303},"Operating Margin":{"score":-5.8834362889920575,"percentile":0.012086790270975542},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.007094639817948865,"percentile":0.5148205685369359},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":4.080767880135784,"percentile":0.7723290151142048},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":-0.26670450900834397,"percentile":0.06962976038580944},"Revenue Growth":{"score":-0.5668903994762572,"percentile":0.01761579640360138},"Asset Growth":{"score":-0.19542862337975275,"percentile":0.0553034952354011},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.3561135548120402,"percentile":0.05823813895855577}},"source_xml":"201632249349300238_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["JOHN E STONE","GEORGE CUNNINGHAM","SHEPARD BARBASH","MARK Y HERRING","ANN MACTIER","MARILYN REED","ROBERT S SPANGLER"],"Title":["PRESIDENT","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR"],"Hours":[40.0,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Ecf was created to advance the interests of parent groups, school boards, college trustees, legislative committees, and civic organizations by gathering and disseminating information about education policy and practice","year":2013,"name":"EDUCATION CONSUMERS FOUNDATION C/O EAST TENNESSEE FOUNDATION","phone":8655241223,"website":"WWW.EDUCATION-CONSUMERS.COM","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"JOHN E STONE","year_formation":2005,"state_legal_domicile":"TN","total_volunteers":7,"tax_period_begin":"2013-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2013-12-31T00:00:00","address":"625 MARKET STREET SUITE 1400, KNOXVILLE, TN, 37902, USA","city":"KNOXVILLE","state":"TN","country":"USA","zip_code":37902},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":7,"Number of independent voting members":7,"Number of employees total":1,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":null,"Number of employees":1,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":149599,"Contributions":{"value":100000,"Other contributions":100000,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":0,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":40893,"Investment income total":20645,"Net investment gain":20248,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":8706,"Other total":8706,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":295541,"Grant expense":{"value":36000,"Grants to domestic orgs":15000,"Grants to domestic individuals":21000,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":33606,"Current officers":0,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":30781,"Pension plan contributions":0,"Other employee benefits":0,"Payroll taxes":2825},"Other expenses":{"value":225935,"Management services":81272,"Legal":0,"Accounting":0,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":8779,"Other services":218,"Advertising":75526,"Office expenses":13570,"Information technology":11809,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":4334,"Travel":5916,"Conferences and meetings":8816,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":0,"Insurance":607,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":15088,"ADMINISTRATIVE FEES":15036,"FED & STATE UBI TAX":52},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":224109,"Management And General Expenses":60051,"Fundraising Expenses":11381}},"Assets":{"value":1084634,"Non-interest bearing cash":13166,"Savings and temp cash investments":0,"Pledges and grants receivable":0,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":0,"Investments publicly traded":1071468,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":0},"Liabilities":{"value":0,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":0,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":1084634,"Net assets without donor restriction":0,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":1084634,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.7583008787274862,"percentile":0.580864073211797},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":8.786574114752659,"percentile":0.3594441996280711},"Operating Margin":{"score":-0.9755546494294748,"percentile":0.04248576277355825},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.0,"percentile":0.9977938754541298},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":3.6699950260708327,"percentile":0.7528753042231622},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Revenue Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Asset Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.548056261985546,"percentile":0.4515990075160243}},"source_xml":"201412209349300106_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["SHEPARD BARBASH","GEORGE CUNNINGHAM","MARK Y HERRING","ANN MACTIER","MARILYN REED","ROBERT S SPANGLER","JOHN E STONE"],"Title":["DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","PRESIDENT"],"Hours":[0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,40.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Ecf was created to advance the interests of parent groups, school boards, college trustees, legislative committees, and civic organizations by gathering and disseminating information about education policy and practice","year":2016,"name":"EDUCATION CONSUMERS FOUNDATION C/O EAST TENNESSEE FOUNDATION","phone":8655241223,"website":"WWW.EDUCATION-CONSUMERS.COM","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"JOHN E STONE","year_formation":2005,"state_legal_domicile":"TN","total_volunteers":7,"tax_period_begin":"2016-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2016-12-31T00:00:00","address":"520 W SUMMIT HILL DR SUITE 1101, KNOXVILLE, TN, 37902, USA","city":"KNOXVILLE","state":"TN","country":"USA","zip_code":37902},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":7,"Number of independent voting members":7,"Number of employees total":1,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":null,"Number of employees":1,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":45503,"Contributions":{"value":25000,"Other contributions":25000,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":0,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":17813,"Investment income total":22472,"Net investment gain":-4659,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":2690,"Other total":2690,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":227707,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":33362,"Current officers":0,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":30588,"Pension plan contributions":0,"Other employee benefits":0,"Payroll taxes":2774},"Other expenses":{"value":194345,"Management services":139170,"Legal":0,"Accounting":0,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":6753,"Other services":360,"Advertising":1394,"Office expenses":8485,"Information technology":24478,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":4578,"Travel":0,"Conferences and meetings":0,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":0,"Insurance":653,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":8474,"ADMINISTRATIVE FEES":8451,"STATE AND LOCAL TAXES":23},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":157348,"Management And General Expenses":59781,"Fundraising Expenses":10578}},"Assets":{"value":584519,"Non-interest bearing cash":7177,"Savings and temp cash investments":0,"Pledges and grants receivable":0,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":0,"Investments publicly traded":577342,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":0},"Liabilities":{"value":4219,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":0,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":4219},"Fund balance":{"value":580300,"Net assets without donor restriction":0,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":580300,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.6910108165317711,"percentile":0.5317697550208245},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":2.3633957269805257,"percentile":0.08898835154095106},"Operating Margin":{"score":-4.004219502010857,"percentile":0.015290382761945503},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.007217900530179515,"percentile":0.5140520096422186},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":2.566978617258143,"percentile":0.6775332495732337},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":-0.17507724657965404,"percentile":0.09797506600251414},"Revenue Growth":{"score":-0.4698854130581313,"percentile":0.024224414736225},"Asset Growth":{"score":-0.20147898889968135,"percentile":0.05340993549729213},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.35542505031822974,"percentile":0.057487396465430746}},"source_xml":"201712439349301101_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["SHEPARD BARBASH","GEORGE CUNNINGHAM","MARK Y HERRING","ANN MACTIER","MARILYN REED","ROBERT S SPANGLER","JOHN E STONE"],"Title":["DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","SECRETARY","PRESIDENT"],"Hours":[0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,40.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Ecf was created to advance the interests of parent groups, school boards, college trustees, legislative committees, and civic organizations by gathering and disseminating information about education policy and practice","year":2018,"name":"EDUCATION CONSUMERS FOUNDATION C/O EAST TENNESSEE FOUNDATION","phone":8655241223,"website":"WWW.EDUCATION-CONSUMERS.COM","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"JOHN E STONE","year_formation":2005,"state_legal_domicile":"TN","total_volunteers":7,"tax_period_begin":"2018-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2018-12-31T00:00:00","address":"520 W SUMMIT HILL DR SUITE 1101, KNOXVILLE, TN, 37902, USA","city":"KNOXVILLE","state":"TN","country":"USA","zip_code":37902},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":7,"Number of independent voting members":7,"Number of employees total":1,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":null,"Number of employees":1,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":16957,"Contributions":{"value":0,"Other contributions":0,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":0,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":16700,"Investment income total":15497,"Net investment gain":1203,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":257,"Other total":257,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":118758,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":33113,"Current officers":0,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":30390,"Pension plan contributions":0,"Other employee benefits":0,"Payroll taxes":2723},"Other expenses":{"value":85645,"Management services":43885,"Legal":0,"Accounting":0,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":5123,"Other services":62,"Advertising":0,"Office expenses":7217,"Information technology":22200,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":4493,"Travel":1861,"Conferences and meetings":45,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":0,"Insurance":722,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":37,"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":80959,"Management And General Expenses":37799,"Fundraising Expenses":0}},"Assets":{"value":356663,"Non-interest bearing cash":3155,"Savings and temp cash investments":0,"Pledges and grants receivable":0,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":0,"Investments publicly traded":353508,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":0},"Liabilities":{"value":0,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":0,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":356663,"Net assets without donor restriction":0,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":356663,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.6817140739992253,"percentile":0.5268737966535892},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Operating Margin":{"score":-6.003479389042873,"percentile":0.01194371997842125},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.0,"percentile":0.9977938754541298},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":3.0032755688037858,"percentile":0.7125977035559375},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":-0.2085962042734377,"percentile":0.08574242866972694},"Revenue Growth":{"score":-0.398278074112367,"percentile":0.031519231905250245},"Asset Growth":{"score":-0.20695179705112593,"percentile":0.05176785978125656},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.41440883233300935,"percentile":0.1454256603944138}},"source_xml":"201943159349301844_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["SHEPARD BARBASH","GEORGE CUNNINGHAM","MARK Y HERRING","ANN MACTIER","MARILYN REED","ROBERT S SPANGLER","JOHN E STONE"],"Title":["DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","SECRETARY","PRESIDENT"],"Hours":[0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,40.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Ecf was created to advance the interests of parent groups, school boards, college trustees, legislative committees, and civic organizations by gathering and disseminating information about education policy and practice","year":2020,"name":"EDUCATION CONSUMERS FOUNDATION C/O EAST TENNESSEE FOUNDATION","phone":8655241223,"website":"WWW.EDUCATION-CONSUMERS.COM","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"JOHN E STONE","year_formation":2005,"state_legal_domicile":"TN","total_volunteers":7,"tax_period_begin":"2020-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2020-12-31T00:00:00","address":"520 W SUMMIT HILL DR SUITE 1101, KNOXVILLE, TN, 37902, USA","city":"KNOXVILLE","state":"TN","country":"USA","zip_code":37902},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":7,"Number of independent voting members":7,"Number of employees total":1,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":null,"Number of employees":1,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":16188,"Contributions":{"value":0,"Other contributions":0,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":0,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":16066,"Investment income total":8802,"Net investment gain":7264,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":122,"Other total":122,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":84185,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":34798,"Current officers":0,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":31876,"Pension plan contributions":0,"Other employee benefits":0,"Payroll taxes":2922},"Other expenses":{"value":49387,"Management services":15682,"Legal":0,"Accounting":0,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":3370,"Other services":160,"Advertising":16078,"Office expenses":4470,"Information technology":2961,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":5879,"Travel":0,"Conferences and meetings":0,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":0,"Insurance":766,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":21,"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":54477,"Management And General Expenses":29708,"Fundraising Expenses":0}},"Assets":{"value":245935,"Non-interest bearing cash":0,"Savings and temp cash investments":0,"Pledges and grants receivable":0,"Accounts receivable":789,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":0,"Investments publicly traded":245146,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":0},"Liabilities":{"value":1376,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":1376,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":244559,"Net assets without donor restriction":244559,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":0,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.6471105303795213,"percentile":0.5113269638210629},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Operating Margin":{"score":-4.2004571287373365,"percentile":0.014845478988945476},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.0055949742818224325,"percentile":0.5247847953158875},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":2.9213636633604563,"percentile":0.7065862963114906},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":-0.21437511653769176,"percentile":0.08381055371846297},"Revenue Growth":{"score":-0.3313705222924238,"percentile":0.04100395005278776},"Asset Growth":{"score":-0.20181619733310854,"percentile":0.05330451967533048},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.3829264255397068,"percentile":0.09593025174271651}},"source_xml":"202143199349315719_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["SHEPARD BARBASH","HAROLD BLACK","RAYMOND BROWN","GEORGE CUNNINGHAM","MARK Y HERRING","MARILYN REED","JOHN E STONE"],"Title":["DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","PRESIDENT"],"Hours":[0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,40.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Ecf was created to advance the interests of parent groups, school boards, college trustees, legislative committees, and civic organizations by gathering and disseminating information about education policy and practice","year":2024,"name":"EDUCATION CONSUMERS FOUNDATION C/O EAST TENNESSEE FOUNDATION","phone":8655241223,"website":"WWW.EDUCATION-CONSUMERS.COM","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"JOHN E STONE","year_formation":2005,"state_legal_domicile":"TN","total_volunteers":7,"tax_period_begin":"2024-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2024-12-31T00:00:00","address":"520 W SUMMIT HILL DR SUITE 1101, KNOXVILLE, TN, 37902, USA","city":"KNOXVILLE","state":"TN","country":"USA","zip_code":37902},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":7,"Number of independent voting members":7,"Number of employees total":2,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":null,"Number of employees":2,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":39828,"Contributions":{"value":35195,"Other contributions":35195,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":0,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":4162,"Investment income total":4162,"Net investment gain":0,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":471,"Other total":471,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":52296,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":30185,"Current officers":0,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":23946,"Pension plan contributions":0,"Other employee benefits":0,"Payroll taxes":6239},"Other expenses":{"value":22111,"Management services":0,"Legal":0,"Accounting":0,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":758,"Other services":14712,"Advertising":0,"Office expenses":3815,"Information technology":0,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":1380,"Travel":0,"Conferences and meetings":0,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":0,"Insurance":0,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":1446,"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":35336,"Management And General Expenses":16960,"Fundraising Expenses":0}},"Assets":{"value":122478,"Non-interest bearing cash":3930,"Savings and temp cash investments":0,"Pledges and grants receivable":0,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":0,"Investments publicly traded":118548,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":0},"Liabilities":{"value":0,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":0,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":122478,"Net assets without donor restriction":122478,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":0,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.6756922135536179,"percentile":0.5238951366679288},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Operating Margin":{"score":-0.31304609822235613,"percentile":0.10943634177006484},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.0,"percentile":0.9977938754541298},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":2.3420146856356125,"percentile":0.6558518864917944},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":-0.1678057395592292,"percentile":0.10135895341991995},"Revenue Growth":{"score":-0.13772407693839744,"percentile":0.10995979395557094},"Asset Growth":{"score":-0.17813856961480498,"percentile":0.06125668556394801},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.4371773925063079,"percentile":0.1865137130495804}},"source_xml":"202502959349301135_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["SHEPARD BARBASH","GEORGE CUNNINGHAM","MARK Y HERRING","ANN MACTIER","MARILYN REED","ROBERT S SPANGLER","JOHN E STONE"],"Title":["DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","SECRETARY","PRESIDENT"],"Hours":[0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,40.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Ecf was created to advance the interests of parent groups, school boards, college trustees, legislative committees, and civic organizations by gathering and disseminating information about education policy and practice","year":2019,"name":"EDUCATION CONSUMERS FOUNDATION C/O EAST TENNESSEE FOUNDATION","phone":8655241223,"website":"WWW.EDUCATION-CONSUMERS.COM","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"JOHN E STONE","year_formation":2005,"state_legal_domicile":"TN","total_volunteers":7,"tax_period_begin":"2019-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2019-12-31T00:00:00","address":"520 W SUMMIT HILL DR SUITE 1101, KNOXVILLE, TN, 37902, USA","city":"KNOXVILLE","state":"TN","country":"USA","zip_code":37902},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":7,"Number of independent voting members":7,"Number of employees total":1,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":null,"Number of employees":1,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":22348,"Contributions":{"value":0,"Other contributions":0,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":0,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":20544,"Investment income total":13299,"Net investment gain":7245,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":1804,"Other total":1804,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":83935,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":33124,"Current officers":0,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":30401,"Pension plan contributions":0,"Other employee benefits":0,"Payroll taxes":2723},"Other expenses":{"value":50811,"Management services":8780,"Legal":0,"Accounting":0,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":4083,"Other services":142,"Advertising":0,"Office expenses":4139,"Information technology":23739,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":4704,"Travel":196,"Conferences and meetings":0,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":0,"Insurance":729,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":4299,"ADMIN FEES TO ETF":4284,"STATE TAX":15},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":53634,"Management And General Expenses":30301,"Fundraising Expenses":0}},"Assets":{"value":316969,"Non-interest bearing cash":3106,"Savings and temp cash investments":0,"Pledges and grants receivable":0,"Accounts receivable":2182,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":0,"Investments publicly traded":311681,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":0},"Liabilities":{"value":2182,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":2182,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":314787,"Net assets without donor restriction":314787,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":0,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.6389944599988086,"percentile":0.5082355215776627},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Operating Margin":{"score":-2.7558170753534994,"percentile":0.019552736178584332},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.00688395395133278,"percentile":0.5161184334508294},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":3.776362661583368,"percentile":0.7582408277335524},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":-0.22077707296823657,"percentile":0.08186111237265435},"Revenue Growth":{"score":-0.3572651690711246,"percentile":0.03694638998099305},"Asset Growth":{"score":-0.20285658191813097,"percentile":0.05299724376876142},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.3847472770218164,"percentile":0.09853385230691329}},"source_xml":"202003219349308320_public.xml"}],"Latest":{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["SHEPARD BARBASH","HAROLD BLACK","RAYMOND BROWN","GEORGE CUNNINGHAM","MARK Y HERRING","MARILYN REED","JOHN E STONE"],"Title":["DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","DIRECTOR","PRESIDENT"],"Hours":[0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,0.2,40.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"Ecf was created to advance the interests of parent groups, school boards, college trustees, legislative committees, and civic organizations by gathering and disseminating information about education policy and practice","year":2024,"name":"EDUCATION CONSUMERS FOUNDATION C/O EAST TENNESSEE FOUNDATION","phone":8655241223,"website":"WWW.EDUCATION-CONSUMERS.COM","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"JOHN E STONE","year_formation":2005,"state_legal_domicile":"TN","total_volunteers":7,"tax_period_begin":"2024-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2024-12-31T00:00:00","address":"520 W SUMMIT HILL DR SUITE 1101, KNOXVILLE, TN, 37902, USA","city":"KNOXVILLE","state":"TN","country":"USA","zip_code":37902},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":7,"Number of independent voting members":7,"Number of employees total":2,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":null,"Number of employees":2,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":39828,"Contributions":{"value":35195,"Other contributions":35195,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":0,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":4162,"Investment income total":4162,"Net investment gain":0,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":471,"Other total":471,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":52296,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":30185,"Current officers":0,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":23946,"Pension plan contributions":0,"Other employee benefits":0,"Payroll taxes":6239},"Other expenses":{"value":22111,"Management services":0,"Legal":0,"Accounting":0,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":758,"Other services":14712,"Advertising":0,"Office expenses":3815,"Information technology":0,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":1380,"Travel":0,"Conferences and meetings":0,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":0,"Insurance":0,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":1446,"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":35336,"Management And General Expenses":16960,"Fundraising Expenses":0}},"Assets":{"value":122478,"Non-interest bearing cash":3930,"Savings and temp cash investments":0,"Pledges and grants receivable":0,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":0,"Land, building, equipment":0,"Investments publicly traded":118548,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":0},"Liabilities":{"value":0,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":0,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":122478,"Net assets without donor restriction":122478,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":0,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.6756922135536179,"percentile":0.5238951366679288},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Operating Margin":{"score":-0.31304609822235613,"percentile":0.10943634177006484},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.0,"percentile":0.9977938754541298},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":2.3420146856356125,"percentile":0.6558518864917944},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":-0.1678057395592292,"percentile":0.10135895341991995},"Revenue Growth":{"score":-0.13772407693839744,"percentile":0.10995979395557094},"Asset Growth":{"score":-0.17813856961480498,"percentile":0.06125668556394801},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.4371773925063079,"percentile":0.1865137130495804}},"source_xml":"202502959349301135_public.xml"},"sector":"Public, Societal Benefit","donation_categories":[],"zakat_policy":null},"error":null}