{"success":true,"data":{"_id":130576141,"filings":[{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["EDWARD SKYLER","Michael J Kuh","Merryl h Tisch","Alair A Townsend","Anthony Mannarino","Edward Wallace","Lawrence B Buttenwieser","William Floyd","KENNETH D GIBBS","Walter L Harris","Jake Elghanayan","H Dale Hemmerdinger","Brian T Horey","David A Javdan","Eugene J Keilin","James L Lipscomb","Haeda Mihaltses","Calvin A Mitchell III","Marissa Shorenstein","Claudia Wagner","Ronald G Weiner","Lawrence Huntington","Richard Levine","Richard Ravitch","CAROL KELLERMAN","MARIA DOULIS","charles m brecher","david j friedfel"],"Title":["CHAIR","Vice Chair","Vice Chair","Treasurer","Secretary","GENERAL COUNCIL","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","Trustee","trustee - as of 1/1/2016","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE - THRU 12/31/2016","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","trustee - as of 1/1/2016","Trustee","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","Trustee","Trustee","trustee","trustee","PRESIDENT","Vice President","director of research","director of state studies"],"Hours":[2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,40.0,40.0,40.0,40.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,267535,156740,171506,107901],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,251085,146940,160713,107901],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,16450,9800,10793,0]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"The citizens budget commission is a not-for-profit organization devoted to influencing constructive change in the finances and services of new york city and state governments.","year":2016,"name":"CITIZENS BUDGET COMMISSION INC","phone":2122792605,"website":"WWW.CBCNY.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"CAROL KELLERMANN","year_formation":1932,"state_legal_domicile":"NY","total_volunteers":0,"tax_period_begin":"2016-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2016-12-31T00:00:00","address":"2 PENN PLAZA 5TH FLOOR, NEW YORK, NY, 10121, USA","city":"NEW YORK","state":"NY","country":"USA","zip_code":10121},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":24,"Number of independent voting members":23,"Number of employees total":17,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":null,"Number of employees":17,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":2520556,"Contributions":{"value":2366207,"Other contributions":1113257,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":1252950,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":154010,"Investment income total":143508,"Net investment gain":10502,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":339,"Other total":339,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":2334294,"Grant expense":{"value":39754,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":39754,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":1448954,"Current officers":703680,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":548338,"Pension plan contributions":58834,"Other employee benefits":48646,"Payroll taxes":89456},"Other expenses":{"value":845586,"Management services":0,"Legal":0,"Accounting":45056,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":291574,"Advertising":15336,"Office expenses":5264,"Information technology":44447,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":277336,"Travel":17374,"Conferences and meetings":68815,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":45601,"Insurance":0,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":34783,"POSTAGE":4552,"MAINTENANCE SERVICE CONTRACTS":3587,"PRINTING AND REPRODUCTION":15134,"MISCELLANEOUS":11510},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":1932196,"Management And General Expenses":236856,"Fundraising Expenses":165242}},"Assets":{"value":7343180,"Non-interest bearing cash":112599,"Savings and temp cash investments":292692,"Pledges and grants receivable":62750,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":55466,"Land, building, equipment":9741,"Investments publicly traded":6611424,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":198508},"Liabilities":{"value":153745,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":85708,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":68037},"Fund balance":{"value":7189435,"Net assets without donor restriction":0,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":6497990,"Temporarily restricted net assets":691445,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.8277432062970645,"percentile":0.6614967413983389},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":14.319646336887716,"percentile":0.5070319902995112},"Operating Margin":{"score":0.07389718776333476,"percentile":0.575148486379484},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.020937114438158946,"percentile":0.4545898861582379},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":3.1457819794764497,"percentile":0.7223360782044755},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.3014538871281852,"percentile":0.18571197633070205},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.059928803099744354,"percentile":0.5670059408689453},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.04811777754958811,"percentile":0.5983401883225252},"Asset Growth":{"score":0.05732412335862674,"percentile":0.5541880780873308},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":0.9583333333333334,"percentile":0.2714375745279776},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.5717593976451507,"percentile":0.5221514032025147}},"source_xml":"201732989349300343_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["EDWARD SKYLER","Walter L Harris","Calvin A Mitchell III","Merryl h Tisch","Alair A Townsend","Edward Wallace","Anthony Mannarino","Brian T Horey","Denise Richardson","David Javdan","Claudia Wagner","DAVID S WINTER","Lawrence Buttenwieser","H Dale Hemmerdinger","Eugene J Keilin","James L Lipscomb","Ronald G Weiner","KENNETH GIBBS","IRENE BAKER","DAVID R GREENBAUM","LES BLUESTONE","CAROL KELLERMAN","ELIZABETH LYNAM"],"Title":["CHAIR - EFFECTIVE 1/1/2014","VICE CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","Vice-Chair","Treasurer","General Counsel","Secretary","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","Trustee","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE - EFFECTIVE 1/1/2014","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE - RESIGNED 10/6/2014","PRESIDENT","VICE PRESIDENT"],"Hours":[2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,40.0,40.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,251450,151940],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,235000,142000],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,16450,9940]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"The citizens budget commission is a not-for-profit organization devoted to influencing constructive change in the finances and services of new york city and state governments.","year":2014,"name":"CITIZENS BUDGET COMMISSION INC","phone":2122792605,"website":"WWW.CBCNY.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"CAROL KELLERMANN","year_formation":1932,"state_legal_domicile":"NY","total_volunteers":5,"tax_period_begin":"2014-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2014-12-31T00:00:00","address":"2 PENN PLAZA 5TH FLOOR, NEW YORK, NY, 10121, USA","city":"NEW YORK","state":"NY","country":"USA","zip_code":10121},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":20,"Number of independent voting members":19,"Number of employees total":17,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":null,"Number of employees":17,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":2682914,"Contributions":{"value":2521983,"Other contributions":1220165,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":1301818,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":156996,"Investment income total":154939,"Net investment gain":2057,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":3935,"Other total":3935,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":2160892,"Grant expense":{"value":9144,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":9144,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":1281720,"Current officers":403390,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":687573,"Pension plan contributions":31137,"Other employee benefits":84267,"Payroll taxes":75353},"Other expenses":{"value":886576,"Management services":0,"Legal":0,"Accounting":44475,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":415706,"Advertising":7234,"Office expenses":4958,"Information technology":31848,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":234055,"Travel":9081,"Conferences and meetings":62660,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":23439,"Insurance":0,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":36572,"POSTAGE AND MESSENGER":1839,"MAINTENANCE SERVICE CONTRACTS":2610,"PRINTING AND REPRODUCTION":9241,"MISCELLANEOUS":22882},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":1822733,"Management And General Expenses":184342,"Fundraising Expenses":153817}},"Assets":{"value":6788049,"Non-interest bearing cash":19649,"Savings and temp cash investments":248061,"Pledges and grants receivable":211715,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":50867,"Land, building, equipment":67130,"Investments publicly traded":6190627,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":0},"Liabilities":{"value":136305,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":70550,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":65755},"Fund balance":{"value":6651744,"Net assets without donor restriction":0,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":5751466,"Temporarily restricted net assets":900278,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.8435095321746761,"percentile":0.6835658124753289},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":16.395996541344584,"percentile":0.544911323669327},"Operating Margin":{"score":0.19457276677523022,"percentile":0.7507939687923338},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.02008014379389424,"percentile":0.45732101508767964},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":3.1413180297765924,"percentile":0.722052139954679},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.18667753872012113,"percentile":0.3371580725619485},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Revenue Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Asset Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":0.95,"percentile":0.26754433258506266},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.6266965525529672,"percentile":0.6811068272170352}},"source_xml":"201502879349300630_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["EDWARD SKYLER","Michael J Kuh","Merryl h Tisch","Alair A Townsend","Anthony Mannarino","Edward Wallace","RENEE BOICOURT","LAWRENCE B BUTTENWIESER","JAKE ELGHANAYAN","WILLIAM FLOYD","KENNETH D GIBBS","WALTER L HARRIS","H DALE HEMMERDINGER","ROBERT HOGLUND","LAWRENCE HUTTINGTON","DAVID A JAVDAN","EUGENE J KEILIN","RICHARD LEVINE","JAMES L LIPSOMB","HAEDA MIHALTSES","CALVIN A MITCHELL III","RICHARD RAVITCH","MARISSA SHORENSTEIN","CLAUDIA WAGNER","RONALD G WEINER","CAROL KELLERMANN","MARIA DOULIS","CHARLES BRECHER","DAVID J FREIDFEL","TIMOTHY SULLIVAN","ANA CHAMPENY"],"Title":["CHAIR","Vice Chair","Vice Chair","Treasurer","Secretary","GENERAL Counsel","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","Trustee","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","Trustee","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE (TO 3/2017)","PRESIDENT","VICE PRESIDENT","SENIOR ADVISOR HEALTH POLICY","DIRECTOR OF STATE STUDIES","SENIOR RESEARCH ADVISOR","DIRECTOR OF CITY STUDIES"],"Hours":[2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,40.0,40.0,40.0,40.0,40.0,40.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,272450,139297,130845,120000,114112,103194],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,256000,129807,122311,120000,114112,103194],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,16450,9490,8534,0,0,0]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"The citizens budget commission is a not-for-profit organization devoted to influencing constructive change in the finances and services of new york city and state governments.","year":2017,"name":"CITIZENS BUDGET COMMISSION INC","phone":2122792605,"website":"WWW.CBCNY.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"CAROL KELLERMANN","year_formation":1932,"state_legal_domicile":"NY","total_volunteers":0,"tax_period_begin":"2017-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2017-12-31T00:00:00","address":"2 PENN PLAZA 5TH FLOOR, NEW YORK, NY, 10121, USA","city":"NEW YORK","state":"NY","country":"USA","zip_code":10121},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":25,"Number of independent voting members":24,"Number of employees total":15,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":15,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":2964911,"Contributions":{"value":2852775,"Other contributions":1291900,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":1560875,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":112136,"Investment income total":131529,"Net investment gain":-19393,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":0,"Other total":0,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":2762216,"Grant expense":{"value":44303,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":44303,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":1597587,"Current officers":256000,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":1130206,"Pension plan contributions":51028,"Other employee benefits":60525,"Payroll taxes":99828},"Other expenses":{"value":1120326,"Management services":0,"Legal":0,"Accounting":45619,"Lobbying services":4273,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":540528,"Advertising":66203,"Office expenses":3623,"Information technology":44329,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":296369,"Travel":15297,"Conferences and meetings":4712,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":63566,"Insurance":0,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":35807,"POSTAGE":2512,"MAINTENANCE SERVICE CONTRACTS":2042,"PRINTING AND REPRODUCTION":9208,"MISCELLANEOUS":22045},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":2334544,"Management And General Expenses":253966,"Fundraising Expenses":173706}},"Assets":{"value":8165306,"Non-interest bearing cash":90464,"Savings and temp cash investments":531647,"Pledges and grants receivable":47950,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":56413,"Land, building, equipment":1814,"Investments publicly traded":7270799,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":166219},"Liabilities":{"value":105636,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":60278,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":45358},"Fund balance":{"value":8059670,"Net assets without donor restriction":0,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":7307058,"Temporarily restricted net assets":752612,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.8451706890409729,"percentile":0.6859467264949691},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":16.423007840834515,"percentile":0.5453788749391559},"Operating Margin":{"score":0.0683646153290942,"percentile":0.5640293567196876},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.012937175900082618,"percentile":0.48435986746046183},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":2.956070777955091,"percentile":0.7091762981687094},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.3185478615720132,"percentile":0.17063637611248972},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.07709397728578458,"percentile":0.6197475409189881},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.025317386922761743,"percentile":0.4915459799414925},"Asset Growth":{"score":0.06722165476221123,"percentile":0.5885427019589119},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":0.96,"percentile":0.27222779639407124},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.5786191130454429,"percentile":0.5423422565831457}},"source_xml":"201803049349301190_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["ANDREW S REIN","MARIA DOULIS","ANA CHAMPENY","DAVID J FREIDFEL","WALTER L HARRIS","Michael J Kuh","MARISSA SHORENSTEIN","EDWARD WALLACE","DAVID A JAVDAN","MELISSA BURCH","ALAIR A TOWSEND","LAWRENCE B BUTTENWIES","JAKE ELGHANAYAN","WILLIAM FLOYD","KENNETH D GIBBS","EDWARD SKYLER","H DALE HEMMERDINGER","ROBERT HOGLUND","LAWRENCE HUNTINGTON","MERRYL H TISCH","EUGENE J KEILIN","RICHARD LEVINE","JAMES L LIPSCOMB","HAEDA MIHALTSES","RICHARD RAVITCH","RENEE BOICOURT","CASWELL HOLLOWAY","RICHARD ROBERTS","ANTHONY MANNARINO"],"Title":["PRESIDENT","VICE PRESIDENT","DIRECTOR OF CITY STUDIES","DIRECTOR OF STATE STUDIES","CHAIR","Vice Chair","Vice Chair","VICE CHAIR","TREASURER","SECRETARY","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","Trustee","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE"],"Hours":[40.0,40.0,40.0,40.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"Total Compensation":[292781,195987,150722,133030,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Direct compensation":[274581,183387,115399,124000,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Other compensation":[18200,12600,35323,9030,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"The citizens budget commission is a not-for-profit organization devoted to influencing constructive change in the finances and services of new york city and state governments.","year":2019,"name":"CITIZENS BUDGET COMMISSION INC","phone":2122792605,"website":"WWW.CBCNY.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"ANDREW S REIN","year_formation":1932,"state_legal_domicile":"NY","total_volunteers":0,"tax_period_begin":"2019-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2019-12-31T00:00:00","address":"240 WEST 35TH STREET Suite STE 302, NEW YORK, NY, 10001, USA","city":"NEW YORK","state":"NY","country":"USA","zip_code":10001},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":25,"Number of independent voting members":25,"Number of employees total":18,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":null,"Number of employees":18,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":2976696,"Contributions":{"value":2748429,"Other contributions":1247519,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":1500910,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":224327,"Investment income total":188030,"Net investment gain":36297,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":3940,"Other total":3940,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":2655358,"Grant expense":{"value":52065,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":52065,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":1711018,"Current officers":292781,"Disqualified persons":20000,"Other salaries and wages":1149203,"Pension plan contributions":60830,"Other employee benefits":89224,"Payroll taxes":98980},"Other expenses":{"value":892275,"Management services":0,"Legal":0,"Accounting":47844,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":305180,"Advertising":77146,"Office expenses":2984,"Information technology":40048,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":299421,"Travel":18928,"Conferences and meetings":2372,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":51707,"Insurance":0,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":46645,"POSTAGE":2817,"MAINTENANCE SERVICE CONTRACTS":3464,"PRINTING AND REPRODUCTION":12231,"MISCELLANEOUS":28133},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":2188060,"Management And General Expenses":263408,"Fundraising Expenses":203890}},"Assets":{"value":9497544,"Non-interest bearing cash":63500,"Savings and temp cash investments":435191,"Pledges and grants receivable":71500,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":181343,"Land, building, equipment":99305,"Investments publicly traded":8581876,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":64829},"Liabilities":{"value":92615,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":92615,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":0},"Fund balance":{"value":9404929,"Net assets without donor restriction":8378434,"Net assets with donor restriction":1026495,"Unrestricted net assets":0,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.8240169498802045,"percentile":0.6564765211507012},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":13.47995978223552,"percentile":0.48946857565834},"Operating Margin":{"score":0.10795123183556533,"percentile":0.6366438481098926},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.009751468379614771,"percentile":0.4995686074007797},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":3.5767470902228626,"percentile":0.7479986395214964},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.2909287561225266,"percentile":0.19571272356629665},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.05800911142463308,"percentile":0.5603632730391833},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.014648718737020894,"percentile":0.43761259918176876},"Asset Growth":{"score":0.06765615431292345,"percentile":0.5899865622863122},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.6208049739111358,"percentile":0.6649582641969625}},"source_xml":"202032699349301513_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["MARISSA SHORENSTEIN","JAKE ELGHANAYAN","WILLIAM FLOYD","CAROL ROSENTHAL","EDWARD WALLACE","MERRYL H TISCH","ROBERT HOGLUND","ELAINE BRENNAN","PAULA DAGEN","KENT HITESHEW","SHARI HYMAN","DAVID A JAVDAN","ANTHONY MANNARINO","RICHARD ROBERTS","SALLY ROCKER","ALAIR TOWNSEND","ANDREW S REIN","ANA B CHAMPENY","PATRICK ORECKI","MICHAEL P VAUGHN","SEAN T CAMPION","KEVIN MEDINA"],"Title":["CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","GENERAL COUNSEL","SECRETARY","TREASURER","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","PRESIDENT","VICE PRESIDENT FOR RESEARCH","DIRECTOR OF STATE STUDIES","VICE PRESIDENT FOR COMMUNICATIONS & STRATEGY","DIRECTOR OF HOUSING AND ECONOMIC STUDIES","DIRECTOR OF OPERATIONS"],"Hours":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,40.0,40.0,40.0,40.0,40.0,1.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,349548,249039,167222,126708,150281,116026],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,328548,200955,144171,119313,140334,108816],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,21000,48084,23051,7395,9947,7210]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"To influence constructive change in the finances and services of new york city and state governments.","year":2024,"name":"CITIZENS BUDGET COMMISSION INC","phone":2122792605,"website":"WWW.CBCNY.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"ANDREW S REIN","year_formation":1932,"state_legal_domicile":"NY","total_volunteers":0,"tax_period_begin":"2024-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2024-12-31T00:00:00","address":"240 WEST 35TH STREET SUITE 302, NEW YORK, NY, 10001, USA","city":"NEW YORK","state":"NY","country":"USA","zip_code":10001},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":16,"Number of independent voting members":16,"Number of employees total":18,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":18,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":3918802,"Contributions":{"value":3000480,"Other contributions":1337052,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":1663428,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":913293,"Investment income total":383376,"Net investment gain":529917,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":5029,"Other total":5029,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":3101789,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":4000,"Fundraising professional":4000,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":2088904,"Current officers":349548,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":1432407,"Pension plan contributions":50388,"Other employee benefits":124243,"Payroll taxes":132318},"Other expenses":{"value":1008885,"Management services":0,"Legal":0,"Accounting":111164,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":352041,"Advertising":16501,"Office expenses":5961,"Information technology":51092,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":304469,"Travel":7525,"Conferences and meetings":103143,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":11182,"Insurance":12413,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":33394,"MISCELLANEOUS":16826,"PRINTING/REPRODUCTION":8213,"RECRUITMENT":5554,"MAINTENANCE CONTRACTS":2801},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":2201556,"Management And General Expenses":461030,"Fundraising Expenses":439203}},"Assets":{"value":15626012,"Non-interest bearing cash":515628,"Savings and temp cash investments":16847,"Pledges and grants receivable":26000,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":206550,"Land, building, equipment":55909,"Investments publicly traded":13438473,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":1366605},"Liabilities":{"value":1644422,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":95403,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":1549019},"Fund balance":{"value":13981590,"Net assets without donor restriction":13203565,"Net assets with donor restriction":778025,"Unrestricted net assets":0,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.7097697490061381,"percentile":0.5431218934529899},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":6.831647324813355,"percentile":0.28500274098331696},"Operating Margin":{"score":0.20848539936439758,"percentile":0.7646703605432513},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.10523619206231251,"percentile":0.32050851887721576},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":5.037741767734684,"percentile":0.8073322354387674},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.37359859100667386,"percentile":0.13030616635417894},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.016536170612083734,"percentile":0.39001423306406763},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.0228882441934886,"percentile":0.4793646207526574},"Asset Growth":{"score":0.08936669330516663,"percentile":0.6554046495666878},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.5715432199854673,"percentile":0.5214924536780483}},"source_xml":"202532939349301103_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["IRENE BAKER","Lawrence B Buttenwieser","William Floyd","KENNETH D GIBBS","Walter L Harris","H Dale Hemmerdinger","Brian T Horey","David A Javdan","Eugene J Keilin","Michael J Kuh","James L Lipscomb","Anthony Mannarino","Calvin A Mitchell III","Haeda Mihaltses","Denise Richardson","EDWARD SKYLER","Merryl h Tisch","Alair A Townsend","Marissa Shorenstein","Claudia Wagner","Edward Wallace","Ronald G Weiner","CAROL KELLERMAN","MARIA DOULIS","MICHAEL DARDIA"],"Title":["TRUSTEE - RESIGNED 12/31/2015","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","Trustee","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","Vice Chair","TRUSTEE","Secretary","Trustee","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE - RESIGNED 11-4-2015","CHAIR","Vice Chair","Treasurer","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","GENERAL COUNCIL","Trustee","PRESIDENT","Vice President","Co-Research Director"],"Hours":[2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,40.0,40.0,40.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,262537,124347,207270],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,246087,116095,193620],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,16450,8252,13650]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"The citizens budget commission is a not-for-profit organization devoted to influencing constructive change in the finances and services of new york city and state governments.","year":2015,"name":"CITIZENS BUDGET COMMISSION INC","phone":2122792605,"website":"WWW.CBCNY.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"CAROL KELLERMANN","year_formation":1932,"state_legal_domicile":"NY","total_volunteers":5,"tax_period_begin":"2015-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2015-12-31T00:00:00","address":"2 PENN PLAZA 5TH FLOOR, NEW YORK, NY, 10121, USA","city":"NEW YORK","state":"NY","country":"USA","zip_code":10121},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":21,"Number of independent voting members":20,"Number of employees total":16,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":null,"Number of employees":16,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":4069761,"Contributions":{"value":2414743,"Other contributions":1248560,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":1166183,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":1654975,"Investment income total":181932,"Net investment gain":1473043,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":43,"Other total":43,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":2410255,"Grant expense":{"value":38599,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":38599,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":1532668,"Current officers":494628,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":843087,"Pension plan contributions":38179,"Other employee benefits":63723,"Payroll taxes":93051},"Other expenses":{"value":838988,"Management services":0,"Legal":0,"Accounting":45656,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":280159,"Advertising":9760,"Office expenses":2842,"Information technology":54910,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":277216,"Travel":21179,"Conferences and meetings":84456,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":37370,"Insurance":0,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":25440,"POSTAGE":2456,"MAINTENANCE SERVICE CONTRACTS":1980,"PRINTING AND REPRODUCTION":9643,"MISCELLANEOUS":11361},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":2048069,"Management And General Expenses":200778,"Fundraising Expenses":161408}},"Assets":{"value":6860997,"Non-interest bearing cash":50697,"Savings and temp cash investments":480436,"Pledges and grants receivable":100750,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":52613,"Land, building, equipment":25079,"Investments publicly traded":6056106,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":95316},"Liabilities":{"value":139076,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":72180,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":66896},"Fund balance":{"value":6721921,"Net assets without donor restriction":0,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":5942254,"Temporarily restricted net assets":779667,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.8497312525023286,"percentile":0.692636124157154},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":14.960491425455988,"percentile":0.519439860137846},"Operating Margin":{"score":0.40776497686227764,"percentile":0.8879832978680692},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.020270523365627475,"percentile":0.45670219407996615},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":2.8465855272574894,"percentile":0.7009376429164278},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.24651084636272924,"percentile":0.24549228906589202},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.11229956138176457,"percentile":0.6990623829799631},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.25252396250291753,"percentile":0.9277234688681023},"Asset Growth":{"score":0.05981288064564,"percentile":0.5630690807263711},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":0.9523809523809523,"percentile":0.26871938838914583},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.669545045067401,"percentile":0.7880384362557828}},"source_xml":"201602949349300505_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["KEVIN MEDINA","MARISSA SHORENSTEIN","JAKE ELGHANAYAN","WILLIAM FLOYD","CAROL ROSENTHAL","EDWARD WALLACE","KENT HITESHEW","ALAIR TOWNSEND","ELAINE BRENNAN","PAULA DAGEN","ROBERT HOGLUND","CASWELL HOLLOWAY","SHARI HYMAN","DAVID A JAVDAN","ANTHONY MANNARINO","RICHARD ROBERTS","JAMIE RUBIN","MERRYL H TISCH","ANDREW S REIN","ANA CHAMPENY","PATRICK ORECKI","SEAN T CAMPION"],"Title":["DIRECTOR OF OPERATIONS","CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","GENERAL COUNSEL","SECRETARY","TREASURER","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE (THRU 9/2023)","TRUSTEE","PRESIDENT","VICE PRESIDENT FOR RESEARCH","DIRECTOR OF STATE STUDIES","DIRECTOR OF HOUSING AND ECONOMIC STUDIES"],"Hours":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,40.0,40.0,40.0,40.0],"Total Compensation":[108866,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,328416,237186,160414,133346],"Direct compensation":[101866,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,308466,191862,138659,124364],"Other compensation":[7000,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,19950,45324,21755,8982]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"To influence constructive change in the finances and services of new york city and state governments.","year":2023,"name":"CITIZENS BUDGET COMMISSION INC","phone":2122792605,"website":"WWW.CBCNY.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"ANDREW S REIN","year_formation":1932,"state_legal_domicile":"NY","total_volunteers":0,"tax_period_begin":"2023-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2023-12-31T00:00:00","address":"240 WEST 35TH STREET SUITE 302, NEW YORK, NY, 10001, USA","city":"NEW YORK","state":"NY","country":"USA","zip_code":10001},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":16,"Number of independent voting members":16,"Number of employees total":15,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":15,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":3603182,"Contributions":{"value":3053581,"Other contributions":1343360,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":1710221,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":546804,"Investment income total":212452,"Net investment gain":334352,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":2797,"Other total":2797,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":3127974,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":6000,"Fundraising professional":6000,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":1635864,"Current officers":328417,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":1077925,"Pension plan contributions":40531,"Other employee benefits":86879,"Payroll taxes":102112},"Other expenses":{"value":1486110,"Management services":0,"Legal":0,"Accounting":121985,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":803788,"Advertising":15907,"Office expenses":20209,"Information technology":46413,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":302296,"Travel":16281,"Conferences and meetings":114961,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":12537,"Insurance":9842,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":21891,"MISCELLANEOUS":11279,"RECRUITMENT":5060,"MAINTENANCE CONTRACTS":3031,"PRINTING/REPRODUCTION":2521},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":2376288,"Management And General Expenses":428374,"Fundraising Expenses":323312}},"Assets":{"value":14357467,"Non-interest bearing cash":322249,"Savings and temp cash investments":16844,"Pledges and grants receivable":144000,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":243056,"Land, building, equipment":67091,"Investments publicly traded":11949465,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":1614762},"Liabilities":{"value":1953607,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":162419,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":1791188},"Fund balance":{"value":12403860,"Net assets without donor restriction":11689375,"Net assets with donor restriction":714485,"Unrestricted net assets":0,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.7596891790021273,"percentile":0.582123206560705},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":9.444688103132577,"percentile":0.38155447836351297},"Operating Margin":{"score":0.13188564996161725,"percentile":0.6736085649784712},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.13606905730655694,"percentile":0.2941306845090318},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":4.590021208616184,"percentile":0.7924478084109987},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.30953837851593397,"percentile":0.17827820313770576},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.019149241170966,"percentile":0.4013278480481165},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.014504928573906452,"percentile":0.43688804488205135},"Asset Growth":{"score":0.08783524466424958,"percentile":0.6511801665738204},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.5751469527141903,"percentile":0.532148637414374}},"source_xml":"202413179349304986_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["WALTER L HARRIS","WILLIAM FLOYD","MARISSA SHORENSTEIN","JAKE ELGHANAYAN","DAVID A JAVDAN","MELISSA BURCH THRU 42022","KENT HITESHEW","EDWARD WALLACE","PAULA DAGEN","ROBERT HOGLUND","CASWELL HOLLOWAY","ANTHONY MANNARINO","RICHARD ROBERTS","CAROL E ROSENTAHL","JAMIE RUBIN","MERRYL H TISCH","ALAIR A TOWSEND","ANDREW S REIN","ANA CHAMPENY","PATRICK ORECKI","SEAN T CAMPION"],"Title":["CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","TREASURER","SECRETARY","SECRETARY","GENERAL COUNSEL","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","PRESIDENT","DIRECTOR OF CITY STUDIES","DIRECTOR OF STATE STUDIES","DIRECTOR OF HOUSING & ECONOMIC STUDIES"],"Hours":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,40.0,40.0,40.0,40.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,318501,210440,137598,108826],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,299310,168989,118086,101377],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,19191,41451,19512,7449]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"To influence constructive change in the finances and services of new york city and state governments.","year":2022,"name":"CITIZENS BUDGET COMMISSION INC","phone":2122792605,"website":"WWW.CBCNY.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"ANDREW S REIN","year_formation":1932,"state_legal_domicile":"NY","total_volunteers":0,"tax_period_begin":"2022-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2022-12-31T00:00:00","address":"240 WEST 35TH STREET SUITE 302, NEW YORK, NY, 10001, USA","city":"NEW YORK","state":"NY","country":"USA","zip_code":10001},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":16,"Number of independent voting members":16,"Number of employees total":17,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":17,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":3396278,"Contributions":{"value":3139727,"Other contributions":1446180,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":1693547,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":256551,"Investment income total":256551,"Net investment gain":0,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":0,"Other total":0,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":2509631,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":58000,"Fundraising professional":58000,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":1477226,"Current officers":318502,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":950789,"Pension plan contributions":34512,"Other employee benefits":80827,"Payroll taxes":92596},"Other expenses":{"value":974405,"Management services":0,"Legal":0,"Accounting":71197,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":273278,"Advertising":98214,"Office expenses":3058,"Information technology":74402,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":307287,"Travel":9444,"Conferences and meetings":0,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":11775,"Insurance":0,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":123479,"RECRUITMENT":69234,"MISCELLANEOUS":40678,"PRINTING/REPRODUCTION":11003,"MAINTENANCE CONTRACTS":2564},"All other expenses":2271},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":1861938,"Management And General Expenses":347173,"Fundraising Expenses":300520}},"Assets":{"value":12953903,"Non-interest bearing cash":466455,"Savings and temp cash investments":100707,"Pledges and grants receivable":34600,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":213430,"Land, building, equipment":79628,"Investments publicly traded":10199974,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":1859109},"Liabilities":{"value":2068514,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":46635,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":2021879},"Fund balance":{"value":10885389,"Net assets without donor restriction":10120235,"Net assets with donor restriction":765154,"Unrestricted net assets":0,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.7419170387997279,"percentile":0.5662350060016272},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":10.447647411154,"percentile":0.41270376162757766},"Operating Margin":{"score":0.2610643180564135,"percentile":0.8091701128196892},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.15968268405282948,"percentile":0.2765863612751195},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":5.161676357998447,"percentile":0.8110521296480236},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.308955778757913,"percentile":0.17880371000030768},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.015694562724363398,"percentile":0.38649666966866353},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.004011417542602842,"percentile":0.3875797170710648},"Asset Growth":{"score":0.08257267298809849,"percentile":0.6362338291147847},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.5885282373845198,"percentile":0.5716864088210843}},"source_xml":"202313149349302311_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["ANDREW S REIN","MARIA DOULIS","DENISE RICHARDSON","ANA CHAMPENY","DAVID J FREIDFEL","WALTER L HARRIS","Michael J Kuh","MARISSA SHORENSTEIN","JAKE ELGHANAYAN","DAVID A JAVDAN","MELISSA BURCH","EDWARD WALLACE","LAWRENCE B BUTTENWIESER","ALAIR A TOWSEND","WILLIAM FLOYD","KENNETH D GIBBS","EDWARD SKYLER","H DALE HEMMERDINGER","ROBERT HOGLUND","LAWRENCE HUNTINGTON","MERRYL H TISCH","EUGENE J KEILIN","RICHARD LEVINE","JAMES L LIPSCOMB","KENT HITESHEW","RICHARD RAVITCH","RENEE BOICOURT","CASWELL HOLLOWAY","RICHARD ROBERTS","ANTHONY MANNARINO","CAROL E ROSENTHAL"],"Title":["PRESIDENT","VICE PRESIDENT","VICE PRESIDENT OF RESEARCH","DIRECTOR OF CITY STUDIES","DIRECTOR OF STATE STUDIES","CHAIR","Vice Chair","Vice Chair","VICE CHAIR","TREASURER","SECRETARY","TRUSTEE - GENERAL COUNSEL","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","Trustee","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE"],"Hours":[40.0,40.0,40.0,40.0,40.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0],"Total Compensation":[277374,189930,165387,156656,137171,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Direct compensation":[259174,177350,145474,121178,127870,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"Other compensation":[18200,12580,19913,35478,9301,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"The citizens budget commission is a not-for-profit organization devoted to influencing constructive change in the finances and services of new york city and state governments.","year":2020,"name":"CITIZENS BUDGET COMMISSION INC","phone":2122792605,"website":"WWW.CBCNY.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"ANDREW REIN","year_formation":1932,"state_legal_domicile":"NY","total_volunteers":0,"tax_period_begin":"2020-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2020-12-31T00:00:00","address":"240 WEST 35TH STREET Suite STE 302, NEW YORK, NY, 10001, USA","city":"NEW YORK","state":"NY","country":"USA","zip_code":10001},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":26,"Number of independent voting members":26,"Number of employees total":18,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":18,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":2137642,"Contributions":{"value":1904698,"Other contributions":1038029,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":866669,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":232944,"Investment income total":159057,"Net investment gain":73887,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":0,"Other total":0,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":2458008,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":1714670,"Current officers":277374,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":1182523,"Pension plan contributions":59088,"Other employee benefits":93163,"Payroll taxes":102522},"Other expenses":{"value":743338,"Management services":0,"Legal":0,"Accounting":45480,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":252062,"Advertising":35419,"Office expenses":4453,"Information technology":34586,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":284265,"Travel":4978,"Conferences and meetings":2424,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":50828,"Insurance":0,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":28843,"POSTAGE":1835,"MAINTENANCE SERVICE CONTRACTS":1928,"PRINTING AND REPRODUCTION":9965,"MISCELLANEOUS":15115},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":2023821,"Management And General Expenses":232174,"Fundraising Expenses":202013}},"Assets":{"value":10073726,"Non-interest bearing cash":179303,"Savings and temp cash investments":195717,"Pledges and grants receivable":41650,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":130776,"Land, building, equipment":102400,"Investments publicly traded":9397726,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":26154},"Liabilities":{"value":172188,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":58860,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":113328},"Fund balance":{"value":9901538,"Net assets without donor restriction":9476193,"Net assets with donor restriction":425345,"Unrestricted net assets":0,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.8233581827235713,"percentile":0.6556068893847727},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":9.428591229277323,"percentile":0.38101396221379286},"Operating Margin":{"score":-0.14986887420812278,"percentile":0.18113575393866196},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.017092781757216746,"percentile":0.4677752186459926},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":4.098329216178303,"percentile":0.7730896866958662},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.3769385616320207,"percentile":0.12824321004597208},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.036894737301543676,"percentile":0.4786414064769439},"Revenue Growth":{"score":-0.014333043537611804,"percentile":0.3148793160744947},"Asset Growth":{"score":0.06996629041946584,"percentile":0.5976339755194182},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.5200988191013267,"percentile":0.3737369717479641}},"source_xml":"202113169349303871_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["Kenneth D Gibbs","Walter L Harris","Calvin A Mitchell III","Merryl h Tisch","Alair A Townsend","Edward Wallace","Anthony Mannarino","Brian T Horey","Les Bluestone","Robinson Markel","Frances Milberg","Denise Richardson","David R Greenbaum","David Javdan","Claudia Wagner","DAVID S WINTER","Lawrence Buttenwieser","H Dale Hemmerdinger","Lawrence S Huntington","Eugene J Keilin","Richard A Levine","James L Lipscomb","Richard Ravitch","Ronald G Weiner","CAROL KELLERMAN","ELIZABETH LYNAM"],"Title":["CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","Vice-Chair","Treasurer","General Counsel","Secretary","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","Trustee","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","Trustee","PRESIDENT","DEPUTY RESEARCH DIRECTOR"],"Hours":[2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,40.0,40.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,230050,154296],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,211188,128293],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,18862,26003]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"The citizens budget commission is a not-for-profit organization devoted to influencing constructive change in the finances and services of new york city and state governments.","year":2013,"name":"CITIZENS BUDGET COMMISSION INC","phone":2122792605,"website":"WWW.CBCNY.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"CAROL KELLERMANN","year_formation":1932,"state_legal_domicile":"NY","total_volunteers":5,"tax_period_begin":"2013-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2013-12-31T00:00:00","address":"2 PENN PLAZA 5TH FLOOR Suite, NEW YORK, NY, 10121, USA","city":"NEW YORK","state":"NY","country":"USA","zip_code":10121},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":24,"Number of independent voting members":23,"Number of employees total":14,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":null,"Number of employees":14,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":2510339,"Contributions":{"value":2405352,"Other contributions":1502802,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":902550,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":104987,"Investment income total":104987,"Net investment gain":0,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":0,"Other total":0,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":1963204,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":1025724,"Current officers":339481,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":505478,"Pension plan contributions":49284,"Other employee benefits":70964,"Payroll taxes":60517},"Other expenses":{"value":937480,"Management services":0,"Legal":0,"Accounting":44794,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":471669,"Advertising":5348,"Office expenses":3754,"Information technology":13514,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":217389,"Travel":9443,"Conferences and meetings":118974,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":14752,"Insurance":0,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":37843,"POSTAGE AND MESSENGER":1954,"MAINTENANCE SERVICE CONTRACTS":3863,"PRINTING AND REPRODUCTION":5131,"MISCELLANEOUS":26895},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":1635809,"Management And General Expenses":176047,"Fundraising Expenses":151348}},"Assets":{"value":6074515,"Non-interest bearing cash":22520,"Savings and temp cash investments":434971,"Pledges and grants receivable":264250,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":29223,"Land, building, equipment":42488,"Investments publicly traded":5281063,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":0},"Liabilities":{"value":197504,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":118722,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":78782},"Fund balance":{"value":5877011,"Net assets without donor restriction":0,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":5082011,"Temporarily restricted net assets":795000,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.8332343454882937,"percentile":0.669084167787776},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":15.892856198958691,"percentile":0.5363965141988696},"Operating Margin":{"score":0.2179526350823534,"percentile":0.7735776071758516},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.03251354223341287,"percentile":0.4229888419669208},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":3.094184302802969,"percentile":0.7189193209167103},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.19577486598438062,"percentile":0.32115599788429766},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Revenue Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Asset Growth":{"score":null,"percentile":null},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":0.9583333333333334,"percentile":0.2714375745279776},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.6222093151929398,"percentile":0.66883336736406}},"source_xml":"201401759349300225_public.xml"},{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["EDWARD SKYLER","Michael J Kuh","MARISSA SHORENSTEIN","EDWARD WALLACE","DAVID A JAVDAN","ANTHONY MANNARINO","ALAIR A TOWSEND","LAWRENCE B BUTTENWIESER","JAKE ELGHANAYAN","WILLIAM FLOYD","KENNETH D GIBBS","WALTER L HARRIS","H DALE HEMMERDINGER","ROBERT HOGLUND","LAWRENCE HUNTINGTON","MERRYL H TISCH","EUGENE J KEILIN","RICHARD LEVINE","JAMES L LIPSCOMB","HAEDA MIHALTSES","CALVIN A MITCHELL III","RICHARD RAVITCH","RENEE BOICOURT","CASWELL HOLLOWAY","CAROL KELLERMANN","ANDREW S REIN","MARIA DOULIS","DAVID J FREIDFEL","TIMOTHY SULLIVAN","ANA CHAMPENY"],"Title":["CHAIR","Vice Chair","Vice Chair","VICE CHAIR","TREASURER","SECRETARY","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","Trustee","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","Trustee","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","PRESIDENT","PRESIDENT (EFF. 1/1/2019)","VICE PRESIDENT","DIRECTOR OF STATE STUDIES","SENIOR RESEARCH ADVISOR","DIRECTOR OF CITY STUDIES"],"Hours":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,40.0,40.0,40.0,40.0,40.0,40.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,272465,210075,173145,132665,165074,118333],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,256015,210075,161420,124000,165074,116248],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,16450,0,11725,8665,0,2085]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"The citizens budget commission is a not-for-profit organization devoted to influencing constructive change in the finances and services of new york city and state governments.","year":2018,"name":"CITIZENS BUDGET COMMISSION INC","phone":2122792605,"website":"WWW.CBCNY.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"ANDREW S REIN","year_formation":1932,"state_legal_domicile":"NY","total_volunteers":0,"tax_period_begin":"2018-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2018-12-31T00:00:00","address":"2 PENN PLAZA 5TH FLOOR, NEW YORK, NY, 10121, USA","city":"NEW YORK","state":"NY","country":"USA","zip_code":10121},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":26,"Number of independent voting members":25,"Number of employees total":14,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":19316,"Number of employees":14,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":3147314,"Contributions":{"value":3074022,"Other contributions":1473875,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":1600147,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":73292,"Investment income total":156707,"Net investment gain":-83415,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":0,"Other total":0,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":3011350,"Grant expense":{"value":30297,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":30297,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":0,"Fundraising professional":0,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":1937743,"Current officers":482540,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":1221570,"Pension plan contributions":50992,"Other employee benefits":82541,"Payroll taxes":100100},"Other expenses":{"value":1043310,"Management services":0,"Legal":0,"Accounting":45550,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":433644,"Advertising":120860,"Office expenses":4032,"Information technology":21067,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":294900,"Travel":17861,"Conferences and meetings":10765,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":52588,"Insurance":0,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":42043,"POSTAGE":2930,"MAINTENANCE SERVICE CONTRACTS":3915,"PRINTING AND REPRODUCTION":12332,"MISCELLANEOUS":22866},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":2532700,"Management And General Expenses":311237,"Fundraising Expenses":167413}},"Assets":{"value":8157645,"Non-interest bearing cash":41662,"Savings and temp cash investments":702372,"Pledges and grants receivable":48025,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":58332,"Land, building, equipment":6235,"Investments publicly traded":7186701,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":114318},"Liabilities":{"value":119284,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":96605,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":22679},"Fund balance":{"value":8038361,"Net assets without donor restriction":0,"Net assets with donor restriction":0,"Unrestricted net assets":6935141,"Temporarily restricted net assets":1103220,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.8410513557042523,"percentile":0.6800796323298398},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":18.361907378757923,"percentile":0.5754960891784443},"Operating Margin":{"score":0.04320001118413987,"percentile":0.5095419936784126},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.014622357310228627,"percentile":0.4772832672110489},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":2.7089660783369585,"percentile":0.6899079049823382},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.3559058229697644,"percentile":0.1419840423687466},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.08224546258932758,"percentile":0.6335890029228767},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.02377248957087405,"percentile":0.48376710002740875},"Asset Growth":{"score":0.05938054464311807,"percentile":0.5615380280568696},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":0.9615384615384616,"percentile":0.27286591873331767},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.568697360788829,"percentile":0.5128843130616195}},"source_xml":"201943159349300914_public.xml"}],"Latest":{"Organization":{"value":null,"Person":["MARISSA SHORENSTEIN","JAKE ELGHANAYAN","WILLIAM FLOYD","CAROL ROSENTHAL","EDWARD WALLACE","MERRYL H TISCH","ROBERT HOGLUND","ELAINE BRENNAN","PAULA DAGEN","KENT HITESHEW","SHARI HYMAN","DAVID A JAVDAN","ANTHONY MANNARINO","RICHARD ROBERTS","SALLY ROCKER","ALAIR TOWNSEND","ANDREW S REIN","ANA B CHAMPENY","PATRICK ORECKI","MICHAEL P VAUGHN","SEAN T CAMPION","KEVIN MEDINA"],"Title":["CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","VICE CHAIR","GENERAL COUNSEL","SECRETARY","TREASURER","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","TRUSTEE","PRESIDENT","VICE PRESIDENT FOR RESEARCH","DIRECTOR OF STATE STUDIES","VICE PRESIDENT FOR COMMUNICATIONS & STRATEGY","DIRECTOR OF HOUSING AND ECONOMIC STUDIES","DIRECTOR OF OPERATIONS"],"Hours":[1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,40.0,40.0,40.0,40.0,40.0,1.0],"Total Compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,349548,249039,167222,126708,150281,116026],"Direct compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,328548,200955,144171,119313,140334,108816],"Other compensation":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,21000,48084,23051,7395,9947,7210]},"Basic":{"value":null,"mission":"To influence constructive change in the finances and services of new york city and state governments.","year":2024,"name":"CITIZENS BUDGET COMMISSION INC","phone":2122792605,"website":"WWW.CBCNY.ORG","type":"990","affiliation":null,"foreign_countries":null,"principal_officer":"ANDREW S REIN","year_formation":1932,"state_legal_domicile":"NY","total_volunteers":0,"tax_period_begin":"2024-01-01T00:00:00","tax_period_end":"2024-12-31T00:00:00","address":"240 WEST 35TH STREET SUITE 302, NEW YORK, NY, 10001, USA","city":"NEW YORK","state":"NY","country":"USA","zip_code":10001},"Governance":{"value":null,"501c3 determination":true,"501c determination":false,"Number of voting members":16,"Number of independent voting members":16,"Number of employees total":18,"Total Gross UBI":0,"Net unrelated business taxable income":0,"Number of employees":18,"Prohibited tax shelter transactions":true,"Taxable party notification":true,"Funds to pay premiums":true,"Premiums Paid":true,"Family or business relationship":true,"Delegation of management duties":true,"Conflict of interest policy":true,"Whistle blower policy":true,"Compensation process for CEO":true,"Compensation process for other employees":true,"Changes to organizing documents":true,"Material diversion or misuse":true,"Members or stockholders":true,"Election of board members":true,"Decisions subject to approval":true,"Minutes of governing body":true,"Local chapters":true,"Form 990 provided to governing body":true,"Document retention policy":true,"Investment in joint venture":true,"Independent audit financial statements":true,"Consolidated audit financial statements":true,"Accountant compile or review":true,"Political activities":true,"Donor advised funds":true,"Conservation easements":true,"Collections of art":true,"School":true,"Hospital":true,"Foreign activities":true,"Foreign office":true,"Gaming":true,"Fundraising activities":true,"Professional fundraising":true,"Loan to officer or DQP":true,"Grant to related person":true,"Business relationship through family member":true,"Business relationship with organization":true},"Revenues":{"value":3918802,"Contributions":{"value":3000480,"Other contributions":1337052,"Contributions from gifts and grants":0,"Fundraising revenue":1663428,"Dues":0,"Campaigns":0,"Grant revenue":0,"Related organizations":0},"Program revenue":{"value":0,"Total revenue":0,"Total other revenue":0,"Unrelated business revenue":0},"Investment income":{"value":913293,"Investment income total":383376,"Net investment gain":529917,"Income from invest bond proceeds":0},"Other revenues":{"value":5029,"Other total":5029,"Royalties revenue":0,"Net rental income":0,"Net income from fundraising events":0,"Net income from gaming":0,"Net income":0,"Gross profit from sales of inventory":0,"Gain from sale of assets":0}},"Expenses":{"value":3101789,"Grant expense":{"value":0,"Grants to domestic orgs":0,"Grants to domestic individuals":0,"Grants and similar":0,"Foreign grants":0},"Total professional fundraising expense":{"value":4000,"Fundraising professional":4000,"Fees to independent contractors":0},"Benefits paid to members":{"value":0,"Benefits paid to members Total":0},"Salaries":{"value":2088904,"Current officers":349548,"Disqualified persons":0,"Other salaries and wages":1432407,"Pension plan contributions":50388,"Other employee benefits":124243,"Payroll taxes":132318},"Other expenses":{"value":1008885,"Management services":0,"Legal":0,"Accounting":111164,"Lobbying services":0,"Investment management fees":0,"Other services":352041,"Advertising":16501,"Office expenses":5961,"Information technology":51092,"Royalties":0,"Occupancy":304469,"Travel":7525,"Conferences and meetings":103143,"Interest":0,"Payments to affiliates":0,"Depreciation and depletion":11182,"Insurance":12413,"Travel entertainment public officials":0,"Travel entertainment payments":0,"Printing, publications, postage":0,"Itemized Expenses":{"value":33394,"MISCELLANEOUS":16826,"PRINTING/REPRODUCTION":8213,"RECRUITMENT":5554,"MAINTENANCE CONTRACTS":2801},"All other expenses":0},"Functional Expenses":{"value":null,"Program Service Expenses":2201556,"Management And General Expenses":461030,"Fundraising Expenses":439203}},"Assets":{"value":15626012,"Non-interest bearing cash":515628,"Savings and temp cash investments":16847,"Pledges and grants receivable":26000,"Accounts receivable":0,"Receivables from officers":0,"Receivables from disqual persons":0,"Other net note and loans":0,"Inventories for sale or use":0,"Prepaid expenses deferred charges":206550,"Land, building, equipment":55909,"Investments publicly traded":13438473,"Investments other":0,"Investments program related":0,"Intangible assets":0,"Other assets":1366605},"Liabilities":{"value":1644422,"Sum of Total Liabilities":0,"Accounts payable, accrued":95403,"Grants payable":0,"Deferred, revenue":0,"Tax exempt bond liabilities":0,"Escrow account liability":0,"Loans from officers, directors":0,"Secured mortgages and notes payable":0,"Unsecured notes loans payable":0,"Other liabilities":1549019},"Fund balance":{"value":13981590,"Net assets without donor restriction":13203565,"Net assets with donor restriction":778025,"Unrestricted net assets":0,"Temporarily restricted net assets":0,"Permanently restricted net assets":0},"Ratings":{"Program Expense Ratio":{"score":0.7097697490061381,"percentile":0.5431218934529899},"Fundraising Efficiency":{"score":6.831647324813355,"percentile":0.28500274098331696},"Operating Margin":{"score":0.20848539936439758,"percentile":0.7646703605432513},"Liabilities to Assets Ratio":{"score":0.10523619206231251,"percentile":0.32050851887721576},"Operating Reserve Ratio":{"score":5.037741767734684,"percentile":0.8073322354387674},"Officer Compensation Ratio":{"score":0.37359859100667386,"percentile":0.13030616635417894},"Program Expense Growth":{"score":0.016536170612083734,"percentile":0.39001423306406763},"Revenue Growth":{"score":0.0228882441934886,"percentile":0.4793646207526574},"Asset Growth":{"score":0.08936669330516663,"percentile":0.6554046495666878},"Independent Voting Board Pct":{"score":1.0,"percentile":0.9933392423419786},"Governance Policy Score":{"score":6.0,"percentile":1.0},"Overall Score":{"score":0.5715432199854673,"percentile":0.5214924536780483}},"source_xml":"202532939349301103_public.xml"},"sector":"Public, Societal Benefit","donation_categories":[],"zakat_policy":null},"error":null}